4 ms·
One response from a particle phycisist to this story can be found over at the PhysicsForums[1]. A couple of the main objections: First, I consider having theo
by magicalhippo 7y ago
One response from a particle phycisist to this story can be found over at the PhysicsForums[1].
A couple of the main objections:
First, I consider having theorists publishing based on preliminary experimental data bad practice and borderline unethical. The experiments say "we're not sure and we're checking this", and the theorists go full speed ahead, often putting words in the experimenters' mouths.
Now, let's look at what happened. The experiment ran in 2015 and saw no events. Then the accelerator and detector made some configuration changes (hoping that they would be improvements) and got 1.5x as much data. They see 4 events, one of which they say is certainly background. They also say that the known backgrounds sum to 0,05. So just looking at background, they see 20x as much as they expect. Clearly the backgrounds are not yet under control. Declaring an observation of signal when the backgrounds are not under control would be scientifically irresponsible, which is why KOTO did not do that.
[1]: https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/rare-kaon-decay-may-shed-light-on-new-physics-maybe.985147/post-6306682 https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/rare-kaon-decay-may-sh...
- empath75 7y agoI don’t feel like it’s unethical to write a paper along the lines of “If this is not noise, then such and such theory could explain it.” Then people could make judgements about further consequences of that theory and whether it makes more sense for the theory to be correct or for it to be noise.