3 ms·
I'm not so sure that "reasonable people who did the right thing" is an accurate characterization. The Museum of the Bible has a lot of controversy regarding the
by jfengel 7y ago
I'm not so sure that "reasonable people who did the right thing" is an accurate characterization. The Museum of the Bible has a lot of controversy regarding their acquisition of artifacts. The company paid a large fine for trying to acquire materials looted from Iraq. Their cover-up obfuscated the origins of the material, reducing its value to archaeology by destroying context.
They put these artifacts in their catalog; it was outside researchers who declared them forgeries. How many other pieces in their catalog are also forgeries, but don't have sufficiently high profile to be forced to check their acquisition?
So I'm dubious when they claim victimhood. Scholars only want the material because of its context. The lack of context was the first clue to outsiders that they were in fact forgeries. Why didn't they know?
They seem to want to acquire these objects more as trophies than as scholarship, and are willing to cut corners on provenance to achieve that. They present themselves as scholars but act more like a cross between treasure hunters and religious fanatics.
- creddit 7y agoThey were trying to cover up attempts at acquiring legitimate artifacts? Seems like OP is right; they are trying to acquire legitimate materials and that it is most likely they got duped.
- jfengel 7y agoWikipedia has an entry for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hobby_Lobby_smuggling_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hobby_Lobby_smuggling_scandal If this were a one-off thing, this might indeed be a non-story. But it fits a pattern of them putting collecting over scholarship. It casts doubt on their entire catalog, and makes it look as if they fund conferences as a fig leaf to grant them unearned scholarly authority. It may not mean anything to techies at Hacker News, but within the circles of archeology and biblical study, it's a warning that people should reconsider their relationship to the museum.
- creddit 7y agoI'm familiar with the scandal. I'm just saying that it points more toward the museum having been actually duped. They are clearly interested in getting genuine artifacts given the lengths they are willing to go to obscure shady provenance.
- lostlogin 7y ago> scandal Scandals - numerous. Buying dubious pieces that have been stolen or faked shouldn’t be taken as a good thing. This logic isn’t applied to real museums luckily.
- jfengel 7y agoIt's a practice real museums have mostly stopped. There's enormous controversy about what they should do with their existing ill-gotten gains -- most prominently the Parthenon Marbles in the UK, but that's just the lid on a massive can of worms. (There are rumors that Greece will hold up any trade deal the UK wants to make with the EU until they give the pieces back, and expect all hell to break loose in the museum world after that.) The Bible Museum reflects a cultural attitude the celebrates the imperial age, when rich countries just took what they wanted from poor ones. There are a lot of people in those rich countries who want that back.
- jfengel 7y agoAh, I see. That makes sense. I see their willingness to accept artifacts of dubious provenance as part of an overall pattern of having things other than scholarship at the top of their agenda. But yes, I do think they'd prefer genuine artifacts when available -- even if that destroys provenance information. If they cared more about provenance, they'd be less likely to be duped, and it makes it hard for me to see them as purely a victim.
- creddit 7y ago> If they cared more about provenance, they'd be less likely to be duped, and it makes it hard for me to see them as purely a victim. Fair point. I don't doubt their propensity to be duped is rather high due to self-imposed biases.
- lowdose 7y agoGenuine question, what is the overlap of archeology and biblical studies?
- waynecochran 7y ago> “Honestly, I’ve never worked with a museum that was so up-front,” Loll says. It doesn't sound like they were trying to hide anything.
- jfengel 7y agoThey clearly did hide things with their previous scandal about smuggled Iraqi artifacts. In this case it was less about hiding things and more about their desire to acquire showy artifacts being more important than authenticity or scholarship.
- James_Henry 7y agoThere isn't a ton of evidence that they weren't just naive with the Iraqi scandal. Also, they seem to have changed a lot for the better as explained by the last section of the article. They seem to be handling what have clearly been a great number of serious consequences due to previous mistakes, and sure, maybe initial greediness, with great integrity now. I quoted some of the article that points this out lower in the comments as well.
- riversflow 7y agoThey’d already been very[1] publicly[2] caught out on housing likely forgeries. That Nova documentary says (I believe verbatim) that some of the fragments they bought were “too good to be true”, one particular example I recall was a few lines that are often quoted together but quite far apart with significant context in between, that somehow ended up on the same fragment. Overall the documentary makes a compelling case that the forgers started small but evolved into targeting groups who were unreasonably gullible. Given the Museum of the Bible’s history of being unscrupulous historians I think they have it coming rather than being victims. [1]2019 November https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/dead-sea-scroll-detectives/?linkId=76304928 https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/dead-sea-scroll-detectiv... [2]2018 October https://www.livescience.com/63895-dead-sea-scroll-fakes.html https://www.livescience.com/63895-dead-sea-scroll-fakes.html
- mannykannot 7y agoWhile the museum - or just its main sponsors - have acted badly in other cases, this does not seem to be so here. On the other hand, an entity that conducts shady business is an attractive target for a con artist, who may be able to exploit its willingness to look the other way in duping it.