3 ms·
> So why not just issue dividends and avoid the downsides? As another replier pointed out: dividends create a tax event if the shares are held in a taxable ac
by throw0101a 7y ago
> So why not just issue dividends and avoid the downsides?
As another replier pointed out: dividends create a tax event if the shares are held in a taxable account (in US: not IRA, not 401(k)).
Sometimes people (pensions, trusts) don't want those types of events and would rather choose when to invoke tax events by selling only when they need to for income purposes.
- AznHisoka 7y agoBut so what if it creates a taxable event? Let's put aside what is good for you in the short-term, for a second. If a company does buybacks, and even borrows money for them, it might boost their stock in the short term, but it doesn't make their company better long-term, because they aren't investing that money into R&D, and it puts them in a possible cash crunch in the future (ie airlines today). As a thought experiment, what if instead of the company buying back stock, it's the US government. What if they decide to spent $500 billion buying 10% of every stock out there, instead of giving $1000 to every American citizen b/c of the virus. The first benefits people in the short-term, and doesn't create a taxable event. The second benefits people in the long-term, but might be a taxable event.
- travisjungroth 7y agoYou're comparing buybacks to everything else. The person you were replying to was just answering why buybacks are now more popular than issuing dividends. The overwhelming reason is taxes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jsight 7y agoI think his point is that buybacks should be no more relevant than dividends. This pop-culture meme that "dividends are irrelevant" is not unique to dividends at all.
- colinmhayes 7y agoCompanies exist to create value for shareholders. That is done via dividends or buybacks. If companies do neither and aren't in a growth stage like amazon was investors would get pissed and there would probably be a hostile takeover. Shareholders prefer buybacks because of the tax advantage.
- throw0101a 7y ago> That is done via dividends or buybacks. Nope, dividends (and buybacks) are irrelevant: only total return matters: * https://www.pwlcapital.com/the-irrelevance-of-dividends-still-a-non-starter/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/the-irrelevance-of-dividends-stil...
- colinmhayes 7y agoThe amount the company pay shareholders, and what people believe the company will pay shareholders, is what defines a companies price. If the a company never pays dividends or does buybacks its value will plummet. It's idiotic to say well dividends and buybacks are irrelevant: only total return matters because future dividends and buybacks are the only factors that play into total return.
- throw0101a 7y ago> If the a company never pays dividends or does buybacks its value will plummet. AAPL went public in December 1980. It paid dividends from 1987 to 1995. It then restarted in 2012. Steve Jobs returns to Apple in 1997. Somehow I see AAPL rising in value during its non-dividend paying years. AMZN when public in May 1997, and has never paid a dividend. AMZN has done some share buybacks in its history, but has not since 2012. Somehow I see AMZN rising in value. See also the history MSFT: somehow it has had a good total return despite not doing buybacks or dividends for most of its existence. There is no explanatory power in dividends or buybacks when it comes to stock returns: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factor_investing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factor_investing * https://www.pwlcapital.com/the-irrelevance-of-dividends-still-a-non-starter/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/the-irrelevance-of-dividends-stil...
- throw0101a 7y ago> If a company does buybacks, [...] because they aren't investing that money into R&D [...] False choice: a company can do R&D and do buybacks (or dividends). The capital return is for excess cash that has no internal use. AAPL spent US$ 4.2B (7.9% of revenues) on R&D and had a dividend. Sometimes there's a limit to how much you can do: companies have a finite number of employees after all, and there are only a finite number of projects that you may be able to handle at one time.
- amiga_500 7y agoThey should remove that "choice" from them and make them pay their taxes on dividends.
- throw0101a 7y agoWhen a share buyback occurs the seller creates a taxable event for themselves through capital gains. It's just buybacks are considered 'better' because the event is the choice of the seller, and occurs when it is for them. A dividend is 'thrust' upon a shareholder whether they want it or not. (And not investing in dividend-paying companies can be a non-starter: the company in question may be quality one that is worth owning (regardless of dividends, or buybacks)). The problem is not buybacks or dividends: it is (a) possible executive chicanery, and (b) a lot of the general public not having the means / spare cash to get their foot in the door in investing.
- amiga_500 7y agoHow many people are reeling from dividend taxable events, and do we really need to look after them? Can't they just plan ahead? I'd bin buybacks and let these guys plan ahead.
- throw0101a 7y agoHard to know: pensions, trusts (private or for foundations), you indirectly by holding an index fund (the fund handles it on your behalf, but it can still create a drag on returns).