7 ms·
I’m going to try and lay out the case in as neutral terms as I can, although to be clear I think they are probably right. They’re going to take an awful lot of
by simonh 7y ago
I’m going to try and lay out the case in as neutral terms as I can, although to be clear I think they are probably right. They’re going to take an awful lot of stick for it though, and indeed already are.
They believe that there are basically two mitigation strategies. One is to have a very drastic early lockdown that shuts down the virus before it spreads widely. The problem with that is, once you lift the lockdown it will simply start all over again. The problem with this is lockdowns are most effective the first time you do them, and then mostly in the first few weeks of the lockdown. Do it too early, and yes it will be very effective in the short term, but later on when cases become much more prevalent the lockdowns will be less effective.
The option they are going for is to start the lockdown a little later in the cycle. The hope is this will make the lockdown more effective at a higher point in the spread. Effectively instead of a series of booms and busts, you get one longer slower initial burn and then you’re mostly done. They believe that in the long term this will make it easier to protect those most vulnerable to the virus, because you only have to do it once, at the cost of increased prevalence among people least vulnerable to it. So they see it as a better longer term strategy.
- knzhou 7y agoBut there's a third strategy that works better than either: don't lockdown, but do effective testing, case tracking, and treatment, well enough so that exponential growth can't happen in the first place. That's the policy of Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Singapore, who are doing great.
- simonh 7y agoThat’s a very good point, you’re quite right. However all three of those are relatively very small population centres with very easily controlled borders. Britain does have the advantage of being an island, but it has a large rural hinterland that the virus can ‘hide out’ in, and many dense population centres without borders, so it’s a completely different environment. Take London. We could introduce a system of tracking and isolation within the M25, and that might work to lock down community transmission within the London population, but millions of people flow into and out of London each week so it would be completely pointless and ineffective. Meanwhile that level of tracking and isolation simply can’t work across the whole British isles. It’s administratively and logistically impractical.
- Marsymars 7y ago> millions of people flow into and out of London each week so it would be completely pointless and ineffective Was curious about this point in particular - checked the numbers, and Heathrow has essentially equivalent traffic as Hong Kong International.
- dmurray 7y agoThere are 5 other international airports that call themselves "London", not just Heathrow. And of course London also has road and train connections.
- simonh 7y agoI was mainly thinking about road and rail traffic into and out of the city, including daily commuters.
- willyt 7y agoThe equivalent of the entire population of Glasgow passes through Kings Cross station in the morning rush hour. There are 4 other stations with similar flows. Over 20 million people live within an hour or 30 miles of Piccadilly Circus.
- endogui 7y agoThat level of population flow and population density are not as special as you are making them out to be. The transfer station nearest Seoul's most recent cluster (discovered 7 days ago) gets about 25% more annual traffic than King's Cross, according to Wikipedia (125,000 per day at Sindorim Station vs. 34 million at King's Cross annually). Despite the cluster having developed at the beginning of March, Seoul is finding fewer than 100 new patients per day. With masks, reduction in ridership, cancellation of meetings, extensive WFH, extensive testing and isolation measures, this epidemic is not as hopeless as the UK seems to be making it out to be.
- willyt 7y ago
- Silhouette 7y agoThat's the policy of Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Singapore, who are doing great. All of which have tiny populations compared to the UK. For larger nations, there simply aren't enough tests available, nor enough treatment facilities for those who are likely to become very sick if the virus spreads rapidly through the population.
- knzhou 7y ago> For larger nations, there simply aren't enough tests available Why? If your nation is twice as big, then all else equal, your government has twice as much money, twice as many resources, and hence twice as many tests. China now has more tests than they need and they're the 2nd most populous nation in the world.
- Silhouette 7y agoNo amount of money helps if there aren't enough tests available to buy. What is missing are manufacturing and distribution facilities, which of course are calibrated to the normal levels of work and not to a relatively sudden pandemic outbreak of one particular virus. China has huge resources but has managed so far to keep the infection mostly contained to one specific area. It's not clear how long they'll be able to sustain that or whether they'd have enough resources to go around if all of China were the same as Hubei. Of course all of this also assumes that tests are effective and that you can then do something useful if you confirm that a patient is indeed infected.
- AlchemistCamp 7y ago> All of which have tiny populations compared to the UK. Is 66 million really that qualitatively different than 24 million?
- Silhouette 7y agoThe honest answer is that I don't know. Perhaps I generalised too readily before, given Taiwan is quite a bit closer to the UK in population than the other two. Even so, assuming that strategies that appear to have been relatively successful in a smaller, more densely populated country will necessarily also work in a larger and less densely populated one seems to be dubious. We know that we don't have the resources we'd need to implement that strategy in the UK right now, and I haven't personally seen any experts arguing that it's a viable option for us, so I'm cautious about extrapolating too much here.
- ksec 7y agoThere are quite a few difference. HK, Taiwan and Singapore all acted extremely early on, to the point where HK knew before the news broke out in China. And the culture allows you to wear mask, which seems to be something most western nation are completely against. Most part of Europe and UK reacted very late in the cycle. Since the Virus has an extremely long stable period before any symptoms appeared or to the point where you could be infected but showing no symptoms at all. It highly likely they are already in wide spread. 500 people each inflecting two, do that 11 times and we have 1 million infected. Then there is the death rate, at least so far it seems to be extremely mild for anyone below 50. Not saying I totally agree with Herd Immunity, but judging from the current data and situation it is possibly the best route to go.
- cactus2093 7y agoIsn’t that the whole point of a lockdown? After ~6-8 weeks you get the new infection rates down low enough that you basically reset the clock and have a second chance at responding like Hong Kong and keeping it in the containment phase. Then you have to keep that up for hopefully 9 months until a vaccine is available. It’s certainly not easy, but it seems possible and it’s not clear this would be much worse on the economy in the long run. Plus it saves half a million lives, so it seems like a moral imperative to at least try.
- ksec 7y ago>Isn’t that the whole point of a lockdown? You will need a Lockdown AND Mask, or you will simply just need Mask and not even lockdown. I would argue social distancing only is not enough. But somehow even people in Italy refuse to wear mask. So I think a culture issue is also a problem there.
- lukevdp 7y agoI don’t think masks are as effective as you think. WHO says only wear a mask: If you are healthy, you only need to wear a mask if you are taking care of a person with suspected 2019-nCoV infection. Wear a mask if you are coughing or sneezing. Masks are effective only when used in combination with frequent hand-cleaning with alcohol-based hand rub or soap and water. If you wear a mask, then you must know how to use it and dispose of it properly. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/advice-for-public/when-and-how-to-use-masks https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2...
- twic 7y agoIt's far too early to say whether they're doing great. Several months too early. Their lockdowns are preventing virus spread now, but at some point, the lockdowns will end, and then there is a vulnerable population waiting to be infected by a carrier coming from abroad. Will they be able to keep carriers out? Will they be able to respond to further outbreaks with more lockdowns indefinitely? Will there be a vaccine soon enough that they can protect everyone and then end the lockdowns before it all goes wrong? I don't know enough to say that the UK strategy is correct (i hope it is - i live here, and more importantly, so do my parents). But i think the situation isn't cut and dried. Hopefully, we will get a lot more detail in the next few days, and then the real experts can come to a consensus.
- hellotomyrars 7y agoI would rather have the spread stopped/slowed domestically with aggressive measures than to do little to nothing to stop the spread thinking it will somehow solve the problem. The UK approach here is basically just accepting that a majority of the population is going to get infected by design. That's fine. It might even be true. (It obviously will be if you don't do anything to stop it, but even in aggressive lockdowns I mean) But it benefits nobody to have it spread quicker. Maybe life in the UK gets back to normal a little faster for people who are not at-risk or aren't treated at risk but we live in a very global society and if everyone else is locked down then it's hard to see much benefit for the UK itself. And your parents and the portion of the population who are most vulnerable are more at risk. An imperfect defense is better than not even trying.
- thu2111 7y agoThere won't ever be a consensus of experts. That whole concept is one I've really come to hate over the years. When it comes to decisions about what to do, versus the outcome of replicable experiments on nature in lab conditions, there is always disagreement and there always will be. The idea that any decision can be resolved by a bunch of scientists sitting in a committee beard stroking doesn't reflect how people really work. Amongst other problems, the term "expert" is ill defined (see discussion above about mathematicians) and there's always value in contrarianism for people who aren't directly making decisions. If they're wrong nobody will remember and there's nearly no reputational impact. If they're right, they can win fame and glory.
- mrtksn 7y agoDo you have sources for these claims?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 7y ago> The problem with that is, once you lift the lockdown it will simply start all over again. Well, no, because the world at the end of the lockdown is not the same as the world before the disease started spreading. Some differences: - People now know there is a dangerous disease and how to act and sanitize to mitigate its spread. - Manufacturing and other logistics for medical providers have had the time of the lockdown to ramp up. - Testing has had the time of the lockdown to ramp up. - A vaccine is that much further along--which is the only viable long-term strategy. - And most important, scientific understanding of the disease has had that much longer to develop. Britain's "expose the youngsters" strategy has a terrible flaw, which is that we don't know if the disease is actually safe for young people! All we know are some basic statistics about messy data that was reported by overwhelmed medical systems with spotty testing. There are reliable reports of a) some young people getting very sick from this disease, b) people who seem to have recovered going back into decline and in some cases death, and c) long-term lung damage among those who did not die. The ideas that this disease is somehow safe for young people, and that contracting it once confers long-term immunity, are ideas that are yet to be scientifically proven. They are, for now, at best heuristics to aid triage.
- listsfrin 7y agoDo you have some links with reliable reports of young people getting sick and other cases you told?
- SyneRyder 7y agoSingapore has had a handful of cases of children getting it. A six-month old caught it and took nearly three weeks to recover: https://co.vid19.sg/cases/singapore-case-28-6-month-old-male-singapore-citizen https://co.vid19.sg/cases/singapore-case-28-6-month-old-male... A 5 year-old was in hospital for six days, but has been discharged today: https://co.vid19.sg/cases/singapore-case-160-5-year-old-male-singapore-citizen https://co.vid19.sg/cases/singapore-case-160-5-year-old-male... A 17-year old evacuated from Wuhan tested positive, but never showed any symptoms during the 3 weeks he was quarantined despite having the virus: https://co.vid19.sg/cases/singapore-case-23-17-year-old-male-singapore-citizen https://co.vid19.sg/cases/singapore-case-23-17-year-old-male... (There's more cases that can be explored on the Singaporean website.)
- mitchdoogle 7y agoIt seems like trying to time the stock market. You can make an educated guess, but in the end it's still a guess.
- peteradio 7y agoUnless, oh I don't know, you test for the disease.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post duplicate comments to HN (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22577808 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22577808). It strictly lowers the signal/noise ratio and makes merging threads a nightmare.
- gimboland 7y agoMerging threads?
- nkurz 7y agoSometimes there are two (or more) threads for what is essentially the same story. When this happens, Dan (or one of the other moderators) frequently chooses one thread to keep, and copies the comments from the thread(s) to be deleted into the thread to be kept. If commenters have already posted the same comment to both threads, this requires more manual cleanup by the moderators. There's a lot of moderation that happens behind the scenes here to keep the site as usable as it is.
- dang 7y agoAs nkurz said. See also: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20merge&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20signal%20duplicate&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoWhy would operating as normal and mostly ignoring the problem cause a "slower initial burn"? It won't. This is nonsense of the most obvious kind, because we're already past the stage where the virus is spreading quickly. In fact the reverse is likely to be true. Lockdown minimises the number with the disease, but that number is not zero. Which means that if immunity is possible (questionable for a CV, but let's pretend), immunity will spread wider and wider in each lockdown wave - and the health system won't be swamped. This plays for time, raising the odds that a vaccine or some other treatment will appear. Successive lockdowns will do exactly what they're supposed to do - spread out the peaks, minimise casualties over time, and minimise health system stress. (Although it will still be very high.) What they won't do is keep businesses afloat. Mass bankruptcies are going to be a huge problem throughout the entire global economy. Other countries understand this, and are stepping in with financial measures to help. Presumably the UK doesn't want to do this. The tell is the fact that the government has plans to quarantine for four months - i.e. place under house arrest - over-70s who are infected. Without access to intensive care - it won't be available if the NHS is swamped - the mortality rate in this demographic is going to be higher than that of any other developed country. It could easily be twice the nominal 15% CFR for this demo in China. It's hard to avoid the conclusion that the real plan is to cull the old and sick while pretending that's not happening.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ascorbic 7y agoThey're not operating as normal: they're telling anyone with a cough to self-isolate for seven days. And the plan isn't to quarantine over 70s who are infected: it's to quarantine them all, when they're not infected.
- Neil44 7y agoI believe the current UK Gov’s huge majority and long remaining term allow them to make decisions that many other countries would not be able to make at this time. I think they’re right, not that this makes things any easier, both my parents are in their mid 70’s and have health problems.
- egr 7y agoAs far as I know, they did not communicate an overall strategy or comprehensive action plan. The basis of this thread are a series of tweets making assumptions about what the government strategy could be (given a lack of measures taken as a basis). I do not understand how not communicating a comprehensive action plan is meant to be the harder choice ("a decision many other countries [...] not able to make") when contrasted with messures such as declaring national emergencies and widespread lockdowns of public life.
- thu2111 7y agoThey held a press conference live streamed on YouTube where the PM and the two chief scientific advisors answered questions and explained their strategy for nearly an hour. The answer to one question alone took over ten minutes. You may not be aware of their communication about their strategy but it's on YouTube waiting for you.
- tigershark 7y agoThat hour long press conference, that I’ve seen live, can be condensed in don’t do anything at all, let’s get 60% of the population infected so we’ll have herd immunity.
- egr 7y agoThe lockdown as implemented by Italy and France aims at slowing down the spreading of the virus. It is not meant as a strategy to overcome the virus. It is meant to flatten the curve of the exponential growth of infection to minimize overloading the health system and to provide more time for preparation and for the acquisition of best practices regarding the situation. There is no disillusion that this might somehow stop the virus. The expected total infected percentage of population, with lockdowns is still in the range of 50-60%. Italy went into lockdown on March 9th when # of new cases reached 1791 and total deaths was 463. This does not seem to qualify as a very drastic early lockdown, as stated by parent. Given everything we know regarding exponential spread, the high percentage of cases requiring icu treatment, and the mortality rate, I fail to see how the absence of any measures to mitigate the spreading of the virus makes sense. The assumption that there are only two viable strategies, lockdown & no measures, is a plain wrong oversimplification. There is a wide range of intermediary steps that can be taken in between to attempt to slow down the virus. Attempting to minimize the degree of overload on the health system by applying such measures in a coordinated fashion is meant to reduce casualties caused by system overload.
- simonh 7y agoThose are good points. Because Italy was hit hardest first they had very little time to prepare. The UK has had about an extra month, which puts us in a different strategic position, so we might be able to afford an approach not viable for Italy.
- golem14 7y agoHow does the UK have an extra month, exactly ? It did not take Italy 1 month to to go from 1,143 (today's UK number) positives to 21,157 (today's Italy number, per https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6 https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.h...), did it ?
- andy_ppp 7y agoTesting in Italy was far less, the totals for there need to be inferred from the deaths and cases and the amount of testing!