3 ms·
> Sidenote - stating that "you will find most people will agree with me" is an, um, interesting method of argument. Not at all. That is the standard for determ
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> Sidenote - stating that "you will find most people will agree with me" is an, um, interesting method of argument.
Not at all. That is the standard for determining what something means.
What you're saying here is that I expressed an idea, you agree with me as to both what I meant by it and what other people would understand by it, but, for unstated reasons, you think my expression was metaphysically incorrect. Why?
The project of communication is for the listener to understand the same thing the speaker intended. If that happens, the communication was correct. As applied here, if I think "responsible for a flow of money", elucidated by a negative example, means something, and everyone else agrees with me that it means that thing... then that is in fact what it means. Words hold their meaning by common agreement, and solely by common agreement.