3 ms·
What would testing easily available for all mean for the control of the disease? When vaccines or even treatment is still a while away, could this help? E.g. i
by alkonaut 7y ago
What would testing easily available for all mean for the control of the disease? When vaccines or even treatment is still a while away, could this help?
E.g. if a country could test 10% of the population in a month, wouldn't that help the "everyone is a potential bearer"-lockdowns we see now and help achieve some normality? Or is mass testing too expensive or wasteful? Or would the information not be valuable enough to do it?
- mlyle 7y agoRTPCR has way too high of a false negative rate to do anything of the sort. It's about 70% sensitive on a nasal swab of symptomatic patients-- in other words 30% false negative rate. Asymptomatic patients may have even a lower sensitivity. Some of this may be sensitivity of early tests, but it's mostly that not everyone who has the virus has copious amounts of it in their snot all of the time.
- YZF 7y agoIsn't this why they run tests twice?
- mlyle 7y agoThere are patients that are even negative on multiple test runs. Each measurement is not an independent measurement. We can't really solve this problem by testing multiple times, even if the measurements are spread in time. The point is, testing everyone may be useful in slowing spread-- may be able to prove people as infectious and needing isolation. But it is not useful in proving people safe.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bosie 7y agoFood for though: if you are asymptomatic and test positive, you self-isolate as to not spread the disease further. Same for when you are symptomatic but not showing symptoms yet. Point is to change the behavior of the individual.
- simonh 7y agoYou can test someone, find they are clear, and the next day they get infected. You’d have to re-test people on a daily basis.
- alkonaut 7y agoYes you don’t test to prove people uninfected but to find those infected without symptoms so they self quarantine. The people crowding bars in NYC right now probably would have stayed home if they knew they were infected. You might also be able to use the stats to identify hotspots where a temporary lockdown or travel restrictions can make sense.