3 ms·
So why are different ethnicities of humans not considered sub-species? They developed in different geographic regions with barriers, the can interbreed success
by phkahler 7y ago
So why are different ethnicities of humans not considered sub-species?
They developed in different geographic regions with barriers, the can interbreed successfully, and they have different appearances, not just in skin color, but in things like facial features. And yet the article specifically states that humans don't have subspecies.
- HelloNurse 7y agoBecause subspecies are a particularly arbitrary taxonomical division. Some of the pragmatic reasons are that human "ethnicities" are very fuzzy because people travel around, that they are only an average of arbitrary large groups of related people, and that people tend to look meaningfully similar only to their closest relatives, and only partially.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoFirst of all, calling ethnicities subspecies creates a political mess and such arguments have often been used for all kind of injustices. Secondly I'd say that the differences are very fluid and it's hard to pinpoint any hard barriers. The "European" ethnicity only developed in the past 4000 years. Migrations during all that time make the picture even more difficult.
- K0SM0S 7y agoThe fundamental reason is that genetic diversity simply doesn't warrant it. You may think we're different based on appearance; but the genetic material says otherwise. I might be genetically much closer to someone of different skin color and gender than to my closest geographical/ethnic/cultural neighbor who looks just like me, in terms of DNA variation. Human beings altogether are not diverse at all genetically compared to most animal species. And if we were to use said differences to classify "races" among the human species, you can be absolutely sure skin color wouldn't correlate, nor would eye or hair color. For better candidates, look at the HLA system for an idea of more relevant classification method (this one defines immuno-regulation profiles among us, and has been shown to drive sexual attraction towards opposites, hypothetically because it favors enhanced, combined immunity in the offspring). But even taking such systems into account, human beings are really far from meeting any common threshold of differenciation worth being called "race" in the animal realm.
- Talanes 7y agoBecause there have always been people trading and traveling, and getting it on as they do so. People retained enough genetic connectivity to not have any massive genetic divergence. Some cosmetic differences and slightly different disease risks are not enough to make a subspecies.