3 ms·
TL;DR: Author makes some straw-man arguments against the famous two-curves infographic and suggests that we need authoritarian containment measures: > Flatteni
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
TL;DR: Author makes some straw-man arguments against the famous two-curves infographic and suggests that we need authoritarian containment measures:
> Flattening the curve is not an option for the United States, for the UK or Germany. Don’t tell your friends to flatten the curve. Let’s start containment.
We've reached the point in the Coronavirus news cycle where the contrarian opinions are competing for clicks. Flattening the curve and increased containment in highly infected areas are not mutually exclusive.
"Flatten the curve" may not be the 100% perfect solution, but it has been very effective at communicating the goals to the average person. The author tries to pick the popular two-curves infographic apart as if it was a scientifically accurate graph. It's not. It's a tool to quickly communicate an idea and encourage people to institute self-containment measures. For that purpose, it's working very well.
- groby_b 7y agoAuthor is so well-versed in epidemiology that they don't even understand the difference between containment and mitigation. If tech bros could stop with their "I've seen exponential growth, I know exponential growth" articles and let the voice of actual experts come through, that'd be lovely.
- burlesona 7y agoCame here to post basically the same thing. A lot of people are angry because containment hurts them economically, potentially severely, and they see that as worse than “getting a bad flu.” The “flatten the curve” narrative seems to have been effective in getting through to those folks why we need containment now.
- zaroth 7y agoWhat an interesting interpretation of the "flatten the curve" pitch! It almost succeeds in making me less disappointed in the whole flat curve thing. To think that all along, it's just a sales technique to get people to participate in a social exercise. And even it's working very well for that purpose! Hmm... IMO, "flatten the curve" is wrong for the same reasons that TFA is wrong. They take numbers with no scientific basis, misapply them to the general population, extrapolate based on an exponential function, and as a result end up predicting the end of modern life as we know it. I'm just going to go out on a limb and propose (and this is directed at TFA not OP), that if your model predicts the end of the world, feel free to stand on the corner with a sign, but perhaps refrain from writing a Medium post as if people should actually listen to you.