4 ms·
I don't think it is a good idea or good tool at all. I don't need or want some external authority to tell me if I'm allowed to leave my house. I used the exampl
by keiferski 7y ago
I don't think it is a good idea or good tool at all. I don't need or want some external authority to tell me if I'm allowed to leave my house. I used the example of "Anti Social" behavior as a joke and I thought that was obvious...but apparently not. The idea is entirely antithetical to a free society.
As someone indicated in another comment, the proper way to do this is through personalized incentives and social encouragement, not through authoritarian state action.
- pishpash 7y agoSure, but what do you have against a personal in-home test? The information should be available at least to the individual.
- keiferski 7y agoNothing, as long as it functions more like a pregnancy test and not something that is sending personal data to a corporation/government somewhere. However, that wasn't the primary idea in the OP, which was specifically about tracking and restricting people based on their test results.
- scotty79 7y ago> I don't need or want some external authority to tell me if I'm allowed to leave my house. In a world full of Covid19 mutations, some even more lethal than the current one you actually might need external authority to tell you if you can leave the house because you yourself will lack technology to asses the risks involved and your decision making even if you have the information might be very dangerous to other peoples freedoms. You still might not want that because people's wants are not necessarily reasonable.
- keiferski 7y agoAs I said in the original comment: > Not every solution to a serious problem needs to be some surveillance state dystopian nightmare. The authoritarian response of shutting everything down, locking people in their homes and instituting all-but-in-name-martial law seems like a massive lack of creativity to me. Plagues are not a new phenomenon. We can come up with better solutions - as Taiwan and Singapore seem to be doing. Throwing away the rights and benefits of a free society should be the last solution.
- scotty79 7y agoAuthority is not authoritarian if it tries to make you do the most scientifically reasonable thing.
- keiferski 7y agoProbably the best thing a woman can do upon discovering that she is pregnant is to see a doctor. Under your argument, it would be ‘scientifically reasonable’ for pregnancy tests to automatically track your name, age, and location, and then send your results to your doctor. Obviously this is a massive violation of privacy...which is exactly the same issue.
- scotty79 7y agoYes. It would. It doesn't not because of sacred privacy, just because technology is not there. Currently tracking is too much of a burden to do at test level and introducing it would harm usage. But when you go to the doctor to confirm pregnancy you can be sure you'll be tracked, because it's easy and it's reasonable thing to do.
- keiferski 7y agoI assure you, no one buying a pregnancy test wants an anonymous corporation or the government to be informed of the results. This has nothing to do with technological feasibility and everything to do with privacy concerns. Your definition of reasonable seems to be pretty warped. The historical abuses of "this opinion is reasonable and scientific" are too heinous and numerous to even list. Thankfully we have (but still need more) consumer privacy laws.
- scotty79 7y agoNo ones wants it. And yet if it comes out positive and you visit the doctor to confirm, it is known to an anonymous corporation, sometimes multiple, and government, if it cares. And everybody is perfectly fine with that. Historical abuses are vast and many in all the fields of human culture. Proportionally to the power of given part of the culture. Abuses don't automatically make given thing completely worthless. Historical abuses are just things that we need to be on the lookout for.
- Sammi 7y agoThere are already a bunch of things you are not allowed to do in a free and democratic society if it is unsafe for other people if you do it. If there exists a home test that can test you for dangerous infectious diseases, and you are forced to take that in the morning before you go out, then this is comparable to not being allowed to drive while under the influence.