4 ms·
> The English word "all" predates the current mathematical consensus (which isn't even universal) by thousands of years. This is at the edge of possibility, bu
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> The English word "all" predates the current mathematical consensus (which isn't even universal) by thousands of years.
This is at the edge of possibility, but it's certainly not a slam dunk. "All" is not an indo-european word; it's restricted to Germanic languages.
> Just because one has knowledge of logic (mathematics) and we happen to have given some operation the English name "all", that does not mean the English word "all" in general speech refers to this logical operation.
This isn't a good argument; all you and the article are saying is that people have vocally objected to the meaning of "all" for a long time. They still do. But this isn't sufficient to claim that the objections reflect a disagreement over the meaning of "all". If you carefully explain to people how you want them to interpret sentences like "every cat is in a box", and then you show them pictures and ask them whether or not every cat is in a box, most people will screw it up. That's not because they didn't understand you; it's because they are very bad at the task.
It is quite clear that the vernacular meaning of the English word "all" coincides with the formal meaning of the logical universal quantifier. You can poll any number of people and they'll give you a definition that just so happens to match the logical quantifier. People don't object to all([]) being true after thinking about what "all" means to them -- they object before thinking about it.
- int_19h 7y agoIf you poll people asking for a definition of "all", you're doing it wrong. Instead, you should ask them to use the word to describe various cases, and derive the actual definition from that. I doubt it'll match formal logic.