4 ms·
Most of the SP500 movements come from small number of companies too. Dow Jones is bad index but the narrow number of companies is not the worst part. DJIA is p
by nabla9 7y ago
Most of the SP500 movements come from small number of companies too.
Dow Jones is bad index but the narrow number of companies is not the worst part. DJIA is price-weighted index which is completely arbitrary and there is no reason for that. They can't add Berkshire Hathaway into the index without completely changing the rules. BRK-A price is so high. Index would track only BRK-A after that.
- jedberg 7y agoI'm not sure why they don't add BRK-B though.
- kolbe 7y agoIn my opinion, BRK shouldn't really be in the S&P 500 anyway. I don't get why a company that owns AAPL should be in an index that already owns AAPL.
- prewett 7y agoWell, BERK-A is the canonical class. But Berkshire Hathaway is practically an index of its own, being a big, giant holding company. I don't think it belongs in any index.
- KMag 7y ago"DJIA is price-weighted index which is completely arbitrary and there is no reason for that." Well, I believe the reason is that it's much easier to calculate on hand-cranked mechanical adding machines. There is a reason, but it's obsolete.