2 ms·
Well, from the perspective of the buyer it doesn't matter if you're buying it for 20x the price from CVS or from Joe Schmoe Markup Inc. It matters to CVS, but t
by whatshisface 7y ago
Well, from the perspective of the buyer it doesn't matter if you're buying it for 20x the price from CVS or from Joe Schmoe Markup Inc. It matters to CVS, but that's their problem.
- gpm 7y agoNo, it matters to the buyer, and everyone else, because that one transaction doesn't exist in a vacuum. If the buyer is giving the factory an extra 19x the price, the factory is incentivized to produce more, the buyer is substantially more likely to be able to buy more then next time they want to. Averaged over society the buyer is much more likely to be able to buy whatever they need the next time they need to buy anything. If it's Joe Schmoe Markup Inc getting the extra 19x the price, there is no benefit to society or the buyer. Joe Schmoe is just an asshole profiting off of making other people worse off. That should be criminal.
- tracker1 7y agoIf you're buying from retail and re-selling at over 4x the purchase cost, that's gouging... not even wholesale pricing, but retail.
- geofft 7y agoFor the most part, CVS isn't producing it, they're reselling it. I agree it doesn't matter which reseller is gouging, but it does matter to me whether I'm paying a markup to someone who was clever enough to hoard important goods (and thereby incentivizing hoarding) or whether I'm paying for increased cost of production (and thereby incentivizing production). Markets are a way of managing information. That's why things like "the stock market went up" or "the stock market went down" matter: it communicates what people believe about whether things are underpriced or overpriced. In turn, those beliefs are only worth paying attention to if participants have some reasonable information about the things they're buying and selling. While my individual purchase of a $50 bottle of hand sanitizer is a small drop in a bucket of information, it is conveying information, and everyone else paying for it absolutely does influence the market. When we communicate that we're willing to pay $50 for a bottle of hand sanitizer even if the cost of production has not gone up, it tells resellers that they should start hoarding. A clever reseller will stop selling their reserves entirely and wait for discovered prices to max out. That does matter quite a bit to me as a buyer!
- erik_seaberg 7y agoMaybe if the gouging limit were higher than 10%, CVS could have filled an extra warehouse with Charmin and Purell last year just in case.