4 ms·
Can anyone who has watched the whole thing give a summary for those of us not sure if we should dedicate a full 90 minutes to this?
by londons_explore 7y ago
Can anyone who has watched the whole thing give a summary for those of us not sure if we should dedicate a full 90 minutes to this?
- tgpc 7y agohumans: go is hard. machines will never be able to play at the highest level. machines: I have won humans: oh
- gwern 7y agoI've been reflecting on exponentials and humans in light of coronavirus. AlphaGo showed the same dynamic: I don't know if everyone remembers, but before the Lee Sedol tournament, most 'sensible' 'respectable' people assumed that there was no way AlphaGo would win, any claims it would stomp Lee Sedol were hyperbolic AI alarmism, and the only question was whether DeepMind would be saved from acute embarrassment by eking out one victory over Lee Sedol or if he would simply clean the board with AG. And in the absolute worst-case scenario, it might be a fairly even match. After all, anyone could look at the Fan Hui vs AG games which were released a few months before and see that AG was really crappy, hardly even human pro level; Lee Sedol wouldn't break a sweat. Yes, it would improve if they trained it more and tweaked it more, but so what? There were so many ELO points between Fan Hui and Lee Sedol, and AIs lack human intuition. Just drawing a line is mindless curve-fitting, which sensible respectable people know better than to do. Meanwhile, people like Eliezer Yudkowsky considered the training time and thought through the exponential graph, and concluded that, given all those months between Fan Hui and the tournament and the fact that DM was willing to do the tournament at all with so much money on the lines, AG would either lose terribly or could well go 5-0. As it happens, his prediction was wrong. It actually went 4-1, because Lee Sedol got lucky and accidentally triggered a 'delusion' (fixed in AlphaZero). We went from 'the best MCTS might be somewhat competitive with a very low-ranked human pro head-on' to 'superhuman' in a matter of months, because AG performance scaled with compute. We've seen similar capability leaps with DoTA2 or SC2: the best non-cheating AI was so low level it basically didn't exist (DoTA2) or was nowhere near competitive with any pros (SC2) and then within a few months of finding a working architecture (compare Oriol Vinyal's demo at Blizzcon to the matches just a few months later with SC2 pros), they reach better-than-most-pro levels even if they are not strictly superhuman yet. That's all fun and games when it's just board games or computer games, of course...
- roenxi 7y agoThat wasn't quite the dynamic; the version that played against Fan Hui was pretty good. That would have been more than enough to claim that the AI was highly competitive against human professionals. The surprise was that it was assumed that Neural Nets would scale exponentially like other computer projects - over the medium term, with a requirement to rewrite the program to take advantage of new hardware opportunities. The idea that the same program + 6 months could scale exponentially was pretty radical even to people who knew a lot about computers. I was certainly surprised because I'd made the assumption that AlphaGo could scale exponentially with improvements in graphics cards as opposed to exponentially with Google's commitment of computer hours. Obviously wrong in hindsight, but it wasn't a misunderstanding of exponentials, it was a misunderstanding of neural nets. And we only really had one data point at the time, which was the Fan games. Couldn't even really draw a line without knowing a lot about the field.
- yazr 7y agoMy only nitpick is that AG (ML + search really) improved logarithmic-ally with exponential compute. In addition, real world domains may not be some parallizable. So yes, current AI is like a brilliant intern. It will eventually be your manager, but its gonna take a few more years ?
- okareaman 7y agoI'm assuming you don't know anything about the extremely surprising, deeply emotional and spiritual experience it was for everyone involved or you wouldn't be asking this and just watch it with fascination.
- aquarin 7y agoUnexpectedly emotional. Movie about how people feel when meeting the new technology, not about the computers.
- dntbnmpls 7y agoI don't know much about Go and my interest with Alpha is primarily with chess (alphazero). But I watched it on Netflix anyways a while back and enjoyed it. It's an interesting behind the scenes look at the lead up to the match, the match itself and the fallout. Definitely worth a watch. If you want to see alphazero games, there are a bunch of analysis of alphazero and stockfish games on youtube as well.
- nmstoker 7y agoI'd echo this. It's the same as the version on Netflix. It's not a technical deep dive (but then again, that's rare in any documentary - even the General Magic documentary didn't go into the technical aspects really). It's a human interest piece with lots of the context and interviews with key people. Obviously tastes will vary but I would recommend it to the typical HN reader.
- jasode 7y agoIt's a "human interest" type of documentary which means it's deliberately structured as an "emotional narrative". I think it's fair to say that a lot of "no-nonsense-just-give-me-the-facts" viewers in the HN demographic would find this type of film very unsatisfying. I.e. lots of interviews with virtually no technical explanations. I quickly scrubbed the film and it looks like it's the same footage from the AlphaGo documentary I saw ~2 years ago: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6700846/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6700846/ I don't know if this new video url dated "2020" is a different film or if they simply enhanced the 2017 documentary with new footage.
- okareaman 7y ago> a lot of "no-nonsense-just-give-me-the-facts" viewers in the HN demographic would find this type of film very unsatisfying I disagree with this assertion. The film explores the idea that AlphaGo, like the game of Go itself, raises a lot of questions about what it means to be human. The relationship between AI and humans is developing and a topic of intense interest, especially among the HN crowd. I think what you might be saying is people with a high IQ but low EQ might not relate to this film. I'm sitting here wondering if people like that don't find human/AI intersection interesting because they are already mostly like a computer program themselves so it's not a big deal.
- jasode 7y ago>, raises a lot of questions about what it means to be human. The relationship between AI and humans is developing and a topic of intense interest, especially among the HN crowd. We're talking about 2 different things: the importance of the topic vs the the method of exposition. You're emphasizing the topic's importance. I'm not disagreeing with that. Instead, I'm explaining that the documentary's style of exposition would be a turnoff to a subset of the HN demographic. As example showing differences in how Battle of Midway can be explained... Here's the "personality-driven" type of history documentary. Scrub the video and you'll see there's a lot of video showing the narrators walking around the beach and flying in helicopters: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wo9wrUcb8jI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wo9wrUcb8jI To be fair, some viewers need attractive people talking to the camera to make history "interesting". What does an attractive man walking along the beach have to do with explaining strategy and tactics at Midway?!? Nothing. Maybe some viewers need "eye candy" to go along with their medicine of history. Basically, all of The History Channel is structured as personality-driven type of documentaries with a human-interest angle. Compare that to another style of delivery with no video of talking heads but has a voice-over with maps and higher information content: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bd8_vO5zrjo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bd8_vO5zrjo If HN viewers want the 2nd style of documentary for AlphaGo, this thread's url is not it. The importance of "what it means to be human" is orthogonal to the method of explanation.