3 ms·
> What's the lesson here? It seems clearly incorrect and foolhardy to conclude that pandemics are good for health. Again I emphasize that the effects calculate
by Apocryphon 7y ago
> What's the lesson here? It seems clearly incorrect and foolhardy to conclude that pandemics are good for health. Again I emphasize that the effects calculated above are just the health benefits of the air pollution changes, and do not account for the many other short- or long-term negative consequences of social and economic disruption on health or other outcomes; these harms could exceed any health benefits from reduced air pollution. But the calculation is perhaps a useful reminder of the often-hidden health consequences of the status quo, i.e. the substantial costs that our current way of doing things exacts on our health and livelihoods.
- zaroth 7y agoI’m not sure that’s a valid way to do the calculation. A net benefit is not a cost. A net benefit is a benefit. A proper analysis looks at costs and benefits together and calculates the net result. There are inherent damages (externalities) to the way that we do things, but the correct analysis is to examine the substitute ways to do things and what their relative (increased) costs are in exchange for decreases damages. So you can say we can reduce A amount of pollution, which is expected to save B lives, at an increased cost of C, which drives D amount of people into unemployment or poverty. Looking at one thing without examining the overall effect on the whole system is pretty pointless, even inhumane to a point.