5 ms·
Your comment about not being older than 60 to get tested made me so angry and shows how fucked the US is. Testing has nothing to do with protecting you (the cur
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
Your comment about not being older than 60 to get tested made me so angry and shows how fucked the US is. Testing has nothing to do with protecting you (the current treatment for Covid-19 is the same as any other severe respiratory illness), it's about deciding who needs to be quarantined and have their contacts tracked to protect other people. While the severity of symptoms varies by age, the transmissibility does not.
The numbers are many multiples of what is being reported.
- Vinnl 7y agoAs I understand it, in GP's case it's already clear that the decision should be to quarantine without needing a test. Additionally, at least were I live, the number of cases has gotten so big that it has become unfeasible to track their contacts. Thus, there's not much use in testing.
- Yetanfou 7y ago> Your comment about not being older than 60 to get tested made me so angry and shows how fucked the US is I live in the (presumed) social democratic paradise of Sweden where the "government" has just decided to stop testing anyone who is not already in a hospital and belongs to a risk group, i.e. anyone under ~65 years of age without any co-morbidities [1 - Swedish]. The "state epidemiologist" Anders Tegnell has other wisdom to spread to the world like the fact that a call for as many companies to have as many employees as possible working from home is "problematic" because it ends up exposing some people to more risk of infection than others and thus offset the principle of "fairness" in society [2 - Swedish]. In other words, if we can not lower the risk of exposure for everyone we should not lower the risk for anyone. He is also against school closures because children can not get infected - oh, they can? OK, because children don't get very ill - but they'll still spread the infection to those who can get very ill? OK, because some children don't have it all that nice at home so it would not be fair to them to close the schools. Again, if we can not make it better for everyone it is preferable to not do anything at all. Sweden is now coming under heavy criticism from other countries, China being one of them [3 - Swedish] when they state "Sweden has capitulated in front of the virus and stands to become a danger to other countries". This is probably part of an ongoing spat between Sweden and China where Sweden earlier criticised China's actions against a Chinese-Swedish citizen but there is no denying that the Swedish "government" has shown a lack of foresight and proactive strategies. There is a dearth of supplies, Sweden has the lowest number of hospital beds per capita in the OECD which is odd for the country with the highest taxes in the world, the health care system can not cope with the normal case load let alone with an influx of Corona-related patients. [1] https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/samhalle/a/70GQRV/nya-strategin--slutar-rakna-exakta-antalet-coronafall https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/samhalle/a/70GQRV/nya-str... [2] https://nyheteridag.se/tegnell-ojamlikt-att-spotifys-anstallda-far-jobba-hemma/ https://nyheteridag.se/tegnell-ojamlikt-att-spotifys-anstall... [3] https://www.svd.se/kina-riktar-skarp-coronakritik-mot-sverige https://www.svd.se/kina-riktar-skarp-coronakritik-mot-sverig...
- ramblerman 7y agoWhat an incredible imbecilic position. Of course, it's not fair that doctors and nurses, and supply chain drivers, pharmacy workers etc... can't stay home. But that is precisely why the ones who can, office workers, should stay home. For them! We are in this together. This guy should absolutely resign, apparently when asked to do so here is his response (link 2) > No. It is clear that if someone who is considered more competent than I am at dealing with this will come to accept that situation. But I think this is really fun. It sounds a bit strange, but it's a big challenge, a fantastic challenge with this kind of work. Guy sounds like an absolute moron.
- Cerium 7y agoI would argue that the most fair thing I can do is stay home. It is the most good I can do society, as each person at home is one less infection path for those who cannot stay at home.
- bjourne 7y agoAnother "I'm a Swede and I hate my country" poster. I'm also Swedish so I know what you write is 100% bullshit and parroted from a bunch of right-wing sites. The reason why not everyone is offered testing is because healthcare is very accessible and free in Sweden (like it is in Denmark, Norway, and Germany too) meaning that you can't offer it to everyone who wants it. Because if you did, you would have to pointlessly test a million hypochondriacs with symptoms that have nothing to do with corona just for the sake of it. For one view on how well countries handle the epidemic, look at the fatality rate. US: 49/2195 = 2.2%, Germany: 5/3062 = 0.16%, Sweden: 2/867 = 0.23%, Norway: 1/996 = 0.10%, Frane: 79/3667 = 2.2%.
- cannabis_sam 7y agoOh dear, another ”the swedish government is never wrong! (Even if I have to make up the rationalization myself)” I’m Swedish/Norwegian, and the governments have responded pretty differently. How do you know that sweden is correct and not norway/denmark?
- 7y ago
- huffmsa 7y agoIf you have a fever and a wet chesty cough, you should be planting your ass on the sofa with Gatorade and fever meds. Regardless of what's causing your symptoms. If you're having increased trouble breathing, you should see a hospital.
- aufav36 7y ago> Your comment about not being older than 60 to get tested made me so angry and shows how fucked the US is. This is not US-only. Here in Austria there are very strict rules on whom to test, and age is a big factor as well as having symptoms or not. Local authorities do decide on a case-by-case basis, and getting a test if you are not showing symptoms is really hard. But on the other hand by taking these measures they try to not overwhelm the testing-labs, as they struggle to keep up with the demand for tests and want to keep the reporting-time as low as possible. A couple of days ago test results came back the next day, now (Saturday) they seem to slip to 3 days or more. So restricting who get's a test and who doesn't seems like a good idea to begin with.
- beeforpork 7y agoHow did South Korea manage to ramp up the testing so quickly? They did a vast amount of tests, and test results constantly came back quickly. What is needed to do the same?
- luddaite 7y agoTesting should be reserved for situations where the outcome of the test will change management. One such situation is whether or not the patient should be quarantined. Another situation is whether or not medical management will be affected (send home vs admit vs ICU). If someone is going to self quarantine regardless, maybe testing isn't appropriate.
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22574772 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22574772.