4 ms·
The current situation is a good argument for owning a car. It's actually not. It's a good argument for actually diversifying our transit options so people have
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
The current situation is a good argument for owning a car.
It's actually not. It's a good argument for actually diversifying our transit options so people have real choice.
A lot of people aren't really pro transit options. They are really for public transit and/or against cars.
If it is easier to do a mix of walking, public transit, etc, then there's no single point of failure.
If the transit system isn't overloaded, you can sometimes find yourself on the bus by yourself for a bit.
If you have flexibility to work from home or go in when you feel like it, that's another way to not be trapped in a crowded bus or whatever.
We need to break some lockstep patterns, not trade one monolith for another, which tends to be the argument.
- threatofrain 7y agoThat couldn't possibly help people in the next half year. An interesting change to the public transportation system is a tree one plants for the decade or two later.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoOften, small tweaks are overlooked or outright dismissed out of hand because people think it's not enough and insist it won't make a difference. But the 80/20 rule tends to apply. If you do whatever small and easy things are immediately possible, you get 80 percent of the way there and it frees up resources and extends the runway so that last hard 20 percent can be resolved or at least better tolerated.
- threatofrain 7y agoFor your idea to work, there still has to be an interesting change to how public infrastructure works, and not merely in the change-your-lifestyle way. Having to walk a little bit is already part of the bus/subway/train bargain unless you're pretty lucky. But once you're on the bus there's only so much social distancing you can do. What are you going to do then? Thus, the car is the ultimate vehicle if you don't want even want a driver. Renting a car is the lowest hanging fruit right now for dealing with this problem. If you have a low hanging fruit suggestion then put it out there, but it's not trying to socially distance yourself on a bus, right?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI've lived without a car for for more than a decade. People who drive have mental maps attached to driving everywhere. They frequently can't see the small shortcuts and the like that already exist. When I gave up my car, I was in an apartment complex within a twenty minute walk of four shopping centers. There were two other apartment complexes lined up next to mine. No one walked. They literally got in their car to drive their trash to the dumpster or pick up their mail or go to the pool. Me and my sons began walking. And when you walked, you didn't have to go all the way down the hill to the street. You could cut through the grass and one of the shopping centers didn't even require you to cross a street. If you aren't familiar with various options, you don't have the mental maps to do things quickly and easily. You impose mental maps from an unrelated process and draw inaccurate conclusions because your brain superimposes the car path you would need to take when you aren't going to go walk down to the street and walk in the street, etc. I gave up my car and the internet told me it was not a walkable neighborhood because there was no theater or something. My favorite grocery store was on the corner.y bank branch was across from it. I was near my job and other shopping. It wasn't perfect, but it met a lot of my needs. I'm not a big movie goer. I did not care that there was no theater. And I can talk until I'm blue in the face and people who don't walk as a form of transit will shout me down and tell me I'm a whack job. But if you want to beat this thing, you may find that you have other options to do things you need to do if you will just look for them. Sir down and list an essential task. Food. Work. Banking. Write out the sticking points. Why is this a problem currently. Brainstorm alternatives: ATM, online banking, PayPal, prepaid debit card, e-gift cards, etc. Search Google maps for all nearby options. Zoom in. Think about what's actually conveniently close. I'm not saying no one should drive. I'm just saying it's not better for driving to become the new monolith everyone should pursue because of the pandemic. Shopping when it's less crowded is effective. It's a practice I'm pursuing. It reduces exposure and it has nothing to do with how I go there. It's just a function of timing.
- leftyted 7y ago> It's actually not. It's a good argument for actually diversifying our transit options so people have real choice. > If it is easier to do a mix of walking, public transit, etc, then there's no single point of failure. I have "real choice". Subway, buses, uber, walking, biking. That's normally how I get around. But I, someone who relies on public transportation, have noticed that there are, in fact, situations where owning a car is advantageous. Like an epidemic. Forget my commute. I can't visit my sister, who lives 15 miles away, without uber/metro/bus. Those options would put me in the wake of hundreds or thousands of other people. If I had a car, I could just drive and it would be significantly safer. I'm not saying "everyone should buy a car". I'm noting that, hey, there actually are situations where being able to safely move around by yourself is helpful. That's not so shocking!
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou know, I know there's a pandemic on and we're all snappish, me included. But real choice includes "choice to own a car, if you so wish, and drive it where you want." That's my entire point. You should have a choice. It shouldn't ever be an argument of "all public transit, all the time" versus "cult of the car." But Americans turn it into an either/or argument all the time. Take care. Safely move around as you choose. Wash your hands. Stop touching your face.
- leftyted 7y agoThis has nothing to do with any of the things I've posted in this thread. I do have a choice. I could buy a car. Many people own cars. My point was that a pandemic (or similar event) is a good argument for owning a car. I'm a little bewildered at how you've chosen to communicate but, uh, have a nice day.
- dchyrdvh 7y agoPublic transport is a hub for diseases no matter how well it's designed. You really need a personal transportation vehicle that isolates you from others.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI'm not sure if you missed the news today but large parts of the world have politely asked it's citizens to avoid all non essential travel. In a week or two they are going to stop with the polite part. You don't need a personal vehicle, you need to figure out how to stay home.
- dchyrdvh 7y agoThis advice is good on paper, but useless in practice.