5 ms·
> If society were to collapse I don’t think anyone would be hoarding gold or silver But people have hoarded gold and silver to successfully preserve value over
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> If society were to collapse I don’t think anyone would be hoarding gold or silver
But people have hoarded gold and silver to successfully preserve value over the collapse of countless societies and civilisations for many thousands of years.
Why do you think our society and the one following it would be any different?
> I find owning large amounts of gold to be a silly proposition
I literally can't think of any more reliable, safe, enduring preserve of value across all of our existence.
If you dig up one of their hoards in a farmers' field today the value of the savings of a Roman from two thousand years ago are preserved to this day.
Can hardly describe it as silly?
- thorwasdfasdf 7y ago>> "But people have hoarded gold and silver to successfully preserve value over the collapse of countless societies and civilisations for many thousands of years." In 5000 years from now, I wonder if people will say the same thing about BitCoin.
- war1025 7y agoA quick search shows a post from this week titled "Bitcoin drops 50% in epic two day tumble", so somehow I doubt it. As others have said, Bitcoin is a very shallow market. It is "worth" a lot in principle, but good luck trying to convert it to cash.
- kylebenzle 7y agolocal.bitcoin.com Its easy to convert to cash in any major city.
- nostrademons 7y agoPresumably, if it gets to the point where you need a safe-haven store of value, you won't be converting it to cash. You'd be transferring it directly to the recipient in exchange for food, shelter, or weapons.
- owenmarshall 7y agoI think if you’re to the point of liquidating assets for “food, shelter, or weapons”, I would prefer a few Krugerrands that fit in my pocket. How can Bitcoin beat them in terms of durability and wide acceptance?
- snowwrestler 7y ago5,000 years from now Bitcoin will the name for a category of physical relics surrounded by myths of hidden wealth, if only they could be unlocked. A loose network of hobbyists, cultists, and oddballs will trade in old digital wallets, external hard drives, and servers, and the occult pseudo-mathematical techniques they employ to try to unlock the encryption to see what's inside. Legend has it that it would take beyond the end of the universe to succeed... but legends have been wrong before.
- adaisadais 7y agoBecause for millenniums society had a gold standard on some level. Currently, the U.S. does not and most other nations do not either. Why would we revert to something that is held in extreme scarcity? Will we revert to slavery if we were to have a societal collapse? Absolutely not. Hypothetical: It's 2021 and a massive earthquake has cause a massive tsunami that has ravaged most of the cities along the Pacific. Shortly after your nation is invaded and a war breaks out. No one has power, food, or water. After a long war with many lives lost and lots of destruction do you seriously think people would care about gold or try and use it as serious form of a new nation's currency?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Will we revert to slavery if we were to have a societal collapse? Absolutely not. Not sure why you're so certain about that - societies have abolished slavery only for it to come back in subsequent societies before. Concrete example - India under the Maurya Empire, only for it to come back in medieval times. > After a long war with many lives lost and lots of destruction do you seriously think people would care about gold or try and use it as serious form of a new nation's currency? Yes, because it's happened again and again and again and again and again across countless apocalypses.
- dragontamer 7y ago> But people have hoarded gold and silver to successfully preserve value over the collapse of countless societies and civilisations for many thousands of years. Ignoring the time from 1933 to 1971 when it was literally illegal to own more than a few ounces of gold.
- chrisseaton 7y agoDo you think nobody hoarded gold during this period? I'm sure they did. And did it retain its value? Yes.