3 ms·
Huh. I was tempted to dismiss this as a thin skin/theme, but if they've recreated the panel and control panel, maybe it is a thorough clone. The real™ CDE is st
by yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago
Huh. I was tempted to dismiss this as a thin skin/theme, but if they've recreated the panel and control panel, maybe it is a thorough clone. The real™ CDE is still alive and works (and open source), but I'll admit something a little less dated is probably easier to work with. Part of the appeal of CDE to me is that it actually had a unified design; in particular, every window had a help menu on the right side with good, contextual, help available. Unfortunately, in the modern world most applications aren't written like that, so just having CDE or a clone doesn't get you that same experience. And yes, you could use a modern DE and associated apps, but they all seem so shallow to me in comparison to CDE's level of thoughtful design and accessibility (it was beginner friendly in an era where that could mean "this is the first computer the user has ever touched").
- satya71 7y agoThat's a good point. There used to be built-in help for almost every thing in CDE. That's how I learnt all about using it. It even had some ability to create GUIs using the Bourne Shell[1]. [1] http://cdesktopenv.sourceforge.net/man1/dtksh.html http://cdesktopenv.sourceforge.net/man1/dtksh.html
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoThat's sweet:) A little like the premise of zenity, but skimming that manpage it looks far more powerful. Albeit, harder to use, since it's pretty much directly exposing raw(-ish?) X & motif APIs in ksh.
- mhd 7y agoksh itself was pretty powerful, and some of its programming features still haven't found their way into bash or zsh. But yeah, the API is a rather direct translation of the somewhat verbose Intrinsics/Motif interface. Compare that to its contemporary Tcl/Tk.
- coleifer 7y ago>I was tempted to dismiss it.... Goes on to completely dismiss it. This is an amazing project and much more than a theme/skin, and obviously a labor of love. Glad to see it on HN getting some well-earned kudos.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago>>I was tempted to dismiss it.... >Goes on to completely dismiss it. Then I failed to properly express myself, and I apologize. Having watched the YouTube playlist, NsCDE is indeed an extremely thorough clone that mostly matches the original and in many places exceeds it. In particular, it does appear to have globally-available help, which lacks the "click anything and get a description" mode but otherwise is a match for the original. They've even somewhat addressed a problem with running the original in 2020 by making it support even non-native applications (through QT+GTK theme support). So yes, this is very impressive, and not at all the shallow skin that I initially expected.