3 ms·
> each day along with a zinc pill. The scientific studies being cited for these COVID-19 vaccines using Chloroquine specifically state zinc supplements by them
by dmix 7y ago
> each day along with a zinc pill.
The scientific studies being cited for these COVID-19 vaccines using Chloroquine specifically state zinc supplements by themselves are not ionized and are therefore useless for fighting the virus. Even though zinc entering cells is a key part of how it works, zinc can't enter the cells in question unless it's properly ionized, which is why they use Chloroquine... an ionized zinc delivery system... jumping to "lets all take some Zinc pills with gin & tonic" is irresponsible advice IMO.
These sorts of Naturopathy proposals is exactly how we got COVID-19 in the first place (ie, people eating Pangolins in east asia for Chinese medicine purposes - the most trafficked animal in the world - which just happens to be infected with a coronavirus that matches 99%+ to the one currently making the rounds).
This sort of weak adherence to a scientific approach to medicine + some vague historical reasoning is the problem, not the solution.
- jasonmp85 7y agoPangolins aren’t the source and I’m not even gonna bother to explain.
- swiley 7y agoIt might not be that specific animal but the Chinese wet food markets have a history of pretty serious viruses, this is just the worst and most recent. Remember, it’s this kind of thing that brought us HIV so it could get even worse.
- dmix 7y agoI’m always open to being educated. I was referencing articles on Nature from February pointing to Pangolins more than any other mammal (without full certainty of course, that takes time).
- pillefitz 7y agoZinc supplementation is an effective treatment against many commonly found viruses. Are you saying the new virus is an exception to this? Seriously curious, as I haven't looked into it specifically. Also: Gargling a zinc/water solution has an astringent effect and removes the bacterial film in your throat, which seems to help in the initial phase of an infection.
- dmix 7y agoThe scientific study wasn't even for COVID-19 but another very similar Coronavirus and yes they said it would have no effect on the cells without ionization (specifically zinc entering the cell to blocking an RNA that's needed by the virus to replicate). There was a video of a doctor breaking down the biochemistry of it that got posted here the last time Chloroquine came up, which I can't find just now. If it were only just as easy as taking zinc pills... I take vitamins daily already just to be safe (there's far more than coronaviruses floating around). I just don't expect them to be enough to prevent something as serious as COVID-19. There's a reason Chloroquine is being studied and not zinc by itself and is 100x more expensive to buy on the internet than zinc supplements, even before it became a meme. It's just not that simple. That hasn't stopped naturopathy from spreading before though.
- pillefitz 7y agoNot in direct reply to your post, but slighty interesting anecdata: I likely caught COVID-19 1-2 days ago (light fever, headaches, loss of smell, but no runny nose): I gargled with Zinc as I noticed the first symptoms, had Cinchona bark tea yesterday. After a day, almost all symptoms disappeared except for the loss of smell, which is generally considered a late-stage symptom. Given that the common cold without any treatment typically lasts around 5 days or so, it might point to some efficacy of the treatment.
- giardini 7y agoWould you share your recipe for cinchona bark tea? How judge the strength and how much to drink per day? I bought some cinchona bark (cut, but is powdery) and they have a recipe on the bag but no specification of strength or how much to drink.
- narogab 7y agodrmix says> " zinc can't enter the cells in question unless it's properly ionized, which is why they use Chloroquine.." Zinc in the bloodstream is ionized zn++. It _can_ enter the cell but not easily. Chloroquine almost literally "opens the front door" to the cell's cytoplasm and any zn++ that stumbles by is pulled in. But there _is_ a background zn++ level in the bloodstream and it is a gauntlet that every coronavirus must run to get to a cell. When a cell dies from coronavirus replication, the virii burst into the bloodstream where they are vulnerable to any zn++ present. So high zn++ blood levels may be efficacious. Once a coronavirus runs the gauntlet and finds its way to a healthy cell, it injects its RNA into the cell. The RNA is now relatively safe from zn++ in the bloodstream (except the few that wander into the cytoplasm by other mechanisms).