4 ms·
> OK... but... isn't that what everyone is being advised to do right now? No. What everyone is advised to do right now is not to withdraw from society, it's to
by masklinn 7y ago
> OK... but... isn't that what everyone is being advised to do right now?
No. What everyone is advised to do right now is not to withdraw from society, it's to perform basic hygiene and social distancing in order to slow down the spread. Social distancing doesn't mean living like a recluse eating spam cooked on a gas burner, it's not getting into large crowds and trying to stay some distance from other people (outside spitting / coughing range). WaPo has an article with a "social distancing" simulator: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/corona-simulator/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/corona-si...
"Self quarantining" is closer to what you're talking about, but it's for people who are at risk or likely to have been infected, not the general public.
Of course the latter you start the more it's already spread and the harsher measures have to be. And the more you'll have to ramp them up as you realise your initial measures were not sufficient, or your citizens have decided "freedom or death" is a good choice and decide to just ignore it.
FWIW Taiwan's already reopened its schools and life has gone back to something not entirely dissimilar to normal (people do have to wear masks and get their temperature checked to step into public buildings or businesses but they can move around just fine).
- derefr 7y ago> it's not getting into large crowds and trying to stay some distance from other people (outside spitting / coughing range) ...which presumes you don't live in a place with high-enough urban density that going outside your home immediately puts you into a large crowd. Like, what are you supposed to do if you live in Manila? Mumbai? Dhaka? Pretty much the only way to "practice social distancing" in those sorts of places is to never go outside.
- alkonaut 7y agoSocial distancing is just minimizing contact, not avoiding all contact (self-isolation/quarantining). E.g. try to go out for groceries once a week and pick a time to avoid the crowds. > what are you supposed to do if you live in Manila? Mumbai? Dhaka? Rejoice that you are with 99% certainty way under 70 years old.
- massysett 7y agoNo, it means don't go to football matches. Don't go to cinema. Don't go to a convention. Don't ride on a train for a leisure trip. That the distancing can't be done 100% perfectly does not mean that all distancing is worthless and therefore that NO distancing should even be attempted. Even slowing the spread of the illness may be worthwhile.
- jrochkind1 7y agoDon't go over to friends houses? I am getting mixed messages, I'm not sure why I think asking for another opinion on the internet will help, but there it is.
- baq 7y agoyou want to be a part of this effort? don't go.
- spookthesunset 7y agoLink to an established authority saying not to occasionally visit friends or you are spreading panic.
- baq 7y agoitalian and spanish prime ministers good enough for you? don't have better at hand, sorry
- jrochkind1 7y agoIt's not that it's necessarily "spreading panic" but that "believe whoever you want on the internet" is not an effective public health communications strategy. But that appears to be what we've got. The shaming approach of "you want to be part of this effort?" (whatever that means) is unlikely to be an effective communications strategy either. I don't know why I asked, I already had my choice of various opinions on the internet (usually given from a position of moral superiority and judgement). I seriously don't understand why the U.S. public health infrastructure is failing so horribly here; if you want to maximize compliance, it seems obvious that you should be giving consistent and pervasive instructions, there should be literally a planned "marketting" campaign, with a consistent message. If people are getting different messages from different places of course they will be confused and compliance will be less. Instead, we have "which chain letter on facebook and/or shaming and blaming comment on HN does my gut tell me seems right?" What the fuck America.
- baq 7y agoMetro Manila, a region of 12 million people, entered a month-long lockdown on Sunday as Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte considers a plan to impose a curfew on the area to try to contain the coronavirus outbreak. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-15/manila-enters-lockdown-for-month-duterte-mulls-curfew-on-virus https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-15/manila-en...
- alkonaut 7y agoYes, but the UK does call far social distancing as much as any other place? And likely soon self-quarantine for 70+ and other risk groups. I thought the UK (and Sweden, Finland etc) differed mostly in not closing schools yet. Are there other significant differences?
- asutekku 7y agoUntil a day or so ago Boris Johnson advocated for a herd immunity when it was not proved to be true for Corona. So no, it did not call for same social distancing as other countries.
- alkonaut 7y agoHerd immunity and social distancing aren't exclusive. You want both. Is it true that he called for no social distancing? Is there a summary of the current recommendations? I mean surely gatherings etc are banned? Football is already cancelled, for example, as in other countries?
- tigershark 7y agoHe didn’t do anything at all. Football was cancelled independently by the football league or whatever it is called some days later, boris was advocating for no action at all and even football and st Patrick parade where actively encouraged.
- alkonaut 7y agoWhat are relevant UK authorities saying? Who’s at the wheel here, politicians or authorities/experts?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tigershark 7y agoNo, they said to do nothing different from normal at all, unless you are over 70 or you have cough. Guess who jumped from 10 deaths per day from yesterday to 14 per day today almost doubling the deads for two days in a row?
- dirtydroog 7y agoTry not getting into a large crowd at any point of your commute into London!
- tigershark 7y agoI’m wfh for 1 week now and luckily before I wasn’t in London.
- tromp 7y agoNow may be the best time to try commuting by bike if you can.
- SirensOfTitan 7y agoPlural anecdotes, but: most folks I’ve seen on social media, Reddit, friends very much have interpreted “social distancing” as withdrawing from society. On the NYC and coronavirus subreddits the consensus seems to be that you’re a selfish piece of garbage if you leave the house for any non-essential reason. The bully pulpit is supremely important in these situations, and no government so far seems to have used it responsibly to disseminate a consistent message early enough to citizenry. Worse yet, in the US ones politics seems to be particularly predictive of opinion on coronavirus. My current feeling is that the virus was not taken seriously when action could have mattered, and now the goal of government and citizenry is to reduce the carnage to both medically vulnerable folks (old people) and to economically vulnerable people. The latter risk in particular scares me, as there are many folks in the US who are going to be severely impacted by politicians reacting severely way too late who are too cowardly to protect those vulnerable people adequately.