4 ms·
> If Tim Cook paid $200 million dollar fine or went to jail for 15 days for this, internal controls and compliance would be rock solid. If Tim Cook paid a $200
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> If Tim Cook paid $200 million dollar fine or went to jail for 15 days for this, internal controls and compliance would be rock solid.
If Tim Cook paid a $200 million dollar fine and went to jail for 15 days for this, he'd run the company from jail for 15 days and then get a $300 million dollar bonus the next year.
You can't get at this by punishing the executives if the consequences still benefit the shareholders, because otherwise all they'll do is increase executive compensation to offset the legal risks. There are plenty of people who would be willing to go to jail for years if there was a hundred million dollars in it for them.
It's the same reason calibrating the fines right is nearly impossible. Go under and it's no deterrent, go over and you're just bankrupting everybody and putting innocent people out of work.
The better solutions are the ones that repair the damage (or prevent it). Don't allow large companies to buy their competitors, or leverage a strong position in one market into a strong position in another, or enter into price fixing agreements etc. This is all basic antitrust stuff and the problem isn't that it doesn't work, it's that it isn't being enforced.
- nuclearnice1 7y agoThese are good points. I agree the lapse in antitrust in the last 20 years has not helped the problem of corporate crime. To address the offsetting compensation, perhaps harsher penalties. Some level of punishment exceeds the economic value of the crime, maybe that where it needs to be aimed? I agree calibration is hard. We’re currently at zero. I bet the number should be higher.