5 ms·
HN has showdead and vouching, which imho substantially reduce the negative effects of shadowbanning. I run showdead, and most shadowbanned accounts deserve it.
by samatman 7y ago
HN has showdead and vouching, which imho substantially reduce the negative effects of shadowbanning.
I run showdead, and most shadowbanned accounts deserve it. I also rescue the occasional comment from the grave.
Do the moderators un-shadowban users if they get enough vouched comments? No idea, but they do have enough information to do so.
- derekp7 7y agoI'll often come across shadow banned comments, and when I look at the author's post history (back to the first dead comment, plus a few pages of comments before) I really don't see anything wrong. Is it because the comment(s) that got them banned have been removed? When I run across such an account, should I email an HN mod to investigate? I wouldn't mind doing that, but I've tried before and never got a reply back -- so not sure what the outcome was.
- emilfihlman 7y agoIt's possibly because of a single comment (out of n, where n is large) of disagreeing with the crowd or saying something unpleasant or a mod powertripping. It's stupid as fuck. Reddit is also plagued by it.
- phillijw 7y agoI am shadow banned. I think because of one comment I made many years ago that was heavily downvoted? I just don't log in anymore. I emailed PG at the time and he said there's nothing he can do.
- samatman 7y agoI presume that sometimes, it's a new account of someone who has been permanently banned for bad behavior. Emailing a mod can't hurt, though.
- downerending 7y agoI wish there was a page to see just flagged stories. Many are noise, of course, but I notice that there are a number of really good submissions there as well.