8 ms·
Right, because no one has stepped up to write a check. Hospitals are businesses, they're not going to do this on their own. GM is a business, they're not dona
by ajross 7y ago
Right, because no one has stepped up to write a check. Hospitals are businesses, they're not going to do this on their own. GM is a business, they're not donating those ventilators, they're trying to make a sale into a new market. States, most of them, can't do it because their budgets are fixed by their constitutions and they can't take a loan or write a bond without a referendum.
There's basically one entity in this country with the ability to actually make this happen, and the people trying to point out that it isn't doing anything useful are fighting downvotes here just to be dark enough to read.
- yellow_lead 7y agoDon't states have emergency budgets that become available during state of emergency?
- ajross 7y agoIn some cases, it's complicated, yada yada. I'm certainly no expert on state-level budgeting in the US. In the case of NY specifically, I know it's been reported that Cuomo specifically asked the federal government for help getting ventilators and was rebuffed.
- kevingadd 7y agoYes and no, some states are constantly on the border of being insolvent. California has a big 'rainy day fund' but this recession is projected to eat into a significant chunk of it. The way hospitals are funded and administered may make it tricky for a state to buy a bunch of ventilators with state funds and then donate them to a hospital... if you "lend" them then after the crisis the state owns a bunch of used ventilators it needs to offload.
- ethbro 7y agoSo mothball them the same way the military does equipment. We don't have a shortage of land in this country.
- jschwartzi 7y agoBecause the equipment requires very sensitive measurements on the order of tenths of cmH2O and tenth of a milliliter of air, a very small leak in any one of the seals can cause a significant inaccuracy in ventilation and especially in the alarms which govern whether the equipment isn’t overinflating your lungs. This isn’t like a car where you can just start it up periodically to keep seals lubricanted. You need to maintain them or to have a plan for how you’ll check them before putting them into service. And you need biomedical technicians who are trained to repair them and clean them. If you mothball the equipment there is a very real danger that without re-qualifying the equipment it will kill or injure patients. The biggest effect GMs announcement seems to have had is convincing people that a car company that builds to PSI tolerances can build anything to the kind of tolerance needed to safely ventilate patients. I think this is a PR move and GM and Tesla will study the problem enough internally to determine they have no idea what they’re doing. Worst case we get ventilators from Tesla with the same manufacturing defects and quality issues which their cars have had. I personally would not feel safe on a Tesla or GM ventilator built without FDA oversight.
- ethbro 7y agoAbsolutely on requalification. IYHO, would that be more or less time that manufacturing fully new units?
- jacquesm 7y agoWhoever thought that running your healthcare system in a commercial fashion was the right idea in the first place? A lot of fundamental decisions are going to be re-thought in the aftermath of this virus' impact, but for now we can ignore all that and focus on what matters: eradicating the thing. And if GM making ventilators on a war footing is what it takes I'm all for it, let's divert some of those funds to them and give the hospitals what they need.
- ajross 7y agoTo be clear: I'm certainly not opposed the idea of air-dropping GM-manufactured ventilators to needy hospitals (though I'll admit I don't see how it's ever going to work in time and genuinely think this sounds like marketing on GMs part more than a serious idea). I'm just saying that the person that needs to get off their ass and move on these ideas isn't Mary Barra but Donald Trump (and McConnell and Pelosi of course).
- jacquesm 7y agoYou need to start thinking of this as a logistics problem, not a tech problem. Ventilators is a solved problem. What is needed is a stream of parts and manufacturing capability. I'm not sure if car manufacturers are the right partners but they do have a lot of people that know how to put stuff together. They can put an assembly line for ventilators together; get a stream of parts going and start manufacturing long before we reach the peak of this epidemic. Their workers are not going to be doing anything else so let's let them have their shot. Meanwhile, other companies could start on parts manufacturing. Some design should be chosen; standardized and then we need to start moving. Everywhere. Ditto portable ICU units, negative pressure environments and training for people to help others during this epidemic. If not many more more lives will be lost.
- iosjunkie 7y agoLet’s throw masks and other PPE onto your list as well.
- 8note 7y agothe people that are most likely to need the ventilators aren't exactly hospitals' profit centres either. are those businesses really going to want to fill all their space with Medicare patients? with fewer ventilators, I imagine they can decline care to more people?
- onion2k 7y agoRight, because no one has stepped up to write a check. If only billionaire Elon Musk knew someone who could pay.
- ggreer 7y agoAlmost all of his wealth is the value of the companies he runs. He's so cash-poor that he couldn't even pay a $75k fine.[1] 1. https://observer.com/2019/10/elon-musk-british-diver-lawsuit-pedo-guy-court-finding/ https://observer.com/2019/10/elon-musk-british-diver-lawsuit...
- koheripbal 7y agoLet's not exaggerate. His companies are public - he has quick access to hundreds of millions in cash.
- jpindar 7y agoAs of last night, Musk does not believe there is a shortage. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1240486275892662273 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1240486275892662273