3 ms·
That’s a very good point, you’re quite right. However all three of those are relatively very small population centres with very easily controlled borders. Brita
by simonh 7y ago
That’s a very good point, you’re quite right. However all three of those are relatively very small population centres with very easily controlled borders. Britain does have the advantage of being an island, but it has a large rural hinterland that the virus can ‘hide out’ in, and many dense population centres without borders, so it’s a completely different environment.
Take London. We could introduce a system of tracking and isolation within the M25, and that might work to lock down community transmission within the London population, but millions of people flow into and out of London each week so it would be completely pointless and ineffective. Meanwhile that level of tracking and isolation simply can’t work across the whole British isles. It’s administratively and logistically impractical.
- Marsymars 7y ago> millions of people flow into and out of London each week so it would be completely pointless and ineffective Was curious about this point in particular - checked the numbers, and Heathrow has essentially equivalent traffic as Hong Kong International.
- dmurray 7y agoThere are 5 other international airports that call themselves "London", not just Heathrow. And of course London also has road and train connections.
- simonh 7y agoI was mainly thinking about road and rail traffic into and out of the city, including daily commuters.
- willyt 7y agoThe equivalent of the entire population of Glasgow passes through Kings Cross station in the morning rush hour. There are 4 other stations with similar flows. Over 20 million people live within an hour or 30 miles of Piccadilly Circus.
- endogui 7y agoThat level of population flow and population density are not as special as you are making them out to be. The transfer station nearest Seoul's most recent cluster (discovered 7 days ago) gets about 25% more annual traffic than King's Cross, according to Wikipedia (125,000 per day at Sindorim Station vs. 34 million at King's Cross annually). Despite the cluster having developed at the beginning of March, Seoul is finding fewer than 100 new patients per day. With masks, reduction in ridership, cancellation of meetings, extensive WFH, extensive testing and isolation measures, this epidemic is not as hopeless as the UK seems to be making it out to be.
- willyt 7y agoI completely agree. I was shocked to hear that only people that present with symptoms that require hospital treatment are now being tested.