4 ms·
> But really, whether anyone believes this can be viewed through a very different lens: multiple times in the past week, US exchanges have ceased trading due to
by loeg 7y ago
> But really, whether anyone believes this can be viewed through a very different lens: multiple times in the past week, US exchanges have ceased trading due to automatic circuit breakers from 7% drops in the market. Surely if the market is all knowing we shouldn't trigger these mechanisms and instead just let the invisible perfect hand let people sell stocks freely.
Yes, you're basically right despite intending to be sarcastic. The circuit breakers are stupid and there's no real good reason for them to exist. Levine:
> The basic idea of stock-market circuit breakers is, like, some news happens, and the market reacts precipitously, and stocks fall 7%, and the market gets turned off for 15 minutes so that everyone can have some time to think and digest the news and see if they want to buy. On an average Tuesday afternoon, not everyone who might want to buy stocks is watching the market every minute. The computers are, sure, but some long-term investors are busy doing other things, reading 10-Ks or meeting with executives or whatever. Someone needs to call them up and say “hey not sure if you noticed but stocks are cheap now, you should buy some.”
> But you generally want to do this sort of thing through mechanical bright-line rules, and occasionally those rules get applied in kind of weird circumstances. The market did not fall 7% by 9:34 a.m. today because of shocking news that came out at 9:32! Investors had all weekend to ponder coronavirus news, and all of Sunday to ponder oil-price news, and they pondered it at their leisure, and futures traded limit-down, and then the stock market opened and investors applied their weekend’s worth of pondering to the market, with the result that the market shut down four minutes later. A weekend of pondering, four minutes of trading, 15 more minutes of pondering. I am not sure what you learned in the 15 minutes that you didn’t learn over the weekend.
Back to you:
> Nor is anyone questioning why it was suddenly urgent that the government put $USD1.5 trillion of liquidity into the market.
The government didn't do that. It loaned $1.5T over a very short term to banks. It was not targeted at the stock market and had no impact there.
- XorNot 7y ago> The government didn't do that. It loaned $1.5T over a very short term to banks. It was not targeted at the stock market and had no impact there. But if the free market should be allowed to run unimpeded, why did the government need to intervene here, when apparently in the provision of basic necessities you are arguing this is going too far?
- loeg 7y agoBanks are some of the most highly regulated businesses that participate in markets. One should not draw general conclusions from government intervention in regulated banking programs. > when apparently in the provision of basic necessities you are arguing this is going too far? I made no such argument.