7 ms·
High corporate debt isn't caused by buybacks, it's caused by low interest rates. Low interest rates cause buybacks because it becomes more attractive to raise c
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
High corporate debt isn't caused by buybacks, it's caused by low interest rates. Low interest rates cause buybacks because it becomes more attractive to raise capital through borrowing than selling shares.
It's the same reason both consumer and government debt are also high. But anybody who thinks now is the time for higher interest rates is a bit confused.
If anything now is the time to print a bunch of new money to counteract the existing deflationary forces caused by the coronavirus, which in the long term is what allows interest rates to rise, since once the deflationary forces wane the printed money would start to cause inflation which could be counteracted by at that point raising interest rates.
- magicnubs 7y ago> now is the time to print a bunch of new money I'm curious as to whether the money would ever make it into the hands of the average consumer (which is where I'm assuming it needs to go to actually cause an increase in inflation, considering how consumption-heavy our GDP is, but correct me if I'm wrong!) There have been recent calls for the government to distribute money to prop up demand, but won't banks lobby politically against this sort of activity? Seems like a lender wouldn't want inflation to actually increase because that would cause their current lower-interest loans to be less valuable? One of the oft-cited concerns for continually missing our 2% symmetric inflation target is that market participants will begin to expect and plan for low inflation, which has a negative feedback effect on future inflation. Seems to me like financial institutions are already expecting low inflation and aren't all that interested in seeing it rise.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt isn't really mortgage banks that lose out from inflation. The money banks loan you is created from nothing as a fiction inside their computers and destroyed again when you pay it back. The only money that continues to exist is the interest you paid them, which they get to keep. Low inflation kind of sucks for banks (and investors in general) because it tends to coincide with low interest rates. When interest rates are low, people borrow money and invest it, which reduces real returns by increasing competition to buy securities. The people who dislike inflation (really, higher interest rates) are the people doing all the borrowing.
- nrdvana 7y ago> The money banks loan you is created from nothing as a fiction inside their computers and destroyed again when you pay it back. The only money that continues to exist is the interest you paid them, which they get to keep. Care to cite a link for this? My understanding is that the money they loan you is physical and real, but the money “held” for savers is a fiction that could be lost if the bank went under, thus the reason that the federal government offers FDIC insurance for money deposited in banks, and why the feds are allowed to dictate interest rates and tell banks what overall percentage of their holdings they are allowed to loan out.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 7y agohttps://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-banks-dont-need-your-money-make-loans.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-b... Banks (like everybody) use double entry accounting. When they make a loan, there are two entries. One is a credit to your account for the amount of the loan, the other is a debit representing the debt you now owe to the bank. You borrowed $5000, so you owe the bank $5000 (the loan) and they owe you $5000 (it's in your checking account), which cancel out. Notice that the amount of cash in their vault hasn't changed at all. Banks have reserve ratios. They're required to keep a certain amount of their deposits on hand in case somebody actually wants to withdraw them. (Those just got set to zero, but they're normally something like 10%.) But as long as they've satisfied their reserve requirements, they create money from nothing when they make a loan. When you pay back the loan, the debt of the loan and the credit in your deposit account cancel each other out again, they both disappear and the money that was created is destroyed along with your debt.
- nrdvana 7y agoSo I think your description is in agreement with mine, but I consider the first action of the borrower to be withdrawing the money and giving it to e.g. someone selling a house. If the person selling the house uses the same bank, then yes the bank really did just create the money for the loan, but if it wasn’t the same bank then I consider them to have created money for the previous investors while handing out the real money to a borrower. Mostly a matter of perception I guess.
- tathougies 7y ago> I'm curious as to whether the money would ever make it into the hands of the average consumer (which is where I'm assuming it needs to go to actually cause an increase in inflation, considering how consumption-heavy our GDP is, but correct me if I'm wrong!) If you listen to white house press conferences, Sec Mnuchin said that he and the president of the united states would like to see direct cash payments to Americans in the next two weeks.
- HenryBemis 7y agoYes of course, he/they want to "make it rain". Printing money will reduce the value of USD, but people would be filled by the cash-at-hand. In the long run that doesn't help. It may help to win elections though.
- nerdponx 7y agoKnocking $1000 off a student loan or mortgage is a nontrivial benefit.
- tathougies 7y ago> Printing money will reduce the value of USD That's really good. The fed has been trying to spur inflation to hit their 3% inflation target for many many years now. However thanks to the great economy, we haven't seen that. Printing money would sure help create much needed inflation.
- airstrike 7y ago> Seems like a lender wouldn't want inflation to actually increase because that would cause their current lower-interest loans to be less valuable? If the alternative is -10% GDP growth in Q2 2020 and God knows what later in the year, a little inflation won't kill banks
- nerdponx 7y agoIsn't this precisely the objective of Keynesian-style fiscal stimulus? Put money in people's hands by literally paying them. It doesn't have to be UBI either. The USA is desperately behind on infrastructure investment. In New York alone, we could use this opportunity to: build high-speed rail between NYC and Albany, rebuild the decaying Amtrak bridge in the Bronx, extend the NYC Subway with the Triboro Line, rebuild the Amtrak tunnels under the Hudson, heavily renovate NYCHA housing, invest in downtown beautification projects across the state, overhaul the Rochester bus system, etc etc.
- bhl 7y agoBanks have more to lose from a decline in economic activity with higher-interest, commercial loans being defaulted on, than from slightly above average inflation if that ever occurs. In my opinion, it's more important to focus on the factors causing inflation, rather than using inflation-as-a-metric by itself; e.g. banks would benefit from economic growth which leads to inflation.
- bawana 7y ago^THIS. The system of lowering interest rates and 'printing money' only helps banks. Back in the day, banks made money by lending money and that WAS their job. The whole Keynesian move to 'pump money into the economy' was to encourage banks to loan money so businesses and houses could get loans.TODAY, since the repeal of Glass Steagall and other regs, banks are make their money by speculating and financial engineering. The larger public is out of the circuit (or at best only a small, ignorable part). There are essentially two economies- the one where the financial sector operates and the real one where people work. The financial sector trades trillions every day-orders of magnitude more than the flesh, blood, sweat and tears of humanity on this planet. When interest rates are falling and especially when the fall is perceived to be accelerating, the speculative instruments of the financial sector start to fail because the conditions on which their profits are predicated have changed. To prevent the collapse of these modern day robber barons, we have to pump money into the system- The government does this through the Fed who purchase bonds that are created to underwrite the financial sector. What we need is a way for the Govt to get money into the hands of the people who will spend it on real stuff that will stimulate our factories and housing industry. Although helicopter money is a phrase I hear more frequently, the method of execution so that it doesnt appear as an entitlement is obscure. Personally, I think the Fed should print money with a half life. This 'Fed coin' should be issued to every taxpayer and the value of that bequest should gradually fade away until it is spent. At which point it enters the economy and it's value is fixed.
- baq 7y agoPrinting money if it can’t be used to buy stuff is a recipe for inflation and we’re in that kind of a situation: it’s a serious supply-demand shock, not some financial wizardry gone wrong. Supply got stretched or severed last month and now demand is crashing while supply is coming back online. It’s a disaster which can’t be mitigated by cheap money and is the reason why rates might need to be raised - too much money available and no use for it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoPeople can still buy stuff, and moreover they need to -- even if you're staying home you still need to eat and pay rent and utilities. But now people are concerned with how long this will last, which makes them want to conserve. Naturally this is deflationary -- people place a higher value on holding currency than buying stuff because they're not sure if they'll need savings soon -- so you need an inflationary force to counteract it. Printing money and giving it to people does exactly that. You put more money in their pockets and they're less reserved about spending it, and then fewer people lose their jobs. You don't even get the inflation until later, because all it's doing now is counteracting the deflation we would have otherwise. And later the inflation can be addressed by raising interest rates.
- LeoTinnitus 7y agoThat was the same logic in 2008 yet we're there again. What's preventing hyperinflation at this point?
- Bombthecat 7y agoNothing, i think it's impossible to avoid it anymore.
- kamarg 7y agoMy understanding of it is that we basically outsourced our inflation from the 2008 QE rounds to other countries. This seems to be a feature of being the reserve currency of the world. Presumably that would be the same thing that prevents hyperinflation this time around.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> What's preventing hyperinflation at this point? Crashing money velocity and vanishing credit. Inflation is a function of money supply and money velocity. Money supply is central bank money plus private money (e.g. checking account deposits) plus credit. Demand destruction, like what we're seeing now, causes money velocity to plummet. That affects lending, which causes credit to plummet. (If we got into a credit crisis, it would cause private money to plummet.) The increase in central bank money simply paled, even in 2008, compared to the destruction of credit and reduction of money velocity. As such, we actually experienced deflation while the central-bank money supply expanded. Because the total money supply, relative to the economy, contracted.
- throw0101a 7y ago> What's preventing hyperinflation at this point? To get technical: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_lower_bound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_lower_bound * https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/07/opinion/the-case-for-permanent-stimulus-wonkish.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/07/opinion/the-case-for-perm... * https://archive.is/Z2TMK https://archive.is/Z2TMK
- wefarrell 7y agoTanking commodities prices.
- Bombthecat 7y agoHyper inflation here we come!
- dpc_pw 7y ago> If anything now is the time to print a bunch of new money to counteract the existing deflationary forces caused by the coronavirus It's time to let everyone reckless go bankrupt, and idiots who "could not see this coming" lose their money and jobs. The business etc. will go bankrupt, restructured and purchased by people who know how to preserve the capital. The reason why this keeps happening is because of moral hazard. We keep rescuing reckless behavior at all levels of society. Until there's no way to rescue anything, or the rescue package is going to kill the dollar due to its size.
- vikramkr 7y agoNobody could have seen this one coming. People thought a recession is coming soon, but not like this, where the economy is basically shut down to prevent transmission of a pandemic. Hopefully people have insurance to protect against some of this, but a restaurant owner that didn't plan for their community being shut down by a pandemic within a couple weeks of the first cases in town hitting the news wasn't being reckless
- daxorid 7y agoNobody saw the Japanese coming in 1941, either. And yet, millions of Americans sacrificed, liquidated their businesses or shifted them to a war materiel production footing, changed jobs, bought war bonds, etc. Tens of thousands of diners and clothiers closed their doors in 1942, and Americans were largely happy to do it for the greater good. This is precisely the opposite of what is occurring now - demands of bailouts, monetization, handouts, 50+ person St. Patrick's Day parties still going, bitching about having to learn how to cook, etc. A complete and total unwillingness to accept even a modicum of pain or sacrifice.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoWasn't there a bunch of huge government intervention during WW2? Businesses shifted to materiel production because they were told the have to, no? So it seems fair that people are demanding leadership now too, no?
- supercanuck 7y agoWhat is the point of going into debt to buy your own stock? The economics are no different than a shop keeper getting a loan at .05% to pay himself. the actual action in and of itself makes no sense from a business perspective. The action basically is, a company doesn't have any good investments or R&D or whatever to invest in, so i'm going to return money to shareholders to do that ...but am going to take on debt to do that...because of dat phat interest rate doh??
- jcranmer 7y agoYou can write the loan interest off your taxes.
- supercanuck 7y ago*financial engineering
- bsamuels 7y agoIf you think the value of your company is going to increase faster than the 0.05% interest on a loan from a bank, you should buy the stock then sell it again later when it has appreciated. Another important detail is that you only have so much stock you can issue. When you pay back a big wad of debt, you can take out some more debt. When you issue stock, that stock is basically gone unless you buy it back.
- supercanuck 7y agoHas nothing to do with value of the company. A share buyback results in an increase in share price because it reduces the number of shares of the company to buy. All things being equal. McKinsey advertises as much https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/the-value-of-share-buybacks https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-cor...
- zby 7y agoThe question was not what buyback causes - but why a company would do a buyback - and the answer was correct. If you expect that your company will be valued $1.1 (in total) next year and the current price is $1 and the rates are much lower than 0.1 - then it makes sense to borrow money and buy the shares. The company management, because of insider info, might be in a better position than the general market to evaluate if the hypothesis that the company market cap will be $1.1. They cannot use that info for trading in their own accounts - but they can do that in the company name. This might be perfectly rational.
- tom-thistime 7y agoThe article is from Jan 7 2020. I think most people (e.g. the Fed) agree with you that the macro situation has changed.