4 ms·
It is interesting to think about how such a counterproductive attitude could develop. I imagine that the Party saw a problem, suppressed some people who were im
by whatshisface 7y ago
It is interesting to think about how such a counterproductive attitude could develop. I imagine that the Party saw a problem, suppressed some people who were impacted by it, and saw the problem go away (at least for them). The they saw another problem, suppressed some people, and saw that problem go away too. After doing this for several decades, their default reflex upon seeing a problem was to suppress whoever was complaining about it. This strategy worked for small problems that would stay about the same size over time, because they could tell the sufferers to suck it up and at most a few people would become discontent. Eventually the strategy became a habit, and the habit became an integral cultural component of their way of governing.
Then, one day, they saw a problem, suppressed some people... and discovered that the small problem would not stay small and suppressible after all.
- kangnkodos 7y agoThis is pure speculation without one spec of proof: My guess is that the regional government covered up the problem. But once the national disease authorities learned of the issue, they did the right thing because of their experience with diseases over the last decade. I can't see the whole article. It might have some information which supports or refutes my guess. --- Edit. From the full article: "on January 3, the National Health Commission, China’s top medical authority, issued its own gagging orders"
- whatshisface 7y agoIt is not really possible for outsiders to tell how orders are being moved around within the party mechanism. China's message is that the regional government is at fault, but that's what they always say when there is an expression of discontent among their people. It is not "kosher" for the central government to take the blame for anything, so you can never really believe it when someone else takes the blame. Maybe the CIA knows, but anyone who isn't tapping internal communications is not likely to get beyond speculation. In any case, a culture of honesty has to start at the top, and it is likely that the local government "knew what not to report." There are many situations where the claim that no official report was given to the central government would be true, while at the same time the central government played a role in the suppression. So as for speculation, I would say that there are many possibilities where the central government had a role to play in the suppression (even if it was played over years before), but only one possibility where the local authority went off and did something totally out of line. Edit: >The laboratory findings were relayed to officials in Beijing at the Centre for Disease Control (CDC). The information should have alerted national health chiefs to a looming crisis, but on January 3, the National Health Commission, China’s top medical authority, issued its own gagging orders. Laboratories were told not to release any information and to hand over or destroy the samples. Well, it looks like the local government didn't know what not to report after all. (Thanks to makomk's comment for pointing this out.)
- petre 7y agoA fish rots from the head down after all.
- makomk 7y agoAccording to the article, this came from the top: the national medical authorities were directly telling the labs to destroy the samples and keep it a secret.
- rapphil 7y agoThis behavior reminds me of what happened with the Chernobyl power plant.
- petre 7y agoThe fall of the USSR is attributed in part to the Chernobyl accident in Mikhail Gorbachev's memoirs. I'm not saying the CCP's days are numbered, but maybe, just maybe they will live in interesting times.
- whatshisface 7y agoOf course their days are numbered, no regime lasts forever.
- gdubs 7y agoMidway through HBO’s Chernobyl it struck me: this was the start of the fall of the USSR. I guess that’s obvious, but the dominant narrative growing up was that the US outspent them militarily and it bankrupted them. But it was so eloquently shown in the miniseries that it was really about the facade coming down — the illusion of the all-knowing regime crumbling into that vast, hellish pit at the center of the reactor.
- petre 7y agoYou could watch Adam Curtis' HyperNormalisation documentary for further insight into this. It's about the current political elite but comoares the current situation with the one in the USSR before the fall of the Iron Curtain.
- dathinab 7y agoAnother think the US likes to look at differently: US: Marchal plan was self-less help. Reality: Marchal plan was mostly self-help, preventing a economical collaps of the US and securing strong longterm influence in the EU/Germany to make sure the EU/Germany won't side with communism in the future. Also allowing them "secure/safe/accepted" military presence in the EU/Germany "just on the border to their enemy". Etc. (Don't get me wrong. It was still awesome and I'm still grateful. Just don't go around stating the EU/Germany owns the USA and should do thinks which would harm itself to support the USA, especially given that currently the US is slightly falling from grace.).
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoYou are spot on. Now realize that all you read about china in the press, is created by this strategy. The green turn around, everything. And our press copys blindly from state media news outlets and organizations that have been corrupted with soft power. Meanwhile on the ground, the world begs to differ. The west aint perfect either (Julian Assange, Snowden), but at least dissent is able to reach the ears of the public, before beeing silenced. And the government wishful thinking aloud is discussed as the foolishness it is.
- billfruit 7y agoThere seems to be much misinformation, as per one translation of sources, the Chinese CDC only asked that the samples which are kept in unsecured conditions/facilities be destroyed.
- whatshisface 7y agoThe way things work in governments around the world, that detail doesn't really tell us anything. The interpretation of "unsecured condition/facility" would be completely up to what the local government thought the central government was implying.
- billfruit 7y agoOTOH preventing unsecured facilities from holding such samples seems a valid thing to do. The point the being the highly charged political divide on this issue makes it impossible to trust sources on either side of this and similar matters.
- whatshisface 7y agoWell, we do know that the local government was suppressing things, because both sides claim that.