8 ms·
Time Has No Meaning at the North Pole
- jonnypotty 7y agoThe sun doesn't only rise and set once a year at the north Pole! Is this a joke? Edit: -3 for correct science. Good work HN
- hansbo 7y agoHow do you mean? When you are not moving but only rotating, how can it rise and set apart from the world rotating around the sun?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jonnypotty 7y agoGo and find out, jesus.
- klyrs 7y agohttps://www.pmel.noaa.gov/arctic-zone/gallery_np_seasons.html https://www.pmel.noaa.gov/arctic-zone/gallery_np_seasons.htm...
- mcsb4 7y ago> The sun doesn't only rise and set once a year at the north Pole! Is this a joke? > Edit: -3 for correct science. Good work HN You have to explicitly say that you are a flat earther. Otherwise people on HN assume standard science as source of knowledge. If you are not a flat earther, you might consider watching this video while closely observing the north pole: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLRA87TKXLM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLRA87TKXLM Also Stellarium is an outstanding piece of FOSS software, you can play with your position, time of day and time of year. Please dont file a bug report because the sun does only set once per year at the north pole. Stellarium is not made for flat earthers.
- nerdponx 7y agoHow does that even make sense for a flat earther? Is their explanation for the posted article is that it's part of some round earth propaganda machine?
- icemelt8 7y agolook at his username, most definitely a troll.
- jonnypotty 7y agoSorry was reading sun setting and rising as 6 months of dark and 6 of light...idiot
- Jaruzel 7y agoOne wonders, why don't they just use UTC ?
- dntbnmpls 7y agoWhat would be the offset be? Which time zone would you use when time zones are set on a longitudinal basis and all the longitudes converge at the poles?
- jwandborg 7y agoThe UTC offset would be zero if you used UTC since it's UTC.
- dntbnmpls 7y agoYes I know. But the problem isn't what the UTC is, everyone knows what it is. The problem is what the time is. What time zone does north pole belong to, aka what is the time at the north pole? A UTC value of X has many times associated with it. Given the same UTC, the time could be 3 PM in NYC and 4 AM in Tokyo the next day. Saying use the UTC without providing a offset is pretty much meaningless. Imagine if you asked me, "what time is it where you are" and I responded with the UTC. You'd have no idea what time it was where I'm at. UTC offset zero ( london ) doesn't make sense because the north pole also encompasses other longitudes and other times zones. Why not use the other time zones since they are just as equally valid or invalid as london? Logically, asking for the time at the north pole is as absurd as asking someone to point north at the north pole. It doesn't make sense. It's only when you take a step away from the north pole that you can answer "what is the time" and "which way is north". At the north pole, there is no "north" anymore and there is no "time". Saying use UTC is meaningless, but looking at the downvotes, it's abundantly clear people either don't understand what UTC is or they missed my point completely.
- excalibur 7y agoThe suggestion is that they would all agree on UTC 0 not because it's their current time zone, but just for ease of coordination. They could choose any time zone for this purpose if they all agreed on it, GMT just happens to be the most universally recognized and least biased option.
- saagarjha 7y ago> The ship is filled with 100 people from 20 countries, drifting at the mercy of the ice floe, farther from civilization than the International Space Station. That probably depends on where the ISS is, doesn't it?
- keiferski 7y agoEdit: Not sure what the orbital path of the ISS is. I suppose it would indeed depend on where it is. The question would be: where in the path is more than ±417 KM away from a city. //ignore Seems like the ISS is always closer. 400KM vs 817KM. > The ISS maintains an orbit with an average altitude of 400 kilometres (250 mi) by means of reboost manoeuvres using the engines of the Zvezda module or visiting spacecraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Space_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Space_Station > Alert, in the Qikiqtaaluk Region, Nunavut, Canada, is the northernmost permanently inhabited place in the world, at latitude 82°30'05" north, 817 kilometres (508 mi) from the North Pole. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alert,_Nunavut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alert,_Nunavut
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoBut presumably the space station passes over the middle of one ocean or another, where it is not only 400km up but also some number of hundred kilometres away laterally?
- jcranmer 7y agoThere's a lot less of that very-distant ocean than you might think. You need about 700 km of lateral distance on Earth to get 800km distant from a point 400km over the surface. Start drawing 700km bubbles from random specks of land in the ocean, and the uncovered ocean disappears quite quickly. Bermuda, the Azores, and Newfoundland conspire much of the North Atlantic between the US and Europe. Seychelles, the Maldives, and the British Indian Overseas Territories similar get a decent coverage of the eastern Indian Ocean. Random Polynesian islands also manage to provide a surprisingly good coverage of the South Pacific (almost contiguous all the way to Hawaii), although the gaps are more evident here. I don't have hard numbers here, but I'd hazard a guess that the ISS is closer to civilization about 80% of the time--not bad, considering that civilization occupies far less than 30% of the surface.
- Legogris 7y agoAnother edge-case highlighting the usefulness of global time; maybe a soft rollout of UTC at the North Pole is a good start in wait for the rest of the world to catch on?
- flohofwoe 7y agoBut what's the point of a global time when the sun rises and sets at different times across the world anyway? Humans live by the 'sun clock', not by UTC. For instance, to arrange a remote meeting you still need to check what time will be convenient for the people around the world, and a global time doesn't make that any easier (arguably even worse). Just because UTC makes sense for machines doesn't mean it makes sense for humans. And machines should adjust to humans, not the other way around.
- Chris2048 7y agoonly if you adjust manually. Given a universal time and a location, you can determine time of (solar) day just like you can determine the day name (mon,tues etc).
- JdeBP 7y agoInterestingly, you highlight an error in the article that gave me pause: > Coordinated Universal Time, which is based, ironically, on the position of the sun relative to Earth. As you say, UTC is not a sun clock. It is based upon Atomic Time. I also wondered who, knowing history, would consider the concept of December not to be fabricated. (-:
- classified 7y agoI bet they still have Daylight Saving Time, so the bureaucrats get one last win.
- madcaptenor 7y agoNorway's Troll Station, in Antarctica, follows UTC (geographically accurate for them) in the southern summer and UTC+2 in the southern winter (to facilitate communication with Norway) - so they do daylight savings time, but backwards! (Source: https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/tz/2014-March/020705.html https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/tz/2014-March/020705.html)
- GrumpyNl 7y agoThey could use swatch time, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatch_Internet_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatch_Internet_Time
- cozzyd 7y agoAt the South Pole station, NZ time is used since it's supplied from McMurdo (which is supplied from Christchurch). However the tourist camp a km away is on Chile time since they are supplied from Union glacier and Punta Arenas. The tourist camp people were nice enough to invite us on Christmas, even though for them it was like 3 am when we visited.
- mcbutterbunz 7y ago3 am to me means in the middle of the night while I'm sleeping. So I'm curious, do people at the South Pole typically follow a similar sleep/wake cycle despite the time zone they follow?
- cozzyd 7y agoI think the staff at the tourist camp just tries to accommodate the tourists, so I'd guess they'd mostly stay on Chile time, but I don't really know. At the research station though a normal schedule is mostly followed, at least for meals. Some people keep odd hours of course, and I think there are people on night shift for certain things (e.g. meteo is always manned).
- zokier 7y agoI do point out that polar night is not that absolute. Even when sun doesn't rise above the horizon, there is still quite discernable day-night cycle from twilight to midnight and back, especially if you are not exactly on the pole.
- BurningFrog 7y agoSunsets/-rises take much longer the closer to the poles you get, because the sun moves "sideways" across the sky, not up/down. So even when the sun is technically "set", it is often just under the horizon, and lighting things up.
- fractalb 7y agoA very nice article. It just made me observe that “there is no time when there is no motion”
- datacaviar 7y agoCan there be an impact on how organisms age in such places?
- kranner 7y agoHard to imagine how that could be the case, other than with messed up circadian (and diurnal, etc) rhythms.
- jessermeyer 7y agod / t What is t, really? It's really just another form of distance, whether you express that in terms of cesium nuclear energy state changes, or the distance a clock hand moves. So d / t is really d_1 / d_2.
- ToFab123 7y agoIPhone users should try to ask Siri "What time zone is Antarctica in" Edit: added screen shot https://imgur.com/a/xw8Z7qr https://imgur.com/a/xw8Z7qr
- creed98 7y agoIf the north pole is all the time zones this means different latitudes are have different time zone coefficients. The closer to the equator the more defined and separate of a time zone reality
- Y-Bopinator 7y agoSorry but time still passes at the North Pole. Clickbait