4 ms·
It's probably accurate. But the assumption that this is a game changer is more questionable. This variant of CV is fairly infectious and makes some people very
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
It's probably accurate. But the assumption that this is a game changer is more questionable.
This variant of CV is fairly infectious and makes some people very ill. It also kills a non-trivial percentage.
So the worst case is an incredibly dangerous virus that mutates every season. We'd have to get used to taking extreme measures, or losing around 1% of the population every year.
But the usual trend is for viruses to mutate in a less dangerous direction. And immunity isn't binary. It's more like molecular pattern matching with variable memory. So the population as a whole wouldn't be starting from scratch every season - any more than it does with colds or flu, even though they both mutate quickly.
Short term we're likely to have the equivalent of a few years of very bad flu seasons, and longer term that would settle down to a less dangerous cycle - still lethal for some people, but not a perpetual state of danger and crisis.
- lbeltrame 7y ago> We'd have to get used to taking extreme measures Or develop drugs to treat the people who become very sick (up to bilateral interstitial pneumonia) to avoid or reduce hospitalization. On the medium term this looks like a possibility (vaccines, if they work, would help long term). If that happens, I believe your scenario of a "less dangerous cycle" will likely materialize earlier. People would still get sick, but at least we'd be able to treat them.
- scotty79 7y ago> But the usual trend is for viruses to mutate in a less dangerous direction. This trend is for viruses that are in danger of killing their hosts before spreading. This coronavirus is so infectious that it's nowhere near that. Hence it can even mutate into more lethal form without risking its ability to spread.
- nateburke 7y agoMutations are random. What is not random is how human society selects from the pool of random mutations. I am thankful that we do not have a global ground war in progress right now. I believe that political pressure to keep the healthy isolated on the front lines, with the sick going home to society -- this reverse version of containment -- was 1918 society selecting the more lethal mutations for increased reproduction. From this standpoint, the herd immunity and flatten the curve approaches are no different. Both put severe versions of the mutated virus in an a hospital, which is an environment where eventually most hosts will have the virus, effectively deselecting virulence. That said, not overwhelming hospitals probably means having more healthy doctors available for the virus to infect-- a slight selective pressure for virulence. This would be in contrast to herd immunity -- letting both a massive spike of people die along with doctors and then turning hospitals into simple pre-death, low-R_0 isolation wards. The issue there though is that overwhelming hospitals via the herd immunity approach would decrease our ability to learn about the virus scientifically. Our ability to learn about pathogens and modify our behavior accordingly is probably our best hope for survival as a species, I think, so perhaps we should not overwhelm the hospitals with the herd immunity approach.
- scotty79 7y ago> perhaps we should not overwhelm the hospitals with the herd immunity approach. Which is great because that's the same thing everybody selfishly would like to do just to have access to healthcare when he needs it. Everybody in the world seems to understand that except perhaps Boris Johnson.
- Scarblac 7y agoThis virus is so bad that it is making whole countries take quarantine measures. That's probably not optimal for spreading itself.
- scotty79 7y agoEvolution doesn't care directly about spreading. Just about survival and this virus is currently at no danger of being eradicated by measures in effect.