3 ms·
Is there some particular reason why this would not pass peer review in some low level journal? Are the statistics off? Or is the data fabricated? Because it wil
by tappio 7y ago
Is there some particular reason why this would not pass peer review in some low level journal? Are the statistics off? Or is the data fabricated? Because it will be published and it will pass the peer review if it satisfies those basic conditions. Peer review just means that someone else read the paper and judged whether the content seems reasonable. I don't think it is productive to call an article bogus because it is not peer reviewed. The judgement should be based on content.