6 ms·
Climate change: The rich are to blame
- kharak 7y agoI like that this approach doesn't measure money, but energy usage. Energy always feels to me like the real currency and form of wealth. Normally, we want to increase the amount of energy we can spend, alas we need to find better ways of doing so.
- endgame 7y agoCEO Morgan would agree with you. Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri: predicting the future since 1999.
- Quarrelsome 7y ago> Resources exist to be consumed. And consumed they will be, if not by this generation then by some future. By what right does this forgotten future seek to deny us our birthright? None I say! Let us take what is ours, chew and eat our fill. CEO Nwabudike Morgan, "The Ethics of Greed"
- endgame 7y agoEnergy is the currency of the future. - CEO Nwabudike Morgan, "The Centauri Monopoly" I was going to link to its page on Paean to SMAC but it turns out that quote is from "Global Energy Theory", a tech that didn't make it into the final game (but had data set up for it). So there's no write-up about it. Instead, I'll link to the Paean's "First Time Here?" page: https://paeantosmac.wordpress.com/first-time-here/ https://paeantosmac.wordpress.com/first-time-here/
- Quarrelsome 7y agoThe lore in that game was so fantastic. I wish there hadn't been an IP war over it. These days Hollywood is so desperate for ideas that it could have been a TV series or a film by now otherwise. My favourite tech quote was MMI (mind-machine interface): > The Warrior's bland acronym, MMI, obscures the true horror of this monstrosity. Its inventors promise a new era of genius, but meanwhile unscrupulous power brokers use its forcible installation to violate the sanctity of unwilling human minds. They are creating their own private army of demons. Commissioner Pravin Lal, "Report on Human Rights" ---- The text doesn't do the delivery credit though, the acting as well was often phenomenal.
- Mirioron 7y agoBecause it is. With enough energy you can make all kinds of problems go away. The industrial revolution was all about unlocking the usage of non-human energy.
- cameronbrown 7y agoClimate change aside: This trend of measuring what resources rich people use compared to everyone else just snacks of jealousy. Who cares if energy distribution isn't "equitable"?? Just live your life and stop comparing. Edit: Prepared to eat Karma here, but it's what I believe.
- folli 7y agoAren't we somehow in this boat together?
- reallydontask 7y agoSome of us are more in it than others :)
- folli 7y agoI don't know, some of us might have a more luxurious cabin on a top floor, where it takes longer for the water to leak in, but the boat is sinking nonetheless.
- praptak 7y agoSome of us are reluctant to give up the good seats in order to save the boat.
- reallydontask 7y agoThis is hardly surprising. A lot of poor people are not going to fly, are more likely to use public transport and because they have less, or no, disposable income, consume less. Sweeping generalisations of course
- esarbe 7y agoNot very surprising. The question is; how do we mitigate further damage, address the damage that has been done and make sure that those responsible pay the bill?
- Loic 7y agoAccounting of the externalities when applying taxes would certainly help.
- esarbe 7y agoOh boy, that would be awesome. I'd love to see the EU to start addressing this by setting higher environmental standards, putting them in force locally and apply such taxes to imported products.
- qayxc 7y agoSadly this won't work. Unfortunately, the capitalist system is very opportunistic and "[my country] first!" initiatives would quickly out-compete countries and trade blocks that heavily tax consumption or production in that way. Just look at Norway, my personal go-to example for that kind of taxation. The country has an absurdly high "luxury"-tax on cars (up to 100% all costs combined). The only reason they can do that, though, is the complete lack of a domestic automotive industry. The high taxation simply doesn't affect their national economy in the slightest. Countries like Sweden, the Czech Republic,or especially France and Germany couldn't do that - they have a substantial automotive industry. What unfair competition can do could be observed in Europe in the 1970s and the 2000s. In the 1970s, pretty much the entire textile industry moved to South East Asia due to absurdly low costs compared to Europe (one could name it outright slavery). In the 2000s, the Chinese government did the same to Germany's solar industry by undercutting prices using substantial government subsidies. Proper taxation of goods depending on environmental impact would be able to fundamentally change the economy from focus on consumerism to a more sustainable and cyclic economy. But it only takes a few market actors that don't participate to render the scheme unsustainable overall... And the recent trend towards autocratic "alpha males" in global politics (from the White House, to the Kremlin, to the Bosporus, and South America) paired with increasing nationalism worldwide doesn't make me hopeful for the near future.
- dimitar 7y agoPossible policies: * Carbon taxes * Cap of total emissions * Energy assistance program for the poor, or a rebate for everyone; whatever is more likely to succeed politically. This way the lifestyle adjustment comes mainly from the top, somewhat from the middle and the poor don't waste fuels and electricity or use other means of heating like illegal firewood.
- justforfunhere 7y ago[offtopic rant] Coronavirus is hitting back hard on behalf of nature. Pollution levels in worst hit areas have come down. Industries have shut down and economic activity has subsided. Coronavirus is in a way a ironic fk you to Humans. Its the kind of enemy that we as a civilization are worse prepared for. Even after all the technological breakthroughs, we are still nowhere. With our current technology we can easily tell whether there is a cat or a dog in a picture, but can't tell quickly enough whether a asymptomatic person standing right in front of you has Corona infection. Way to go! Let's make some more bright graduates to work on making people click more ads, yeah.
- adreamingsoul 7y agoWhen looking at Nature as a system, it seems obvious to me that this virus is some kind of attempt to address the current imbalance. I'm personally curious how long it will take for nature to understand the feedback from what the virus is doing. This is an area of research that I wish I could focus on. It would be beneficial to us if we could understand what inputs nature is using to determine if the system is balanced.
- esarbe 7y agoWhat? No. The system just is. There's not attempting at balance whatsoever. Any appearance of a balance is emergent from the individual parts trying to optimize for reproduction.
- ngold 7y agoThe greatest tragedy is we have 50 years of lost geniuses doing Quant work for Wallstreet instead of making scientific breakthroughs.
- jlawson 7y agoBeing fair, efficient allocation of capital is important. it creates wealth, which improves human life. There are definitely lots of bulshit jobs out there, but I wouldn't call quants among the highest tier in terms of waste of human talent. I'd probably look at adtech for that.
- easytiger 7y agoRidiculous reductive nonsense
- hackeraccount 7y agoAgreed. This article is takes something complex and reduces it to total idiocy.
- easytiger 7y agoIt's a reimagining of original sin. And it can get lost. Evil way of thinking
- blunte 7y agoThis ignores the area where the rich do the most climate damage - with corporate activities. Individuals and poor people don't cut down hectares of rainforest, kill hectares of soil with mass monoculture farming, spill billions of barrels of oil into the ocean, etc. All these things are done in pursuit of more profit (or at least more revenue). The beneficiaries of these activities are the rich - the execs, shareholders, banking partners, VCs, etc. I would guess that the scale of damage done -- the disparity of climate harm between rich people and poor people -- is far greater than the individual rich vs poor personal energy consumption.
- Mirioron 7y agoThe beneficiaries of these activities are the people buying the products. If people wouldn't have a desire for more cheap food and other products then people wouldn't make it. Turns out though, that it's the poorest people for whom cheap food is most useful. An executive still eats the same amount of calories as anyone else.
- pjc50 7y ago> An executive still eats the same amount of calories as anyone else. .. but throws away far more, and the CO2 emissions and land area produced are not the same for all calories.
- blunte 7y agoThat's the theory, but in practice it doesn't work that way. Just take oil and gas, for example. The poorest people are certainly not consuming large amounts of petroleum products. For example, consider the US Military - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_usage_of_the_United_States_military https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_usage_of_the_United_Sta... The primary beneficiaries of this military consumption are the corporations that supply the goods and services that the military pays for (with public money), but the gains made by those corporations go into a relatively few pockets. Another example is big agriculture corporations. In the US, for decades there have been subsidies paid to corn "farmers" (now big corps), to the extent that the businesses had to find ways to use corn beyond just food. Thus came corn syrup, ethanol (https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_case_against_ethanol_bad_for_environment https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_case_against_ethanol_bad_...) and more. Beneficiaries of this, again, are a few people. Meanwhile, land is burned out (soil quality reduced to worthless), plus all the infrastructure and energy use related to operating large scale farms. If I had all day to spend, I could probably find a dozen other examples. This has nothing to do with cheap food for poor people; and after all, the research shows that the cheap food is the unhealthiest.
- Neil44 7y agoUs "Rich People" have agency to push entropy aside, using energy as a resource, in a way that people in undeveloped areas do not.
- jahnu 7y ago"Rich People"... we are rich. It doesn't warrant scare quotes.
- Quarrelsome 7y agoye and that agency comes at a global cost. I'm looking at the ankle deep water in Bangladesh. Who is paying for that? Not the 'rich'. How is that anywhere near the human principal of 'fair'?
- Udik 7y agoDo you really think that Bangladesh's problem is the "ankle deep water"? Honestly, I think the left has completely lost it. Let me elaborate very briefly: forty years ago, the left would have been concerned with people in the poorest countries living in mud huts, with no food safety, no hospitals in reach, no schooling, no protection from illness and natural disasters. Nowadays- and it's enough to read a left-wing newspaper to realise- the left is only concerned with the marginal increase in misery (supposedly) caused to the poorest by climate change. While in fact the mythical baseline we should bring the world back to is only just slightly better than the current situation, that is, still horrid by any standard. If your problem are the floods in Bangladesh, you'll help them very little by cutting the jet trips of the rich west; what they need are tons of energy and machines to build water management systems, schools to educate a class of engineers and civil servants, factories to build job security, agriculture to build food safety and resilience. All stuff that in fact emits shittons of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. /rant
- Quarrelsome 7y agoAnkle deep water is just a flippant way of referencing rising sea levels. Some families that used to have low-lying farmland now just have a river, raise ducks instead of chickens. Its a visible outcome of the use of fossil fuels. Obviously its not Bangladesh's only nor primary concern. Also, FWIW, I find it exceptionally offensive that you've tried to turn this into some left/right hocus pocus. Global warming, climate change, developing world poverty; these are all issues where the directional political learning does _nothing_ to provide the solutions.
- averros 7y agoPeople complaining about rich countries being environmentally bad really need to get their derrieres up and go see the world outside of tourist traps. The amount of environmental devastation in poorer countries is unbelievable (to us spoiled Westerners). Rich countries are, in fact, much cleaner in all aspects. This is because people can afford caring about environment and because modern tech is much cleaner than mid-industrial age tech. I would start listening to these sanctimonous enviro-preachers when they start pushing the REAL polluters to clean up. You know, the Chinese. Or when they get Zulu to give up their goats (you need to visit Serengeti to see what these do to the savanna), or when they ditch their support of warmongers - DU is a heck of a pollutant, and so are burning oil wells. Telling the western people that they need to live like third-worlders by giving up fruits of civilization is both asinine and idiotic (if the goal is to protect the environment).
- makomk 7y agoClimate change: we need to make everyone less well-off in real, tangible terms that will directly affect every part of their lives. Justified by framing it in class-war terms, but with proposals that will make many things that were once available to the masses luxuries for the really rich. It's like it's a simultaneous demonstration both of why many on the right believe fighting climate change is just a left-wing weapon to push their ideology and why the supposed natural audience of the anti-rich populist left, poor and working-class members of society, are "voting against their own interests" and not supporting them.
- pjc50 7y agoThe alternative is random unevenly distributed making of people less well off; such as the Australian wildfires or the gradual flooding of Miami.
- mrpickels 7y agoconsume less, be moderate, have a healthy lifestyle, avoid civilization and have an abundance of happiness! and MOST important - don't read stupid comments on HN haha
- qayxc 7y agoThe irony in your comment stings so hard, I'm feeling like a fakir reading it...
- esarbe 7y agoWhat's the reason this got flagged?