10 ms·
The Mac Minis are still expensive and underwhelming (even when maxed out) when compared with the top of the range NUCs with even AMD GPUs. The Skull and Ghost C
by rvz 7y ago
The Mac Minis are still expensive and underwhelming (even when maxed out) when compared with the top of the range NUCs with even AMD GPUs. The Skull and Ghost Canyon NUCs are great for Linux CIs or building large projects or I could even go far to either Hackintosh a few NUCs to surpass the need to buy a Mac Mini anyway for next 5 years.
Thanks, but I would skip this Mac Mini and go for the latest maxed out NUC instead.
- gorgoiler 7y agoTrue, but a more charitable take is that the high price goes to subsidize macOS development. Having just moved to a Windows 10 shop running on cheapest-possible Dell hotdesking workstations, I’m starting to miss macOS and all its command-spacebar glory!
- asveikau 7y agoBut people often speculative that macOS development is on the back burner these days. Release to release they have not seemed to add much of use in a long time. They keep introducing new limitations on apps and deprecating stuff. That has questionable utility if your goal is to get work done. Of course Windows 10 is also in bad shape.
- emsy 7y agoTry pressing the windows key (granted, it's not as pretty as Spotlight).
- bradstewart 7y agoThis is honestly the thing I miss most while using macOS. The windows key search always seemed to work better than Spotlight.
- dep_b 7y agoI don't know what you like about it? When I use Windows I try to use it to find Control Panels to set up stuff and it does a horrible job at that. In macOS you'll find Disk Utility by typing "disk utility" in CMD+SPACE, even when you're on a different language system that has it's own name. I couldn't find anything in Windows even when that was the literal name of the panel. And hunting for formerly easy to find settings is one of the things that already drives me crazy in Windows 10. Also when I type "alert sound" I still find the Sound and Notifications Control Panels even if they're not full matches, but they do deal with alerts. There's a lot about Windows I like though. It's just not the UX, apart from the Explorer once I exactly set it up as I like it (well it looks the same as Windows 95 mostly).
- bradstewart 7y agoI generally have the opposite experience you've described--I can find exactly what I need in settings/Control Panel on Windows, but rarely on macOS. Could be that I'm just used to the names of things in Windows? Realistically, they both get the job done.
- emsy 7y agoSpotlight is better at understanding multiple languages (accidentally typing the English name on a German System often yields the right result), synonyms and results inside windows. I think this is mainly due to Apples accessibility efforts. Windows is much more picky. But most of the time you just want to start an app anyway.
- bradstewart 7y agoThat is entirely possible. I'm in an English bubble.
- jayd16 7y agoHit the windows key and type "disk man" and the disk manager pops up. Maybe you're just used to the OSX names for things? Search "alert" brings up the audio settings. I'm not sure what you're doing differently.
- thefounder 7y agoPerhaps you should buy something more in the price range of the mac-mini to make a real comparison rather than the cheapest dell.
- striking 7y agoHave you tried http://keypirinha.com/ http://keypirinha.com/ ?
- banachtarski 7y agoHave used mac for many years. Never miss spotlight on Linux or Windows. First, you do have that functionality if you need it. Second, the spotlight indexing takes a non-trivial amount of CPU time and is honestly annoying when I need the juice to finish a render or compile code. My guess is you're just suffering from "unfamiliarity" syndrome.
- jrace 7y agoIn windows just press the windows key and then type the name off the app you want (same as command spacebar in macOS) One less button press than on a mac.
- oneplane 7y agoOnly if it works. Which often it doesn't. And by doesn't I don't mean it doesn't do it 100% correctly but I mean it doesn't find a program or file even if you type the whole name completely. It just gives no result at all for some terms.
- Juliate 7y agoAre Hackintosh a practical reality? (genuine question)
- PedroBatista 7y agoIn the last couple years, yes. But Apple has been playing the long game and tightening the noose in order to pull the rug on all Hackintoshs one day.
- mantap 7y agoPeople forget that the original hackintoshes had to work around the hardware security module. Where there's a will there's a way.
- mstolpm 7y agoThey are, but I would only use one as a second device besides a real Mac. Setup and updates are relatively painless if you choose the right hardware and store additional kexts not on the system OS partition but the EFI boot partition. Biggest troubles are WIFI and Bluetooth (and therefore continuity, needs one of a few selected cards), graphics (no nVidia) and keyboard and trackpad (for desktops, use used Apple peripherals) as well as sound in some configurations (might use a Bluetooth speaker if BT works). It always can happen that you mess up (or need access to a real Mac for downloading the OS in the first place), so have a Backup and wait a few days after system updates appear, read forums about possible showstoppers and necessary precautions. That said, Catalina is still not perfect and troubles may not be caused by the hackintosh but the OS.
- reaperducer 7y agoThe Mac Minis are still expensive and underwhelming (even when maxed out) when compared with the top of the range NUCs with even AMD GPUs I've been considering getting a Mac mini, but haven't committed yet. Can you tell me which NUCs run macOS so I comparison shop?
- thirdsun 7y agoDon‘t. If you want macOS just bite the bullet and buy yourself a pretty carefree experience. If you don‘t care about the OS obviously get any of the countless affordable PC configurations.
- danieldk 7y agoMaintaining a hackintosh is a drag. You never now if an update is going to break things. You have to jump though a lot of hoops to get things like iMessage working. Moreover, you have to be prepared to use random kexts from the net. You also miss out on many security features of the Mac (T2 and their secure boot mechanism). If you want to run Linux or Windows, buy a NUC. If you want to run macOS, buy a Mac. Hardware-wise, the Mac Mini is comparatively expensive, but you also fund macOS development and will have a much better experience than any other hardware. Source: I use NUCs (currently NUC8i5BEH for Linux, plus two other around the house), a MacBook Pro, and have had Mac Minis in the past.
- endorphone 7y ago"Thanks, but I would skip this Mac Mini and go for the latest maxed out NUC instead." Neat. Of course of the actual base of buyers for this, the fact that it runs macOS is a critical requirement. Running an outdated, hacked version is not a viable consideration for most (I'm fairly certain that the "I'll run a Hackintosh" comments outnumber people actually running a Hackintosh by at least 1000:1). I don't think there has ever been an Apple release without a barrage of "Lame. No wireless. Less space than a Nomad" kind of responses. As if we are all unaware that it's a competitive space with lots of options. Yes, there are alternatives. Lots of people buy those alternatives. But it is absolutely not an orange-orange situation. As one fun aside -- I had a Mac Mini a few years ago and loved it. The power utilization of thing was absolutely bonkers tiny. It just worked 100% of the time. Bought it for like $799. Sold it after having it for I think five years for $500. The kind of bizarre ability of Apple devices to hold value is really a financial factor that many don't consider.
- StreamBright 7y agoTrue, if you ignore the difference in terms of UI/UX. For me, MacOS is the killer feature. Hard to estimate the price but still worth to buy a Mac Mini over a NUC. Hackintosh is not something I would like to waste time on.
- moondev 7y agoWhich NUC has 6 cores and 4 thunderbolt ports with integrated 10GbE? I have 3 hades canyon nucs (homelab) and also a fully maxed mini. The great thing about the mini is it's versatility for expansion via TB3, as well as allowing me to triple-boot macOS, windows, and linux with minimal effort (no hackintosh workarounds needed)
- gurkendoktor 7y agoI've been looking for Mac Mini alternatives recently, but both the Skull Canyon NUC and the HP Z2 Mini G4 had plenty of reviews complaining about fan noise, plus they require large external PSUs. The Ghost Canyon NUC isn't super cheap either. The Mac Mini really has a lot going for it.