5 ms·
I almost understand this, but not quite. The reason is likely that I lack the prerequisite understanding of what constitutes an order, how it's different from a
by kqr 7y ago
I almost understand this, but not quite. The reason is likely that I lack the prerequisite understanding of what constitutes an order, how it's different from a limit order, and so on. Either way, I would like to understand it better because they way you put it makes it sound rather elegant.
This feels like something that could be very intuitively explained with visuals. Does anyone know of such a visual explanation of this?
- thedudeabides5 7y agoGood question, but I haven't seen any. The core concept is that there are a bunch of folks that more or less promise to either post bids (promises to buy) or offers (promises to sell) continuously, and for that promise they (sometimes) get special treatment as 'market makers.' In an orderly market, there are both bids and offers for every instrument. A market maker (or really any market participant) desire to participate in the market is a function of a) the rest of their portfolio (whether they are net 'long' or net 'short') and b) their expectations of when and at what price they can unwind the trade if they get 'hit' on their bid (aka someone sells to them at their posted price) or 'lifted' on their offer (aka someone buys from them). When markets are moving 5-6% an hour, it becomes almost impossible to have any certainty on a) what the rest of your portfolio really looks like and b) when and at what price you might be able to unwind a particular trade. This results in market makers (and HFT, and other market participants) basically exiting the market. When people say the 'bid-offer spread is wide' this is usually what they are referring to. All the usual players basically take a step back and say 'too rich for my blood' and then you have wide markets, and 'risk premiums' for assets all over the place. Circuit breakers are an attempt to slow time down to give people a chance to understand their portfolios better, and hence return to the market. Wide bid-offers represent highly profitable market opportunities, if the market is orderly. When it's not, you get stuff like an ETF on US government bonds trading as a steep discount to the 'intrinsic value' of the underlying bond portfolio. Aka chaos. https://ycharts.com/companies/TLT/discount_or_premium_to_nav https://ycharts.com/companies/TLT/discount_or_premium_to_nav
- Simulacra 7y agoThe Dude, ladies and gentlemen. Very nicely said.
- jkulubya 7y agoIf you have access to a trading platform (try one of the crypto exchanges, they usually have free data), you can try and watch an order book for a few minutes. It’s quite intuitive. Investopedia and Wikipedia can explain the different order types.
- rmrfstar 7y agoYes, pdf page 50 of [1] has a graph with a thoroughly worked example. [1] http://people.stern.nyu.edu/jhasbrou/TeachingMaterials/STPPms12a.pdf http://people.stern.nyu.edu/jhasbrou/TeachingMaterials/STPPm...
- baking 7y agoThe terms "limit order" and "market order" are more than a little bit dated. A limit order is just an order to buy or sell at a specific price or better. It's like going on e-bay and bidding at a specific price, you may or may not get it if there is no one to sell at that price. A market order is to buy or sell right now at the market price no matter what. You may get a terrible price, but you will get the deal done. So let's say you are looking to buy a stock. A limit order puts your bid price on the market and someone can come along and sell it to you at that price, but only after all the higher bids and all the bids at the same price that were entered before yours were executed. The other option is to try to pay the asking price of someone who is trying to sell the stock. Let's say you see an ask at $80.00 and you are willing to pay that price so you put in a market order to buy. But someone could see your order and "front-run" you by buying up all the $80.00 asks and relisting at a higher price so you get stuck with it at that new higher price. The safer option is to try to match that $80.00 ask with a limit order of your own at the same price, but there is a risk that it might not go through if someone beats you to it.
- seanhunter 7y agoThink of an order like swiping on tinder. If both sides swipe (are willing to trade at a given level) they go on a date (the buyer's order is "matched" against the seller's and there is a trade). A vol break is like everyone is still able to swipe on tinder but the dating is going to happen in one big bang (pardon the pun) when the market resumes.