3 ms·
The logic of the UK position is well articulated in this very HN-friendly article by a UK epidemiologist unaffiliated with the govt scientific advice team [comp
by notahacker 7y ago
The logic of the UK position is well articulated in this very HN-friendly article by a UK epidemiologist unaffiliated with the govt scientific advice team [complete with graphs, the Python code of his illustratory models and an appropriate caveat about the magnitude of the uncertainties of the assumptions the scientific advisory team's models will have made]
https://personalpages.manchester.ac.uk/staff/thomas.house/blog/modelling-herd-immunity.html https://personalpages.manchester.ac.uk/staff/thomas.house/bl...
nb the UK has since issued stronger isolation guidelines and downplayed herd immunity in the media. Longer paper about their current model https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/sph/ide/gida-fellowships/Imperial-College-COVID19-NPI-modelling-16-03-2020.pdf https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/s...
- baq 7y agothe article hints at a solution: > The reason that this happens is that social distancing measures do not lead to herd immunity, so once they are lifted the epidemic starts again. In the absence of a vaccine, it is therefore meaningless to speak about whether a policy 'aims' to get herd immunity or not, since every country in the world will reach herd immunity unless it is able to implement social distancing for an indefinite period of time. i predict this is exactly what will happen: indefinite social distancing. impact may be reduced with fast tests and large scale testing so isolation and contact quarantining is immediate.
- notahacker 7y agoIt's plausible that COVID-19 will lead to behavioural change around hygiene and remote work, greater travel restrictions and possibly even a degree of acceptance of periodic lockdowns, but the idea humanity as a whole is going to permanently shift towards social distancing after millennia of doing the opposite stretches credulity. At risk groups moving towards social distancing, maybe [for some old people that won't even be much of a change], but that's where the theoretical possibility of herd immunity of the general population not in permanent isolation comes into play.
- baq 7y agoindefinite does not mean infinite. effectively until a vaccine is deployed globally or global herd immunity is achieved after ten years of pandemic or however long it takes.
- notahacker 7y agoOne of the few things epidemiologists can be certain of in their assumptions is that our economy and society won't sustain indefinite lockdowns. Extended localised lockdowns, until R0 drops below 1, yes. Repeated localized lockdowns, maybe but decreasingly so. Let's wait until we have a vaccine or something, no.
- baq 7y agoI agree completely, that’s what I had in mind, but wasn’t really precise enough - basically whatever’s South Korea doing right now. Access to testing, test all suspected cases, quarantine and isolate, and the economy can sort of be back to pre-pandemic order of magnitude.