3 ms·
As someone who does keep cash on hand, I find it frustrating when those who don't are bailed out. That said, hasn't almost every bailout the government has give
by LatteLazy 7y ago
As someone who does keep cash on hand, I find it frustrating when those who don't are bailed out. That said, hasn't almost every bailout the government has give returned a big profit? So (grants aside) isn't this just the lender of last resort seizing a good business opportunity? And as tax payers, that's good for all of us right?
If we decline, then there will be big disruption (bad for us as consumers), supply will contract unnecessarily driving up prices (bad for both consumers and taxpayers) and some private lender will make a killing selectively bailing out or investing. Sound better?
- magicsmoke 7y agoWhen the US government bails out those airlines, they're using taxpayer moneys to do so. To be fair, if this bailout does result in a return, then you could view it as a government investing its tax revenues in profitable investments, sort of like a sovereign wealth fund. However, this viewpoint requires a level of trust in the government to act as a responsible steward of its tax coffers for the betterment of its people which frankly isn't there in today's political climate. With the level of mistrust towards the US government and megacorps, any bailout seems like the elites using taxpayer money to build a safety net for themselves that the average citizen doesn't have. It ultimately isn't a problem with the numbers in the books, but with pent up discontent in the minds of the public over these past decades about how society just doesn't seem to be in their best interests anymore. If you yourself aren't helped by the government when hard times hit, why should the elites get any help, regardless of whether benefits will trickle down to you?
- LatteLazy 7y agoI think you're right about the general attitude, I just get really frustrated by it. The bailouts were help for normal people (the alternative was double digit mortgage interest rates and everyone's house being under water). And the bailouts turned a cash profit too, so right now we're all paying less tax for more services than we otherwise would. The fact people don't know these simple facts makes me wonder how much longer democracy can be made to work. People just believe whatever sounds most exciting and then vote against things that are in their (and the national) interest. What's a guy to do!?
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoSince this is becoming a recurring theme, of "too big to fail". I think, from now on, any company that is "too big to fail", should have to pay a "too big to fail" insurance tax to the government (perhaps a certain percentage of their revenue). they can't just keep getting free bail outs, without paying the insurance premium. If I opt to not get drivers insurance and then crash into someone, i can't just ask for insurance coverage after the fact.
- LatteLazy 7y agoIsn't that exactly what the bailout is? We lend them 100bn, they pay back 120bn, that's 20bn in to-big-to-fail insurance premiums...
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agowell, the premium they're paying is less than the market rate, otherwise the market would have given it to them. Hence, if they're going to get a subsidized loan, they should have to pay into that, along with everyone else that is elligble for it
- LatteLazy 7y agoThere is no market rate for this because it can only be provided by government and because these events are basically unique. The key here should be for the insurer (government) to recover a little more than their expenses in the medium term. That's a correctly priced insurance policy. That's exactly what tarp did. It's actually very impressive that the managers of the program were able to price the policy so correctly if you think about it...
- thoughtstheseus 7y agoCheck out: Systemically important financial institutions