4 ms·
Chinese links didn't matter. Patient-0 in Europe was tracked to Germany in January. The most affected Italian areas do not have a particularly large official or
by toyg 7y ago
Chinese links didn't matter. Patient-0 in Europe was tracked to Germany in January. The most affected Italian areas do not have a particularly large official or unofficial Chinese population - but have massive economic and social links with Germany. The areas where the Chinese concentrate, like the Prato mentioned in your first source, saw no cases - they all voluntarily self-quarantined as soon as the emergency exploded in Wuhan, and kept that discipline going.
Italy simply pays the price of a very elderly and weak population, coupled with a decades-long shrinking of public healthcare. Even in Lombardia, one of the best regions for healthcare, intensive-care units in public hospitals were instructed "in peace time" to run close to capacity as much as possible, in order cut beds and save money. This is how we ended up with less than a third of the capacity of Germany, and when shit hit the fan, it wasn't enough.
(Also, Germany is kinda fudging the numbers. They don't record deaths as Covid-related unless covid was absolutely the only health issue a patient experienced. That's not how victims are recorded in most other countries.)
- seemslegit 7y ago> (Also, Germany is kinda fudging the numbers. They don't record deaths as Covid-related unless covid was absolutely the only health issue a patient experienced. That's not how victims are recorded in most other countries.) That's not just fudging that's outright misleading, any source for this ?
- toyg 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22589306 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22589306
- detaro 7y agoLooking at German news, most reported deaths are reported as having prior complications or having died of other related illnesses, so the blanked statement about "don't record deaths" is clearly not true. If you have sources that it's happening partially, I'd be interested in those though.
- seemslegit 7y agoThey could be reporting those on the news and omitting them from the officially reported data, but this really wouldn't befit Germany.
- toyg 7y agoIt was reported in Italy (obviously in Italian) https://twitter.com/Paolo_Tumolo/status/1237018245552582657/video/1 https://twitter.com/Paolo_Tumolo/status/1237018245552582657/... There are other reports of hundreds of deaths that were simply not tested for the virus, whereas in Italy they've tested pretty much every death since the outbreak in February. Considering that Patient-0 was infected at the end of January, the theory that there might be some under-reporting going on is not unrealistic. Germany probably just had the capacity to deal with this "under the radar" for longer than Italy. This is hardly unique to Germany, btw - each country has adopted different methods to test and report, it will likely take time to get some decent convergence at European level.
- detaro 7y agoCases slipping under the radar, sure, I expect that's happened everywhere to varying degree. But also quite different from not reporting someone that's known to be infected "unless covid was absolutely the only health issue a patient experienced".
- josefx 7y ago> It was reported in Italy (obviously in Italian) https://twitter.com/Paolo_Tumolo/status/1237018245552582657/.. https://twitter.com/Paolo_Tumolo/status/1237018245552582657/.... First: I hate twitter. Second: in a follow up he seems to say (using google translate): > It is EXACTLY what I meant: they charge the deaths to other pathologies present. I don't see many other possible explanations. So he doesn't have proof or even a statistic to point to? He just doesn't see an alternative explanation? Is the newspaper he is working for yellow press?
- freeflight 7y ago> Patient-0 in Europe was tracked to Germany in January. At the end of January, was then promptly isolated and all the contacts informed, also afaik didn't have any history of traveling to Italy [0]. At that point, there were still direct flies going from Wuhan to Italy, as those were only stopped after the German case was discovered. That's why the first positive hit in Italy were two Chinese tourists, on 31 January, who had been in Milan since 23 January [1]. There are 2 countries and several hundred kilometers between the Bavarian January case, and Codogno and Veneto. While those two countries between, Switzerland, and Austria, only started reporting cases late February, a month later. So I don't really ascribe to the idea that COVID-19 came to Italy trough Germany, it probably came there by multiple channels, such is the problem with a pandemic. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_G... [1] https://www.corriere.it/cronache/20_gennaio_30/coronavirus-italia-corona-9d6dc436-4343-11ea-bdc8-faf1f56f19b7.shtml https://www.corriere.it/cronache/20_gennaio_30/coronavirus-i...