3 ms·
To the author (if you're reading this): please image those disks ASAP and take scans of the manuals, and upload the whole thing to Internet Archive Software Col
by zozbot234 7y ago
To the author (if you're reading this): please image those disks ASAP and take scans of the manuals, and upload the whole thing to Internet Archive Software Collections, C64 and C128 sections. IA is literally an archive, so they are expressly allowed to store this content for the benefit of allowed users, even when copyright law would prevent most people from doing this on their own.
- sterwill 7y agoCan you explain how an organization that calls itself an archive gets treated differently than another organization under US law? I'm not aware of any exemptions for archival.
- homarp 7y agothey don't, per https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360014759692-Rights https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360014759692-Righ... what they will do though is keep it in their archive and a) put it online waiting for some entites to complain. b) if someone does complain and it's a valid complain, the content will be 'offlined', but still avail in their archive. The day it becomes 'legal', they'll put it back online. for old software, cf what they are doing for the Apple 2, where flux images of the disks are archived https://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary_apple_woz https://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary_apple_woz Old manuals are scanned too https://archive.org/details/savetz_stacks https://archive.org/details/savetz_stacks
- sterwill 7y agoThanks for the links. I'm a big fan of the Internet Archive. I browse their content regularly for fun, and have even contributed one old (1990s!) piece of software.
- bane 7y agoThe savetz_stacks are by Kevin Savetz, one of the hosts of the ANTIC Atari 8-bit podcast, which has had hundreds of incredible interviews with people from across the 8-bit computing industry. Totally worth listening to.
- zozbot234 7y agoSection 108 of U.S. copyright law has relatively broad exceptions for libraries and archives. Note that this is strictly about preservation, not making the content available to the general public (per sibling comment). However, preservation also enables worthwhile things like formal academic research, etc. that in turn gets broad exemptions due to fair use.
- sterwill 7y agoThanks, I wasn't familiar with section 108. The restrictions look pretty tight on redistribution, though. I guess it all comes down to who the "allowed users" are in your original comment as to whether they're compliant.
- erickhill 7y agoHey there! If you go to the article and read directly below the original post, I walk through the challenges and tribulations I went through in merely trying to copy the disks. After nearly a day of experiments, I did succeed in making copies. However my process of creating d64 files fails. I use what's called a ZoomFloppy. This device allows me to connect an ancient Commodore disk drive and see the files on a PC. Thus, I can move individual files over to the PC, or create entire disk images. Conversely, I can create new floppy disks the same way from d64 (or d71/d81) files I find online. But due to this program's unusual track numbering, the disk image fails. This is why it took me so long to figure out how to copy the disk, too. In any case, I do believe there is a way, but it is a project I'll likely be attempting in the future as it's more involved.