5 ms·
So, what’s the difference between a “wet market” and the sort of familiar farmer’s market of butchers/fishmongers/etc. that five-star restaurants source from al
by derefr 7y ago
So, what’s the difference between a “wet market” and the sort of familiar farmer’s market of butchers/fishmongers/etc. that five-star restaurants source from all over the world?
This article seems to be doing a motte-and-bailey of grossing you out with things that are just “regular meat wholesaler things” (e.g. fresh meat sitting out on ice without refrigeration) and then moralizing about the specific kinds of meats available in certain markets in China.
As far as I can tell, the author really just wants to tell Chinese people to stop eating certain meats (pragmatically, bush meats; but also, less pragmatically, whatever a Westerner would find gauche, like endangered species or things we’d consider pets), but doesn’t want to come out and say what they really mean; and so instead tries to seem like they’re making a point about sanitation. In so doing, they end up arguing against the existence of wholesale meat markets in general, which is clearly silly: meat wholesaling happens all over the world every day and is perfectly sanitary, despite seeming to a layman like it’d be unsanitary. (It is unsanitary in some ways, but in general principle—which can certainly be violated, like any other standard can—it’s always exactly as sanitary as it needs to be for any given use-case. Meats that are cooked get treated with less care; meats that are served raw are treated with more.)
This sort of reminds me of the parable of the new owner who came into a bakery and demanded it be cleaned because everything was greasy. The bakers kindly informed them that the grease was intentionally put on every surface, right after cleaning; and that, in fact, grease is used to clean some surfaces. Some systems function perfectly well in ways that seem disturbing to outsiders. If the bakers have been greasing the bakery for thousands of years, and you’ve never gotten sick from a loaf of bread, then maybe think a moment before telling the bakers to stop greasing the bakery.
Certainly, if you buy a loaf of bread and it turns out to have a bunch of thumbtacks in it, there’s a problem. But not one, I would suspect, endemic to the concept of bakeries.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y ago> So, what’s the difference between a “wet market” and the sort of familiar farmer’s market 1) The wet market is full of live animals in close proximity and very unsanitary conditions. So pathogens are more likely to still be alive, and can jump between diverse hosts, not just to humans. 2) The wet market is full of non-domesticated, exotic animals which carry pathogens humans are not acquainted to.
- derefr 7y agoRe 1: you’re probably picturing your local butcher shop. Don’t. Picture a pier in a coastal town. The lobsters? Alive. The oysters? Alive. In close proximity? Certainly. Sitting right beside a bunch of gutted fish and processed chum? Yup. That’s a wet market. You can’t name one thing going on in Wuhan that doesn’t happen on such a pier. Even the general approach of “whatever we catch, we sell” is the same. And yet, nobody gets sick from that. Food poisoning in your sushi or your raw oysters, every time it’s been followed up, has turned out to be from the source (farming in bad conditions) or from transport (shipping hundreds of miles in non-refrigerated trucks), not from cross-contamination at a market. Thus my point: clearly, some markets keep generating diseases; but if they’re doing the same thing as the markets that don’t generate diseases, then it’s likely not wet markets as a process for distributing food that are the problem here. Because some of them—almost all of them, in fact—work just fine. (Analogy: are “restaurants” a vector for disease? Not in general, no. Specific ones, certainly. But not as a concept. Something additional has to be going on.) So, if you eliminate the process itself, what’s left? The inventory and its sourcing; the people and their own personal hygiene; and a few other things. In any case much less tasteful topics to argue about. Which is why people would prefer that this not be about those things, and instead be some endemic issue to meat markets.
- woah 7y agoI haven't read the article, but it seems much more likely that a virus be able to jump from a mammal to a human than a mollusk to a human
- tlb 7y agoThe risk to human health from gutted mammals is much higher than from lobsters, because viruses are more often compatible between more closely related species. A reasonable restriction would be on wet markets for mammals, excepting a few where the safety properties are well known like cows.
- kleer001 7y ago> That’s a wet market. No it's not. You're off by two orders of magnitude of number of different and wild species. That's THE key. The variation and combinations of vicera and species. "...live wolf pups, golden cicadas, scorpions, bamboo rats, squirrels, foxes, civets, hedgehogs (probably porcupines), salamanders, turtles and crocodiles. In addition, it offered assorted parts of some animals, such as crocodile tail, belly, tongue and intestines...." from https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/jan/24/calls-for-global-ban-wild-animal-markets-amid-coronavirus-outbreak https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/jan/24/calls-for-gl...
- dx87 7y agoIf the bakers are greasing the bakery and causing deadly pandemics every 5-10 years, maybe the system isn't functioning perfectly well.
- jonny_eh 7y agoHere's a great explainer video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPpoJGYlW54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPpoJGYlW54
- misiti3780 7y agoThis video explains the difference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=98&v=TPpoJGYlW54&feature=emb_title https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=98&v=TPpoJGYlW54... Wet markets should be banned because they contain endangered species and the vendors are committing horrible animal rights abuses, oh and they are responsible for multiple corona viruses too.
- kccqzy 7y ago> So, what’s the difference between a “wet market” and the sort of familiar farmer’s market of butchers/fishmongers/etc. that five-star restaurants source from all over the world? That's exactly the question I have. How are these Chinese markets fundamentally different from, say, the Japanese Tsukiji fish market? Taking a look at pictures like https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vendors_begin_selling_their_fish_at_4am_at_the_Tsukiji_fish_market.jpg https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vendors_begin_sell... it doesn't strike me as very much different from the Chinese wet markets.
- ricefield 7y agoThose animals are dead
- tathougies 7y agoIn a wet market, animals are alive: https://www.businessinsider.com/wuhan-coronavirus-chinese-wet-market-photos-2020-1#reports-indicate-that-before-the-huanan-market-closed-vendors-there-sold-seafood-meat-and-live-animals-including-chickens-donkeys-sheep-pigs-foxes-badgers-bamboo-rats-hedgehogs-and-snakes-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/wuhan-coronavirus-chinese-we...
- burkaman 7y agoJust to address that specific example, Tsukiji closed a year and a half ago and relocated to Toyosu, which looks like this: https://asianinspirations.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/00_Toyosu_FeatImg01-940x627.jpg https://asianinspirations.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/...
- kleer001 7y agoThe key is number of different living species, let alone genuses and families of animals.
- IndrekR 7y ago> This sort of reminds me of the parable of the new owner who came into a bakery and demanded it be cleaned because everything was greasy. You are probably refering to Making Wrong Code Look Wrong by Joel Spolsky: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2005/05/11/making-wrong-code-look-wrong/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2005/05/11/making-wrong-code-...
- philwelch 7y agoThe relevant differences, to my view, are the ones that allowed a pandemic coronavirus to jump from the Chinese bat population to the global human population over the course of just a few months. The specific details are a question for experts in the field, but something clearly went wrong here and it's important for the sake of the entire world to make sure it doesn't go wrong again.
- unbendable 7y agoH5N1, SARS and COVID-19 have been traced back to asian wet markets. Seeing the effects COVID-19 has I really don't care what cultural or emotional reason you could have for those markets. Just BAN everything that could ever allow this. The thought that we knew it could happen AND that it already happened blows my mind.
- pinkfoot 7y ago> Just BAN everything that could ever allow this. How?