4 ms·
I find the Amiga graphics are the nicest, then the Jaguar, then the 3DO's are so terrible and overwrought I never would have liked this game if this was the fir
by the_af 7y ago
I find the Amiga graphics are the nicest, then the Jaguar, then the 3DO's are so terrible and overwrought I never would have liked this game if this was the first version I played.
Nostalgia? Maybe. But I find the minimalist polygon graphics of the original a big part of what made Another World a big hit. At least to me. In my mind this is related to the concept of "closure" as described in "Understanding Comics": the more abstract, more symbolic the graphics, the more my mental processor can give it hyperrealistic meaning in my mind; conversely, the more detailed the graphics, the less interesting they become and the less room for my mind to "complete" them. The beast as a black outline with eyes and fangs is terrific (and terrifying). The beast as a more detailed rendition would probably just look silly.
Plus, you know, the polygon graphics look objectively cool ;)
- trav4225 7y agoI know exactly what you mean! This is why, to me, the text adventure genre was always so fantastic.
- vidarh 7y agoI was an Amiga user, and I certainly can see why you prefer it, but the Jaguar ones look great as well (something I'd never have admitted to back in my Amiga days when Atari was "the enemy") - it feels like pixel art made for the resolution. The problem with the 3DO one to me is that it looks like it was just downsampled from a high resolution image rather than was being drawn for the resolution it was rendered at.
- noizejoy 7y ago> back in my Amiga days when Atari was "the enemy" To the best of my recollection that was the first major fanboi war in computers, also amplified by the advent of pre-internet online community in the form of BBSs (Bulletin Board Systems). I fondly remember accessing GEnie[0] from my trusty Atari 1040ST (my first home computer, since it had midi builtin). However, I have to admit, the whole fanboi thing struck me as silly, since Amiga’s were graphically superior, while Atari ended up attracting midi developers and users. Not until much later did I realize, that in marketing terms, a fanboi war may very well benefit both sides. So while I still shake my head at fanboi posts, I also see why manufacturers like those wars. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEnie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEnie
- ngold 7y agoI was always surprised at how Amiga went under the radar during apples 2e and Microsoft dos days.
- vidarh 7y agoCommodore destroyed their dealer network in the US by mistreating them during the C64 days. The worst probably being Jack Tramiels parting shot as Commodore CEO when he cut recommended retail prices overnight without warning dealers or offering any refunds/discounts to deal with the massive drop in the value of their inventory he caused. Conversely in Europe where local Commodore subsidiaries did well in many countries, Apple was a tiny presence most places until the Mac. I pretty much lived in the local computer stores in Norway in the 80s and never saw any Apple 2 variant for example. Apple was a non-entity to me, even though I knew of obscure brands like Dragon and Enterprise 64. Commodore dominated the home computer market in Norway, with Atari, Spectrum and Amstrad following shortly after, and a variety of smaller players.. Once the Mac arrived, one store nearby had a single one on display in the corner. These things varied greatly by country.
- pjmlp 7y agoTo add to vidarh's testimony, in Portugal Apple devices were sold by Interlog, they had two offices across the two main cities Porto and Lisbon. So no one one islands would get to see one, and on main land it required actually driving down to those shops to see them, or you would eventually see an ad on a computer magazine and eventually schedule a delivery to your place, that could take several weeks. On top of that they were very pricey versus the competition, which was already quite expensive for average Portuguese salary. So the only place you would actually see Apple live would be in some computer lab at the top universities. Regarding DTP, most companies were using Atari or Amigas for it.
- TomVDB 7y agoTo the best of my recollection that was the first major fanboi war in computers, ... Definitely not the first major one! I fondly remember endless back and forth discussions between proponents of the magnificent Commodore 64 and adherents of the despicable ZX Spectrum.
- noir_lord 7y agoI think it’s the same as the effect of a really good book and a really good tv film adaptation. I can count on one hand where the TV/Film adaptation lived to my imagination - most recently been the expanse and altered carbon both of which absolutely nailed the source material.
- aquova 7y agoI'm torn in the middle, but I don't totally agree. I had never seen the 3DO version before now, but I really like how it evolves on the original layout. I think the artwork is really interesting and "other worldly" while still retaining some of the abstractness. Now, part of this might be due to being familiar with the original, and having an exciting alternate version to see, I'm not sure if the game would be as notable without the polygon aesthetic.