4 ms·
Are you suggesting the entire world work from home and interact only over the internet for the rest of our lives? No, of course not. But some people who are e
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Are you suggesting the entire world work from home and interact only over the internet for the rest of our lives?
No, of course not.
But some people who are especially vulnerable can work from home permanently.
We can permanently crack down on things like cashiers licking their fingers to help them open bags.
I have a compromised immune system. The gross behavior of cashiers is one of my single biggest headaches in life. If we recognized how critical a link they are in transmitting disease and took that threat seriously, I imagine people would generally be healthier.
We also can design public bathrooms without doors so you don't have to touch the handle. Walmart has that mastered.
We also can make it more the standard for public bathrooms to have no-touch technology, such as hand dryers and faucets that are motion activated.
We can permanently move to bowing instead of shaking hands. Several older cultures have such practices.
We can more widely adopt the practice of removing our shoes at the front door when we get home rather than tracking dirt all over the house. There are plenty of cultures that do that.
We can move away from wall-to-wall carpeting in most homes in the US. It is not the norm in other countries.
We can move to passive solar design and away from forced air HVAC systems.
I'm suggesting that this isn't a situation where we need to throw our hands up and just be resigned to it being utterly futile. There are many things we can do to reduce the transmission of disease without simply calling a halt to life. And for a professional scientist to suggest otherwise is basically being alarmist because they are stressed out or because the solutions don't fit their mental models of "just pop a pill" or whatever.
They are boring and a lot of them are basically the purview of what housewives historically did. And no one wants to admit housewives did anything of real value.
American culture acts like homemakers and full-time moms are losers and leeches and not actually contributing anything of real value to the economy. A charitable reading of that is that it's a blind spot and people just don't get it.
A less charitable reading is that it's misogynistic BS rooted in intentionally being disrespectful of women and of the value and importance of "women's work" and that people would literally rather die than admit that women's work has real value on par with what important men do, like doctors and scientists. And to whatever degree that is true, the world can now either get over its crap or die due to clinging to it.
A lot of people may die over that. Change tends to occur one funeral at a time because most people stubbornly cling to their ideas and refuse to change.
This can either be an age of enlightenment or a new dark age.
Ain't no big thing. We're all dust in the wind anyway. But the dark path is not the only option.
- frosted-flakes 7y ago> We can more widely adopt the practice of removing our shoes at the front door when we get home rather than tracking dirt all over the house. There are plenty of cultures that do that. Including American and Canadian cultures. Every home I've been in across Canada and the northern US has practiced this. Granted, most of the many people I know are descendants of people from the nordic countries, but is it common for people to wear shoes in the house?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYes, it's common in the US. I always understood it to be the norm, though I don't know if that's actually true any longer. I associate the practice of removing shoes with Asian and Middle Eastern cultures.
- gwd 7y ago> We can... [big list of good ideas] Those all sound like good ideas[1]. But exactly how will those affect the R0 of the virus if we all keep going to the pub, and the club, and church, and the office, and schools, and concerts, and sporting events? Particularly if we ride the bus and the tube and trains and airplanes to get there? Fundamentally, not enough to keep it from saturating the population at least once. And if immunity doesn't last long enough for it to die out after that, not enough to keep it from saturating the population over and over. Which isn't to say we shouldn't do all the things you suggest. But simply slowing things down isn't our ultimate goal. Going back to some semblance or normalcy is our ultimate goal: Perhaps with tiles instead of carpet and bowing instead of shaking hands, sure, but not everyone holed up in their homes permanently. And towards that goal, there's not a clear path. [1] Except for "move to passive solar design", which I didn't really understand.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoPassive solar design relies on things like absorbing heat from the sun and storing the heat in structures with thermal mass instead of burning fuel and forcing air flow to try to heat the home. It actually results in a more comfortable home and higher quality of life. It's more environmentally friendly. It's more sustainable. And it doesn't actively promote sick building syndrome. Please note that Legionnaire's Disease was originally transmitted by the air conditioning system where it was growing. I hate forced air heat with a passion. I currently live in a hundred year old building with a radiator in my unit and it's a huge improvement over most living arrangements I've ever had. Normalcy: For someone in the 1800s, there's absolutely nothing normal about airplane flights, much less for ordinary individuals. There's nothing normal about computers. There's nothing normal about the internet. These things are all basically magic for someone from 150 years ago and we take it all for granted and feel like our lives are being utterly ruined if someone suggests we should maybe curtail our use. I have a form of cystic fibrosis. I've made a lot of the changes I'm talking about. I'm a social creature. I would love to have a "normal" life. The way I live didn't come naturally at all. It was a shotgun wedding. But it was better than the way I had and I am no longer in constant, excruciating pain and I'm no longer on boat loads of drugs and I generally sleep better, I'm more productive and I'm happier. I don't have a whole lot of sympathy for the world's worship of some arbitrary concept of normal. Life routinely adapts or dies. The people telling me that making permanent changes to our current lifestyle in order to not die is some unthinkable and harsh burden may well be among the dead in the near future. And the ones who remain can choose to adapt or die in the next round. It doesn't much matter to me. I already live the life of a germaphobe thanks to my genetic disorder. And I long ago gave up on ever being taken seriously, cared about, etc. So I have enough anger, bitterness and baggage over the past decade of being treated terribly by the world at large that I will be perfectly happy to see some folks go and I've got a mental list of "Hey, universe, maybe you can make sure Coronavirus gets these people soon. Thanks." But go ahead and cling desperately to your ideas about some "normal" life and how amazingly important that is. Maybe someone will mourn the loss of people doing that. But it won't be me. You have a good day. This is probably not a conversation worth pursuing.