4 ms·
My wife is a university professor and is being told she needs to record lectures going forward. I'm wondering how she can easily record a lecture video and then
by gnicholas 7y ago
My wife is a university professor and is being told she needs to record lectures going forward. I'm wondering how she can easily record a lecture video and then splice in powerpoint slides later. The best I can think is to record yourself on a computer, while flipping through slides on an iPad right next to your screen. Then afterward go through and take screenshots of the Powerpoint and insert them into the video (using iMovie?). This would probably take me 30 mins for a 45 min lecture, and I'm experienced with iMovie. If there are transitions to preserve, it would take much longer.
Are there other solutions? Seems like something that Zoom should be able to do — you share your screen and video your face on a recorded session. Then afterward you can go back and choose which stream (face or screen) is used at any given point in time.
- worthless-trash 7y agoAfter having done editing, I imagine that 30 minutes is optimistic. Your best bet is to take the low-tech approach and distribute the slides seperately in pdf form.
- gnicholas 7y agoYeah, I've done work in iMovie and think it could be done without too much difficulty, so long as no animations are needed (which is not ideal, of course). Part of the reason for having slides big on the screen is that then you can have your face off-camera at times, in case you have to scratch your face or whatever. Being right in front of a high-res camera for 45 mins is not awesome...
- ghaff 7y agoEven as someone who does a lot of presenting to audiences, I find recording video of myself speaking all by myself is really awkward. I suppose it's something one can get used to but I find it very hard. My usual approach is to do a quick video introduction to humanize it and then just talk over slides.
- solresol 7y agoThat's why I do the two system thing (Workspaces for the slides, laptop for my face video). Then I don't even bother editing it afterwards unless I think there's something really important. The recording shows your face in a window because you are speaking, and the content in a big screen. You just hit the "record" button in Zoom and it works. This of course makes sense because we were operating remotely; if your wife is teaching in a lecture theatre then that's a different kind of thing. Likewise, if she is creating lectures to be viewed offline, then the cost and effort goes up, and she's now going to be spending all her spare waking hours editing video.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- moooo99 7y agoI'm not 100% sure if I understood the problem right, but maybe OBS [1] could be an easier solution. You can use it to record screens and webcam streams. You can layout "scenes" with the video sources and use it while holding to lecture to switch between webcam and screencast. It's usually used for livestreams of all kinds, but works for recording as well. With my little experience in video editing, I'd say 30-45 min for a whole lecture is very optimistic, so maybe this would be an easier solution. [1] https://obsproject.com/ https://obsproject.com/
- gnicholas 7y agoThanks for sharing this! Can you simultaneously record your screen and your face, and then later splice the two together (while keeping audio synced, preferably)? To clarify, basically the desire is to be able to sit in front of a computer, look through slides while talking to the camera, and then afterward go through and (easily) choose which segments should show the screen and which should show your face. And hopefully the audio would just auto-sync, so you don't have to fiddle with it to get the lips to line up when it's set to show your face.
- maher_au 7y agoIf you already have powerpoint, try that. Camtasia is a licenced ($300) tool, but has almost fool proof editing and post production
- moooo99 7y agoYou can't use it to record into seperate files. However, you can use it to make the necessary editing while recording the presentation. In OBS you can create Scenes with multiple video sources. The scene will be the output you see in the video file. You can add the video sources as layers into the scene, scale and move them around. So you could create a scene where the main focus is on the PowerPoint slides and the webcam is just in the corner. The other scene would be the other way around. Then, while recording, you can switch between the scenes to show the powerpoint or the webcam. This does not allow for as much flexibility in post, but it would save a lot of time since you don't have to edit the video afterwards. Also, the audio should be in sync as well.
- Angostura 7y agoI work at a large school and have been experimenting with cheap and cheerful solutions. If on Windows 10 check out the built-in Game Bar (designed your let you record games) if on Mac Qicktime will let you record the screen and mic.
- gnicholas 7y agoYeah, Quicktime does seem like a good option if just recording screen with mic audio is desired. I think that there would be some benefit to being able to see the professor at least from time to time, to make the experience more personal. But perhaps this could be accomplished just by having a small photo of the prof in the corner, by the course name or something.
- pdm55 7y agoI use screencast-o-matic, because it is so easy to use and very affordable, to make videos that I upload to Youtube. I have a dynamic microphone, Audio-Technica ATR2100-USB, which has been working well for years. https://screencast-o-matic.com/tutorial/welcome-to-screencast-o-matic https://screencast-o-matic.com/tutorial/welcome-to-screencas...
- zwayhowder 7y agoDoes Quicktime save as compressed MP4? Last time I used it for a 30 minute video it saved as uncompressed mov by default. I was not impressed, and while I know how to re-encode, most people don't.
- albertzeyer 7y agoJust use any screen recorder (e.g. QuickTime player on MacOSX can do that). And then arrange your screen in any way you want, e.g. put your slides on it, and maybe some window in the corner which shows the webcam (video of yourself).
- zmk_ 7y agoShe can use zoom to do that with the benefit of students seeing your wife. Otherwise if she is using _PowerPoint_ she can record her presentation with voice (only) in PowerPoint (slide show > record slide show)
- Vrondi 7y agoZoom can do this. When she sets up her Zoom rooms, they can be set to record automatically. Then, she can share her whole screen or just one single app she has open with her students during the session. So she can share her PowerPoint with them, but they still hear and see her video thumbnail, and then after the session is over, Zoom will process the recording for her. No need for any other software. It may take Zoom a day to process the recording, but she will eventually get a link inside Zoom she can share as needed. This is all built into Zoom. No other tools are needed.