11 ms·
Am I more likely to use the Xoom than the iPad? Yes. The hardware is faster but more importantly, the software is better suited for multitasking. I’m a bigger f
by bane 16y ago
Am I more likely to use the Xoom than the iPad? Yes. The hardware is faster but more importantly, the software is better suited for multitasking. I’m a bigger fan of Honeycomb’s multitasking UI & notification system compared to the double-tap-home and passive notifications you get with the iPad and iOS. I can be more productive with the Xoom than I can be with the iPad as a result. I don’t believe Honeycomb’s UI is perfect by any means, it’s just more multitasking oriented than iOS is at this point.
It's like watching all the lessons we learned about multitasking in the early 90s coming true all over again...and once again Apple is running a hair behind the competition due to various architecture decisions.
I have hope that we'll see a new iOS in a year or two though that does multitasking and notifications correctly (or at least in an appropriately Apply way).
There's still tons of room for Apple to leapfrog over Honeycomb without too much work since I'd argue that Honeycomb is the first version of the OS to out and out compete with iOS. iOS today is really a number of subtle tweaks to the original, some refinements here, a new gesture there, etc. Apple has got to have something big in the works that'll push their stuff into the next generation.
- rimantas 16y agoI don't think multitasking helps productivity…
- trotsky 16y agoI agree. And to make sure I don't forget that, I exited chrome, started a shell, started vi, added your statement to a file of quotes I keep, exited vi, exited the shell, started chrome again, logged back in to HN and posted this response.
- smackfu 16y agoDepends on whether your task requires one app or two. One app, you are right. Two apps, ha!
- rimantas 16y agoGetting close. We are talking tablets there, I'd argue typical tasks on them involve only single app.
- cryptoz 16y agoTablets have only been around in their present form for a few months. This particular tablet has been around for a few hours. Don't you think it's a bit too early to argue about what "typical tasks" on them will be? Give it some time before suggesting you know exactly how users will use their tablets.
- rimantas 16y agoYah, I am pretty sure in the next year or two we will see that most typical use case for tablets will be vi/emacs, not web browsing, e-books and consumption of information in general. On the serious note, I am pretty sure single-app-for-single task will be dominant paradigm on tablets. And just take a look at some features of OS X 10.7… Are you seriously suggesting that switching apps makes you more productive?
- cryptoz 16y agoI was responding to your post above, specifically you said > I'd argue typical tasks on them involve only single app I think that's absolutely ridiculous. I don't know about "productivity" since even defining that is a bit vague. I'm not trying to comment on productivity. I'm suggesting that most users will be multitasking frequently on their tablets; or they might not be and it's just too early to know either way! Take for example what I expect to be a pretty typical use case. You pull your tablet out and start watching YouTube videos. You've got one app open now - YouTube. An email notification comes in from a friend, it's about a funny incident found on Street View (or something). So you click on the link. You've now got three apps open: Gmail, YouTube, and Maps. The email distracted you from the YouTube video, so now that you're done with streetview you hit up HN. Four apps. Maybe you'll go back to the YouTube video. How will you do that? On iOS you have to leave the current app - I think, I don't own any iOS devices - then slide around your homescreen until you find YouTube, then open it up. The idea behind Android 3.0's multitasking is that you have an easy-to-access list of running applications and tasks. I'm not suggesting people will be seriously coding on Android tablets anytime soon (but that'll happen eventually...), but I think it's pretty clear that users will very much enjoy having many things going at the same time.
- jbm 16y agoCan someone please explain to me why this was modded down? I'm curious, as I am unaware of the Apple multitasking history. (Had an 8086, and an Apple II at school; never encountered apple again until after I got an iPod and then an iPhone)
- ugh 16y agoRecently someone compared weird downvotes to cosmic rays. They are going to strike but they are mostly harmless. Upvote back and carry on. On topic: I’m not sure whether architectural decisions hamper iOS multitasking – it seems to me that the UI for multitasking in iOS just isn’t very good [0]. There are some edge cases where true multitasking would be great but I think that Apple is for the most part facing an UI problem, not an architectural problem. [0] There isn’t much of a multitasking UI, actually. There is this horribly inaccessible row of recently accessed app icons and nothing else. If only it weren’t beneath Apple to shamelessly copy WebOS or Android.
- loire280 16y agoI suspect most people never noticed the addition of multitasking in iOS. Suddenly Pandora didn't stop playing when they checked a mail message and their apps reopened much faster, but they probably credited/blamed the app developers for that. I wonder what percentage of users don't even know about the double-click-home menu. I think multitasking UIs on touch devices (where apps are usually 100% of the screen) are more confusing for users than just going back to the icon on the home screen. Users get that more than one thing is running at a time in a windowed environment -- you can see both of them at the same time if you position your windows properly. I'm not sure they bring that understanding along when they pick up a tablet.
- bane 16y agoI don't totally disagree but multitasking doesn't have to be only user-facing apps. The notification system in Android is light-years ahead of iOS and it relies entirely on having a good multi-tasking environment. Importantly, the notifications don't have to just be from some specific set of things-that-can-notify a user as chosen by Google. Pretty much any kind of app can notify a user of anything. In theory iOS is more than capable of supporting this on the backend, but the front end architecture is a mess and would have to be significantly reworked for even this kind of basic thing (well, it seems basic on an Android device it seems so obvious there).
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Raphael 16y agoWill iOS ever have alternate launcher support? It makes Android a chameleon that can look and behave any way. Also, the "intents" system that allows the appropiate app to take over at any time is powerful.