4 ms·
To assume good faith in your question: the point is to slow the spread, and to flatten the curve so that the hospital system is not overburdened and that as few
by sneak 7y ago
To assume good faith in your question: the point is to slow the spread, and to flatten the curve so that the hospital system is not overburdened and that as few people as possible that need emergency critical medical care fail to receive it.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> so that the hospital system is not overburdened To go one step further, it's to reduce the mortality rate. Mortality when everyone has access to a respirator is one thing. Mortality when hospitals must deny care to thousands is another. Distancing slows down the rate so we spend more time in the first scenario. (It's too late, now, to entirely avoid it.)
- asjw 7y agoMortality rate in Italy was high only for people 65 and up. But lot more have been brought to hospitals for no real reason, once they were there they couldn't be sent home anymore In fact home confinement has increased a lot once they understood not everyone was in need of medical attention Hell, we even tested people with no symptoms at the beginning because they said they weren't feeling fine or one of their acquittance had flu in the previous week's That of course became immediately problematic for the healthcare system
- easytiger 7y agoThat too is my understanding. Italy really screwed up by turning hospitals into disaster zones. Other countries are not letting people with symptoms near hospitals, even for testing, unless they have severe breathing difficulties
- toyg 7y ago> Mortality rate in Italy was high only for people 65 and up. Part of the reason mortality rates are so high among the elderly, though, is the fact that they are de-prioritized in cases when there is a scarcity of beds, ventilators, or other stuff. Doctors are forced to concentrate efforts on people with better survival chances, which are typically the youngest. > home confinement has increased a lot once they understood not everyone was in need of medical attention This is a double-edged sword though. My father has some contacts in the health service near Bergamo (he was a nurse himself etc etc), and he was told some cases don't even make it to the hospital - they go from cough to full-on pneumonia in less than two hours, and die on the ambulance. They now refer to late afternoon as the critical shift, when the stream of intakes spikes and ensuring they are all treated becomes extremely hard. A lot of these cases might have been saved had they been monitored full-time in a hospital.
- asjw 7y ago> they go from cough to full-on pneumonia in less than two hours, and die on the ambulance From cough to full pneumonia in few ours sounds made up But people with severe pneumonia that die in the ambulance is not rare Pneumonia still kills 13 thousands people every year in Italy Pneumonia has a very high mortality rate, the average for EU is 25/100 thousands while covid-19 is at 2/100 thousands The flu kills between 9 and 10 thousands people every year in Italy Most die home because nobody goes to the doctor for a flu usually If they did, even with light symptoms, we would have the same situation we are having now
- easytiger 7y ago> Pneumonia still kills 13 thousands people every year in Italy In bad epidemic years it kills way more in Italy. 24k in 2017 epidemic You are absolutely right
- asjw 7y ago> Part of the reason mortality rates are so high among the elderly, though, is the fact that they are de-prioritized in cases when there is a scarcity of beds, ventilators, or other stuff. This is absolutely NOT TRUE They died because prior conditions made them weaker and a pneumonia at 84 is as deadly as a bullet in the head Nobody is left to die in Italy My parents have worked in the healthcare for 40 years before retiring, here we try to save everybody at the best of our abilities
- thu2111 7y agoThere's no current scarcity of beds even in Lombardy. Their capacity is (at present) nearly used up, but it's not completely gone yet. And then there's the hospitals in the rest of the country.
- threatofrain 7y agoSo what does that mean in the long run? After virtual lockdown is lifted? A resurgence in winter?
- ForHackernews 7y agoIf we're really lucky, we might have an effective vaccine by early 2021.
- sdkaufman 7y ago- If we can reduce / avoid overloading hospitals, people who get it after the lockdown will get better treatment and will be less likely to die than if they got it now. - Over time, we will come up with more effective treatments and perhaps a vaccine. We will likely also have more equipment like ventilators and protective gear at our disposal. - More people will have had it and built up some level of immunity, and "herd immunity" means it will not spread as quickly.
- mr_toad 7y agoHerd immunity won’t make a significant difference until half the population have had it, and a vaccine could be a year away (if ever).
- threatofrain 7y agoThis also all assumes that the virus won't be quickly mutating. If it is, vaccines and herd immunity will have diminished efficacy.
- avip 7y agoIn the long run we'll have protocols and procedures, and your physician will have seen hundreds of covid cases before treating you, and the fatality rate will (wishfully, possibly) converge to standard seasonal flu.
- easytiger 7y agoSurely then it would make sense to only embargo people in identified vulnerable groups? Let the rest of the nation go about their business given they are very very unlikely to have anything bad happen and then, presumably they will stop being infectious even if the virus does get into their system again And what does it mean to quarantine people? How are they fed? Can they go outside? You can't get the virus walking down the street past an infected person.
- hk__2 7y ago> Surely then it would make sense to only embargo people in identified vulnerable groups? Let the rest of the nation go about their business given they are very very unlikely to have anything bad happen and then, presumably they will stop being infectious even if the virus does get into their system again Vulnerable or not, the rest of the nation is a transmission vector. Also, not all deaths happen among the identified vulnerable groups: "they are very very unlikely to have anything bad happen" is completely false.
- easytiger 7y agoIt's not false. The rates of mortality being quoted are fundamentally wrong because testing is highly selective. I personally know people who likely have it, haven't been tested and so don't get counted. The virus is clearly more widespread than 200k infected who have actually been tested.
- Zach_the_Lizard 7y ago> Also, not all deaths happen among the identified vulnerable groups: "they are very very unlikely to have anything bad happen" is completely false. Even assuming a 4% death rate (too high for the less vulnerable), that's a 96% chance of not having the worst possible consequences. So I'd say that's "very unlikely" for them. This isn't the flu, and it's possible for even people in their teens to die (true of the flu as well), but let's not act like it's the likely outcome. I've seen numbers in the 0.2% range for younger (< 39) age cohorts. That's twice as deadly as the flu (0.1%) but IMO not "shut society down" levels of bad for people in that age group.
- 7y ago