3 ms·
Thunderbolt smokes USB, FireWire with 10Gbps throughput
- dreamux 16y agoI can't help but feel this is a solution without a problem.
- amock 16y agoI think there's a problem that this is trying to solve but I don't think it solves it very well. The problem I have is that it's hard to share hardware between computers. What I want is to be able to plug all of my monitors, storage, printers, mice, keyboards, etc. into a bus along with my computers and then be able to decide via software which pieces to connect. This makes the situation better because you can hook all of your peripherals together and then plug one cable into a computer to use them all. If it were a switched network instead of only allowing chaining I think this would be great, but maybe the technology for that isn't cheap enough yet.
- noelchurchill 16y agoIf it were wireless 10Gbs throughput that could be useful.
- cmer 16y agoThis definitely solves the problem of slow, inefficient external hard drives. Especially with Firewire dying. USB2 is extremely slow for today's computing if you think about it...
- fletchowns 16y agoThe transfer rates of platter hard drives, even some SSDs, is still below the speed of USB 2.0, is it not?
- cmer 16y agoDefinitely not. Firewire is MUCH faster than USB2, and it's still slower than having a drive connected directly to SATA for example... This new technology should allow external drives to be as fast as internal ones.
- jarek 16y agoNo - USB 2.0 is 80 MB/s theoretical, and you're lucky to get half of that sustained in practice. 20 MB/s is normal in my experience. Meanwhile hard drives have exceeded 100 MB/s on sequential read.
- phamilton 16y agoOne of the main problems with USB is the software implementation of it. Theoretical and practical are a wide split. Firewire is better in this regard due to the transfer protocol being done primarily in hardware. USB is designed to be more "Universal", so communication is delagated to software.
- anigbrowl 16y agoIt'll be great for pro video, but then USB 3 would be too and I have yet to own any of those devices. I hope it does better than Firewire, whose ad-hoc networking potential was never fully exploited.
- JunkDNA 16y agoWell, for laptops and mobile devices, it's a nice alternative to a docking station. Connect one wire into your monitor from your laptop. Then all your stationary stuff: external disks, Ethernet, audio, and legacy USB devices all connect through a hub on the monitor.
- alexgartrell 16y agoNow imagine how great life would be if they could also run power through it (PoE style) so you could avoid plugging the laptop [directly] into the wall as well. One plug and done is a pretty compelling reason to forgo [1] the desktop altogether. [1] fun (completely unrelated) fact: forgo and forego are both words with pretty dissimilar meanings (to omit and to precede, respectively). I discovered this only because I was unsure of the spelling, but it's sufficiently surprising (to me) that I felt the need to share.
- GHFigs 16y agoOne problem this (partially) solves is the performance gap between internal PCIe-based peripherals and external devices. USB3 and ExpressCard both top out at half the bandwidth of even a single lane PCIe 3.0 slot. If you look at the list of companies contributing blurbs to Intel's Thunderbolt page, about half of them are companies producing high-end A/V peripherals where this makes a real difference in terms of what kind of product they can offer.
- zwieback 16y ago10W power to devices downstream! What voltage does Thunderbolt run on?
- DuaineBurden 16y agoas my friend Chris Johnson said: What they don't tell you is that their claim of 10 Gbps is faster than any cutting edge SATA3 chipset can handle. They also don't tell you that Intel delayed the release of USB3 chipsets on their motherboards until Thunderbolt (Intel made it) was ready so that the marketing geniuses could tout Thunderbolt as a superior option because the advertised speeds on the shiny packaging are higher. "Corporate collusion to force the Apple lemmings to another proprietary standard" at its finest.
- bryanlarsen 16y agoLet me get this straight, have they replaced the 17Gbps displayport with a 10gbps thunderbolt port and call it an upgrade? 17Gbps fits nicely with the next upcoming standard display size: quad HD, AKA 4K, 3840x2160. It seems insane, but it's not -- it's retina display at 30" or standard monitor quality at 80". Sure, Quad HD doesn't matter now. But Thunderbolt isn't going to matter for a few years either. Sure, Thunderbolt may eventually going to scale to 100Gbps, but the baseline is now established at 10Gbps and few items will support more than it, I bet. How many HDMI ports support 2560x1600 resolution even though it's in the HDMI 1.3 spec? I don't know of any.
- radicaldreamer 16y agoDisplayPort isn't 17Gbps, it's rated between 1.62Gbps and 2.7Gbps. Just like you mention about Thunderbolt, the theorethical maximum for DisplayPort is 17Gbps, not the actual throughput for devices that are out right now. The actual throughput for the Thunderbolt port on new MacBooks is well above what the DisplayPort on the older models was.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ugh 16y agoDidn’t Intel even say that those 10Gbps are real numbers, not theoretical?
- bryanlarsen 16y agoDisplayPort handles 2560x1600 screens just fine, and that requires 6gbps, (2560 x 1600 x 24bits/pixel x 60frames/second = 6Gbps) so I'm not sure where you get your numbers from. 3 Gbps is required to handle full HD, and DisplayPort obviously handles that. Unless you're talking gigaBYTES per second. 2.7GBps is more than 17Gbps, so your numbers are even higher than mine.
- radicaldreamer 16y agoSure, but that's because you're using 4 channels to get there and it's unidirectional. Thunderbolt is 10 Gbps per channel, so actually up to 40 Gbps if there were 4 channels available (there are only 2 shipping on the MacBooks, hence the 10Gbps bi-directional rating).
- sorbus 16y agoI will withhold being impressed until I see actual benchmarks. At this point it's all marketing.