7 ms·
Jury Nullification Advocate Faces Indictment
- thailandstartup 16y agoThere's a jury that i'd like to be on!
- monochromatic 16y agoI was pretty much on his side until this: > Mr. Heicklen has sued the government and various hospitals to which he was taken after being issued citations and falling to the ground. He sued the hospitals? What did they do wrong?
- thailandstartup 16y agoMore info here . . . http://tyrannyfighters.com/progress-report-2010-12-20/ http://tyrannyfighters.com/progress-report-2010-12-20/ The purpose of the hospital visits is to perform what is euphemistically referred to as extraordinary rendition. In each incident, the hospitals, ambulance personnel and the police knew that I had no medical problem. The hospitals are in collusion with the police to perform torture. At the hospitals, I have been sodomized, had a plug driven up my left nostril (extremely painful), had my corneas “dusted” with a brush, beaten black and blue on my chest, and forcefully injected with thorazine on two occasions against my expressed wishes. Two days after one of these hospital visits, I saw my physician, who looked at my chest and exclaimed: “Did the police do that to you?” I answered: “No, it was not the police. It was the hospital personnel.”
- isleyaardvark 16y agoIn the NYT article it sounds like he intentionally collapsed and then they took him to the hospital. From the above link it sounds like the police just took him to the hospital because they wanted to. "I have been arrested 9 times. The proper procedure for police is to take the arrestee to a magistrate. This happened twice. On 7 occasions, I was taken to hospitals (3 times to NY Downtown Hospital, 3 times to Bellevue Medical Center, and once to Saint Vincent Catholic Hospital)." I can't help but think of the recent case of the NYPD who was forcefully admitted to a psych ward because he was a whistleblower.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoIn this most recent incident, at least, he was cooperating with police (who entered his home with an arrest warrant) until they refused to provide their names and badge numbers. At that time he dropped to the floor and refused to speak. He didn't actively resist their arrest, but did refuse to cooperate in any way. I believe that taking the "suspect" to the hospital in this case is putatively for his own safety, just in case the reason he's unresponsive is that he's having a seizure or some other medical issue. But from Julian case, it appears that sometimes this is treated as an invitation to "soften him up". (fwiw, I've never met Julian, but I've communicated with him by email and get regular updates on his work)
- thailandstartup 16y agoYou can see his technique here - http://tyrannyfighters.com/category/announcement/page/3/ http://tyrannyfighters.com/category/announcement/page/3/ Whatever about the law on what he was doing, they was clearly wrong to be harassing the videographer, and DHS appear to have paid out $5000 in settlement. http://blogofbile.com/2010/10/18/settlement-with-department-of-homeland-security-reached/ http://blogofbile.com/2010/10/18/settlement-with-department-... I'm not sure its a good idea that they can hand out tax-payer money to avoid judgement against them for their illegal acts.
- ezy 16y agoOk, is there any direct evidence of this? Let's just say that I've seen this type of crusading before, and that formal, yet highly aggressive letter doesn't really assuage my suspicious feelings about the man and his motives... or, I suspect, the judges feelings. :-)
- lukifer 16y agoThe Streisand Effect in action: by literally turning the issue into a federal case, the prosecutors are guaranteeing that more Americans will learn about the concept of jury nullification than from merely handing out pamphlets on the street. I wouldn't be surprised if he intended to provoke the case all along.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoThis is certainly true. In past events, Julian has notified the media that something interesting might happen. (And the police have harassed his friends who have photographed and filmed these events, going as far as arresting them and confiscating their cameras, as I recall) (fwiw, I've never met Julian, but I've communicated with him by email and get regular updates on his work)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ajays 16y agoI was for him till I read this: In one recent letter to the court, he said he wanted Muslims “excluded from the jury” because he was Jewish and “Islam preaches death to Jews.” Now he comes off as some old racist, cranky dude. [Edit: I still do think what he's doing is admirable and very noteworthy. I was just saying that that single quote makes it easy for people to dismiss him and why he's doing what he's doing.]
- CWuestefeld 16y agoJulian is cranky, and I've occasionally disagreed with some of the details of his claims. But that doesn't invalidate the core truth of what he's fighting for.
- rorrr 16y agoRacist? Which race is he against?
- ajays 16y agoYou're right. I guess there's no comparable word for someone who's biased against followers of a particular religion, as there is one for someone who's biased against a race. So I used 'racist' as a proxy. Does my use of that word somehow take away from the point?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- burgerbrain 16y agoConsider the following. If I were an atheist on trial for what I considered to be a freedom of expression issue, would I be out of line to call for self-pronounced Southern Baptists to be removed from the jury? If a citizen on trial has concerns that the jury of their peers might not be as disinterested as initially assumed, they have an obligation to voice their concerns. And I think we all dislike sweeping generalizations, but lets be honest here. Lawyers make far more offensive generalizations during jury selection as standard practice.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoIn other jury nullification news: A judge in Florida has moved beyond merely forbidding the act of jury nullification in his courtroom. He's also banning advocates from letting anyone know about it. http://reason.com/blog/2011/02/08/judge-orders-prior-restraint-o http://reason.com/blog/2011/02/08/judge-orders-prior-restrai...
- afhof 16y agoI would have to disagree with this mans views that jurors should ignore the law if they disagree with it. I appeal to the Categorical Imperative on this one which states that you should only act by moral rules that you can at the same time apply to be universal moral laws. If every juror could ignore the law then there would be no point to having a law; it would be a contradiction. Instead he should be trying to change laws he disagrees with. [EDIT]: grammar.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoThis logic is incorrect; you could apply the same argument anywhere in our government: to the Legislature for failing to see what the Courts deem that the Constitution says; to the Courts for finding that the Legislature is wrong; to the Executive, for not enforcing the laws as intended, etc. The whole point of our system is one of checks and balances: when part of the system gets out of line, it can still be corrected elsewhere in the system. This is exactly what jury nullification does. When the government's laws get out of hand, when they're not listening to the populace (both of which apply today, I would submit), the People have final veto power, on a case-by-case basis, through the jury system. Indeed, this is precisely why the Constitution guarantees the right to a jury trial: otherwise, we could just have a computer keep score. It beats the next chance for citizens to put a check on the government, by using the 2nd Amendment.
- nooneelse 16y agoQuite right in the main. However, there are several other chances for a citizen check between jury nullification and guns. Peaceful protest for instance. Nonviolent, civil disobedience for another.
- CWuestefeld 16y agothere are several other chances for a citizen check between jury nullification and guns. I don't think so. It's true in the sense of escalation of severity. But in the "between" sense of chronology, we're past peaceful protest and civil disobedience. You're effectively writing off those who are today being convicted of unjust laws, hoping that things will be better tomorrow, but not considering the plight of those who are wronged today. From the perspective of someone whose morals are based on natural rights (which, I think, includes the founding fathers), the status quo is such that morally-innocent people are being imprisoned and having their rights taken away in other ways, right now. Since the force the State is using to do this is founded on its citizens, I am in essence committing the crime of taking away the rights of these innocents. It is therefore morally incumbent upon me to write this wrong. Asking the government nicely to stop being evil hasn't worked, and these innocents are still suffering. It's therefore each citizen's responsibility (under this moral code) to free these innocents.
- drstrangevibes 16y agoa jury has more power in deciding a case than a judge, the sad fact is that all too often juries are bullied into believing that they cant exercise this power by the judge and advocates. it can never be a crime to inform people of thier rights
- drstrangevibes 16y agoDespite heavy pressure from the Lord Mayor to convict Penn, the jury returned a verdict of "not guilty". When invited by the judge to reconsider their verdict and to select a new foreman, they refused and were sent to a cell over several nights to mull over their decision. The Lord Mayor then told the jury, "You shall go together and bring in another verdict, or you shall starve", and not only had Penn sent to jail in loathsome Newgate Prison (on a charge of contempt of court), but the full jury followed him, and they were additionally fined the equivalent of a year’s wages each.[52][53] The members of the jury, fighting their case from prison in what became known as Bushel's Case, managed to win the right for all English juries to be free from the control of judges.[54] This case was one of the more important trials that shaped the future concept of American freedom (see jury nullification)[55] and was a victory for the use of the writ of habeas corpus as a means of freeing those unlawfully detained.
- chloraphil 16y agosource?
- sharth 16y agoNot a direct source of his quote, but it's the topic in question. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bushels_Case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bushels_Case
- burgerbrain 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bushel%27s_Case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bushel%27s_Case
- tzs 16y ago“I don’t want them to nullify the murder laws,” he said. “I’m a big law-and-order guy when it comes to real crime.” But, he said, there were other laws he wanted to nullify, like drug and gambling laws. You can't get one without the other. There is no murderer that some don't consider unjustly prosecuted. For instance there are a lot of people that would use nullification if told about it when trying someone accused of killing an abortion doctor. Worse, once you tell a jury they can judge the law you will get juries that go for anti-nullification--that is, they will convict the defendant even though they do not believe he broke the law. In this case at least the judge or an appeals court can reverse the conviction...if they can tell it happened. In many cases they won't be able to tell. In most cases, the prosecution alleges a set of facts that if true support conviction, and the defense alleges that those facts are not true. There is no way in general for the judge or the appeals court to distinguish between "jury believed prosecutor's alleged facts and so convicted" and "jury believed defendant's view of facts but convicted anyway". Another problem is different outcomes for similar defendants. If 5-6% of people think that a particular law should not have passed, and a unanimous jury of 12 is required for conviction, then 50% of guilty defendants get a jury that will not convict. It's really hard to design a system of checks and balances where you tell juries about nullification but somehow stop the bad outcomes I described above. The best anyone has been able to come up with is to not tell the jury about it. The idea then is that it is only applied in cases where some juror decides that his conscious would find convicting so wrong that he must violate his oath.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoYou can't get one without the other. I don't think you're reading his comment correctly: > "I don’t want them to nullify the murder laws," he said. I read this to say that he doesn't want it to happen, i.e., he hopes that it will not. He never says that such an outcome ought to be forbidden, just that it's not desired.
- cabalamat 16y ago> It's really hard to design a system of checks and balances where you tell juries about nullification but somehow stop the bad outcomes I described above. The best anyone has been able to come up with is to not tell the jury about it. Given that the internet exists, how do you propose to keep jurors ignorant of it?
- miles 16y agoAs John Adams said, “It is not only his right but also his duty... to find the verdict according to his own best understanding, judgment, and conscience, though in direct opposition to the direction of the court.” More recently, the following decisions have upheld jury nullification: The jury has an “unreviewable and irreversible power ... to acquit in disregard of the instructions on the law given by the trial judge. The pages of history shine upon instances of the jury's exercise of its prerogative to disregard uncontradicted evidence and instructions of the judge. Most often commended are the 18th century acquittal of Peter Zenger of seditious libel, on the plea of Andrew Hamilton, and the 19th century acquittals in prosecutions under the fugitive slave law." - U.S. vs Dougherty, 473 F 2d 1113, 1139 (1972) "If the jury feels that the law under which the defendant is accused, is unjust, or that exigent circumstances justified the actions of the accused, or for any reason which appeals to their logic of passion, the jury has the power to acquit, and the courts must abide by that decision." - U.S. vs Moylan, 417 F 2d 1002, 1006 (1969) And finally, from two of America’s Founding Fathers: "... you [juries] have a right to take it upon yourselves to determine the law as well as the fact in controversy." - John Jay, First Chief Justice of the United States Supreme Court "The jury has the Right to judge both the law and the facts." - Samuel Chase, Supreme Court Justice and signer of the Declaration of Independence See also: http://fija.org/ http://fija.org/ http://www.greenmac.com/eagle/ISSUES/ISSUE23-9/07JuryNullification.html http://www.greenmac.com/eagle/ISSUES/ISSUE23-9/07JuryNullifi...
- gnosis 16y ago"In reality, FIJA's origins and orientation are extremist, built (like most Patriot schemes) on long-rejected legal theories and dubious "facts." Now, there have been exceptional rulings in which jury nullification can be seen ipso facto as beneficial (particularly in some of the recent drug-war cases), and these cases are cited readily by FIJA adherents. However, these cases have no more force of law in modern courts than does the Dred Scot decision (though that ruling too is cited on more than a few occasions by FIJA adherents). That system is predicated upon the admonition that juries must rule on evidence and the law, pure and simple, and they take oaths to uphold that standard. Their failure to do so in fact breaks the law. The legal powers that nullification proponents would hand to juries violates the careful balance of powers that exists within the system. If juries are deciding the justness of the laws, they are assuming powers traditionally relegated to the judiciary and, in other contexts, to the legislative branch. There is nothing in any body of law that would allow them to do this, other than the pure absence of an outright prohibition -- which actually exists in the form of the jurors’ oaths. ... It is likely that the bulk of nullification proponents -- including, probably, Mark Paschall, though his notions about placing God's laws before man's are common among both Identity followers and Christian Reconstructionists -- have no idea whose agenda they’re being used for. But then, most people are oblivious to the elements in our society that would like to see it all fall apart, and are doing their damnedest to make it happen." http://dneiwert.blogspot.com/2003/10/spreading-extremism.html http://dneiwert.blogspot.com/2003/10/spreading-extremism.htm...
- svlla 16y agoI think of this as the difference between power and authority. juries have the power to reach any verdict they want, but rightly or wrongly the legal system tells them they only have the authority to reach verdicts according to certain rules. everything seems structured in favor of getting juries that forget they have the power to reach any verdict they want, again for better or worse... funny that legal systems spend so much time justifying to themselves what is legitimate even when it results in absurd, unjust conclusions... legal systems don't want laypeople muddying the waters of their absurdities.