3 ms·
In the past, I believe Apple has certainly placed limits on what prices Wal-Mart or Amazon could sell Apple products at, to avoid the appearance of them being "
by crazygringo 7y ago
In the past, I believe Apple has certainly placed limits on what prices Wal-Mart or Amazon could sell Apple products at, to avoid the appearance of them being "discounted" or customers shopping around -- your iPhone is $x99 no matter where you buy it, period. (They seem to have loosened up somewhat since.)
Should that be illegal? For a company to say "I'll sell you this wholesale stock only on the condition you only resell it for exactly $x and never less."
Is there a meaningful distinction here from supermarkets in an area colluding to sell all milk an inflated price? Or is it really the same anti-consumer, anti-competitive behavior in the end?
And I wonder to what extent it has to do with defining the price on an entire category of items (milk) vs a single company (you can always buy an Android instead).
I don't know the answer, so just curious if there's any kind of consensus conclusion here by economists.
- jeremymcanally 7y agoA single company setting a price for its own product, for which viable alternatives exist in the same category at different price points, is a very different animal than a group of suppliers using their monopoly status on a product category to inflate prices for their own profit.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoExcept that it's exactly what allows that to happen. If MegaCorp says they sell widgets wholesale for $7 and you must sell them retail for $10, everybody sells them retail for $10 and makes $3. Meanwhile BigCorp does the same thing for for the widgets they make and all the widgets retail for $10. Nobody can lower their prices except the manufacturers who are few enough to be secretly colluding, so no price competition commences. Without this, BoxCo starts buying widgets for $7 and retailing them for $9. Which, immediately, is a lower price for the consumer. Then another shop without BoxCo's scale starts pressuring MegaCorp to give them widgets for $6.50 instead of $7 so they can compete with BoxCo's $9, which the manufacturer wants because they don't want BoxCo to have a retail monopoly on their goods. So now more retailers are selling for $9 retail to the benefit of the customer. Then BigCorp has to lower their wholesale prices so their retailers can compete with MegaCorp retailers selling for $9, and so on. Price fixing is enabled by fixing prices. Or to put it another way, enforced MSRP is a conspiracy to fix prices on the part of the retailers coordinated through the manufacturer.
- manmal 7y agoYes, in this very case, it means French customers don’t profit from the benefits of a free market (i.e. a competitive price) because the price was fixed. The problem here is that all customers that would buy a product for amount X, but don’t buy it at Y (the fixed price, which is greater than X), won’t buy it just because of the fixed price. Which effectively cuts those customers off from the product. The French obviously want to maximize their consumers‘ access to such products.