2 ms·
Because means testing requires a massive, and in this case ad hoc, bureaucracy established to evaluate who should get money. Good luck establishing that. Mailin
by Jtsummers 7y ago
Because means testing requires a massive, and in this case ad hoc, bureaucracy established to evaluate who should get money. Good luck establishing that. Mailing out checks is actually cheaper and technically feasible, in comparison.
Additionally, not everyone in debt got there by way of lack of personal responsibility. One ambulance ride and ER would send many minimum wage earners into debt, even if they were responsible with their earnings.
- belltaco 7y agoI think the IRS is much better set up for this than state run welfare programs. Send a check out to everyone now but collect $950 more in taxes next year from only folks that made more than $XX,XXX amount of money in 2020. Also you could make it so that uncashed checks would be cancelled by next year and you get a $50 extra refund.
- macinjosh 7y agoI agree, the people I had in mind are those who make high 5 to low 6 figures but have extensive credit card debt for things like vacations, unnecessary purchases, or expensive cars. (I personally have been guilty of this in the past)
- NamTaf 7y agoMeans-testing it isn't necessarily that difficult. When Australia implemented the same idea during the GFC, it was paid out on a scale up to ~$130k based on the previous year's income tax report. Whilst not perfect, I'd be willing to bet good money that it correlates pretty decently well across financial years. It was also distributed via direct electronic funds transfer in the most case (as that's how the vast majority opt to receive a tax return), so it was pretty frictionless here because all of that infromation was readily on hand. That may not apply in the US, I don't know.