8 ms·
A Vacancy Has Been Detected (2019)
- Aloha 7y agoThis is why systems like this ought to have reason codes, each reason code should have a different friendly message sent to the user.
- whatshisface 7y ago"Your status is CODE 444: DEATH OF ROOMMATE. Please report to the campus housing administration so that your dead roommate may be replaced with a live one. Go Lions!"
- john-radio 7y agoNailed it, zero notes.
- lostlogin 7y ago> CODE 444 I think a ‘410: Gone’ might be better.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gherig4 7y agoThat email seems very human and reasonable and it did its job perfectly. It warned the student of a potential outcome and the student was able to act on that warning. The alternative of somebody moving in one day without warning would be the real fail case and that didn't happen.
- khawkins 7y agoI agree it was reasonable, but it was written such that it was very recognizable as a non-human automated system response. I'd make the case that the message should go even further to seem like a robot, because few empathise with mindless automatons. For the same reason, it's not clear that serious emotional damage occurred. It wasn't cruel or unsympathetic, it was a machine going through its motions. I think it was a simple oversight on behalf of system administrators.
- ska 7y agoThere are multiple failure cases. It certainly could have been worse. On the other hand, it obviously could have been handled better. I suspect the only "right" way to handle things like this is by the automated system having certain pathways that require human interaction for edge cases. That way "student X dropped out" and "student Y died" can be treated differently without needing a workaround or complaint. If the system tracking dorm allocations notes a vacancy, it can also note "but I can't handle this one" and assign appropriately.
- SilasX 7y agoAt risk of sounding like a jerk, I agree and think this whole reaction is overblown. A vacancy has been opened up. That will trigger numerous consequences across the system. Yes, every time you observe such consequences, you will be reminded of its cause -- the roommate's death. But it's unrealistic to expect every other subsystem not to do anything that reminds you of that death, which, as far as I can tell, is the extent of this email's "wrongdoing". "Woe is me, how dare you, the housing system, refer to my roommate's death as just another vacancy." Come on, now.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoIt wasn't me, it's the computer that did it, that excuse is as old as dirt. There is that version of the Monty Python "Dead Bishops" skit, where the murderer says "It was me, but society is at fault." Consequently the Church Policeman asks all the other people present: "Excuse me, are you a member of society?" - "Yes." - "Come with me, then."
- SilasX 7y agoBut the "it" here is "tell you the consequences of the vacancy". The "wrongdoing" is reminding the author of the roommate's death (which is out of the control of anyone who communicates to him about the vacancy). A human would do the exact same thing (to the extent of telling you about that), so nothing is being excused by virtue of the computer doing it.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoThe problem is with the wording. The "Friendly Campus System" "detected a vacancy". In the face of a sudden, unprepared death you offer condolences and give the bereaved person the customary 30 days. The email from the blogpost is completely inappropiate. Mortality in college students is something around 15 in 100000, a campus of 10000 can expect a student death per year. It's surprising that there were no processes in place to act appropiately in that situation.
- 7y ago
- paiute 7y agoPerhaps the "Go Lions!" valediction is insensitive, but that's all.
- domador 7y agoI disagree. Both the email and the alternative you mentioned sound callously insensitive to me. The school should not let either of these situations take place. This notice and the handling of the housing situation should have gone to a properly-trained school administrator handle with sensitivity.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoI agree. This is a perfectly appropriate notification. Its impossible to design systems to be beholden to everyones feelings.
- Animats 7y agoYes. Now a bad response would have been: "A vacancy has been detected. As you are now a single person occupying a double room, you will now be billed at the higher single-occupancy rate for a double. Payment must be made by the end of the month."
- nicholassmith 7y ago> That email seems very human Does it? If a human composed and made the decision to send an email to a student who's roommate had recently taken their own life and said "we've detected a vacancy" there would be some serious questions asked around their emotional capacity.
- st1ck 7y agoWhere did you get the bit about suicide? I was rather frustrated that author didn't bother to explain the cause of death.
- nicholassmith 7y agoDelayed, it was my takeaway from unfortunately having read far too many announcements in similar language. I could be entirely wrong, it might have been a sudden health condition.
- khendron 7y agoI don't think it is the existence of the email but rather the wording of it that is at fault. The email was cold, soulless, and underscored the fact that "the system" viewed the residents as inventory, not people. I am reminded of the automated email I received from my company's HR software, just prior to my summer intern going back to school. The email asked if I had run through the checklist for the pending "termination" of my "resource". I went to the HR director and was like "WTF, can't we inject a little humanity into Human Resources?" She just shrugged it off, saying the emails were built into the system.
- lostcolony 7y agoHow about the alternative of alerting a person, who can then inquire as to why the vacancy? Or even, given that the person was expected to come back (it was Christmas break that they passed), the system allow for _why_ the person will not be coming back, and an option as to whether to seek to fill the vacancy, or keep it empty? But that's neither here nor there either. This isn't necessarily about "what could the system have done better in this situation". It's highlighting that software ultimately leads to inhuman interactions; no person would have come in and said that. In fact, no person would know about the vacancy, without also knowing the reason for it (without either a system, which again highlights the problem, or another person, who would have explained the circumstances, being the one to deliver that information to them). And that's something we can work to improve, even if we can't address every possible instance.
- smoyer 7y agoSorry for your loss (Kelly) ... I was also a (Nittany) Lion and had a similar experience but it wasn't software based. In my second year, a good friend of mine was killed in a car accident. She was a year ahead of me (and not in a STEM curriculum) but we ended up having three BDRs (Basic Degree Requirements - now GenEd at PSU) together that semester. In all three of those classes, no one told the professor what had happened and, knowing I was her friend (we sat together, worked on group projects together and left the room together), they naturally asked me where she was. That was a pretty tough question for an otherwise macho (the term at the time) 19 year-old to answer. I grew up pretty stoic (PA Dutch family - non-Amish) but here I sit 30+ years later and tear up a bit recounting this time of my life.
- hinkley 7y agoThere are some cultural groups in North America where, in a time of crisis like this, Standard Operating Procedure is to bring food and company and let the affected person chose when or if to talk. You just sit and do something else, and if they need anything you're there, and if they want to talk about it they can, but they don't have to if they don't want to. It comes up as a joke trope in some movies, but I grew up around that sort and it's not inherently bad. It has a way of avoiding scenarios like the one you illustrated. I recall I was fairly young and we lost a family pet, and every time someone tried to console me by bringing it up it was like a doctor palpating an injury. Yes, we know it hurts, why are you touching it!? It felt a bit like it was happening all over again. It felt, to be honest, a bit cruel. If I had been in your situation, at that age, I might have written it down on a piece of paper, so I only had to get through admitting they were gone the one time on someone else's terms.
- domador 7y agoIt's hard for me to think of a situation where a dorm-room vacancy-notification email to a student would be a good idea. I can think of only sad situations that would produce a vacancy, in addition to the one in the article (for example, someone having to quit or pause college due to a family crisis, or running out of money to pay for college, or flunking out.) At best, this kind of email should go to a college employee to look into the matter, not to a student occupying the room. This aspect of their system was not designed with much empathy in the first place. Dorm rooms should not be treated as warehouses to be filled with inventory. At the very least a manual override was available.
- bil7 7y agoisn't dropping out far more likely than a sad event?
- domador 7y agoIsn't dropping out also a bit sad? (Or sometimes very sad?)
- lnanek2 7y agoI suppose, but in this case the author fought for and got a free upgrade - he got to live in a single for the price of a double using his roommate's death as the reasoning. If the roommate had dropped out it's unlikely the author could have pulled that off since there is less claim to being emotionally unable to accept a roommate that the college has to accommodate.
- SilasX 7y ago>It's hard for me to think of a situation where a dorm-room vacancy-notification email to a student would be a good idea. I can think of only sad situations that would produce a vacancy, in addition to the one in the article (for example, someone having to quit or pause college due to a family crisis, or running out of money to pay for college, or flunking out.) Not true, this happened to me because my roommate found a different dorm hall he preferred and requested a move to it. (Similarly, deciding that you'd rather be in an apartment off campus.) Hey, maybe that was, in part, driven by how he couldn't stand me. Still, not something I'd call "sad".
- tlb 7y agoPart of the problem is the uncanny valley of emails that look human-written, but aren’t. Nobody expects, eg, a piece of hospital equipment to display empathy when a patient dies. It can just beep and display HR 000. But people expect an email that’s not obviously a form to be composed with empathy for the receiver. So you can improve it with either more empathy or more automated-form design.
- strken 7y agoYes. I think it would have been much less offensive if the "Go Lions!", "Dear XYZ", the explanation of not enough rooms, and "Sincerely, Your Friendly Campus System" had been removed. "A vacancy has been detected in your room. You may be reassigned a roommate. Visit foobar.com/roommate-assignment for details, or get in touch with the campus housing team at 1234567890."
- dudzik 7y ago> So you can improve it with either more empathy or more automated-form design. I work on a CI system that supports an app with more than 150000 tests. At that size we have to remove tests to manage intermittent test failures. In the beginning we were removing those tests manually and developers would argue with us a lot. Especially about the methodology that we used to determine that a test is intermittently failing. Since we switched to a bot the arguments stopped. I guess it seems less arbitrary if an automated system disables tests rather than an human.
- aj7 7y agoDid they add a death bit and a test?
- devchix 7y agoThis is a log output message. The problem with logs is that they are first and primarily written for the developer. I'm writing the alert for the condition I need to know about. It's only as an afterthought that they are revised to be read by not-developer and bear some semblance of communicating an event or status. This is why most logs, especially the debug kinds, are inscrutable. Devs may eventually put in logs for other people, but unless thought is put into who will consume the log and what the expected actions would be, the original logging text remains. The human who wrote the automated text was probably coding toward identifying vacancy. Aha! Vacancy detected! What's more natural than coding that into the alert message? That person is probably not thinking about the death of a student, a less frequent event than graduating, moving, whatever. I get what the author is trying for, there are actually heartless automatic messages involving actual death or traumatic events. This is not those. I'm not thinking about how to not inadvertently hurt someone's feelings when I'm writing logs, it's first written in a very confined objective for me.
- Thorrez 7y agoI think the title of the post is slightly misleading. The title is in the passive voice > A Vacancy Has Been Detected Whereas the email is in the active voice > We have detected a vacancy in your room The active voice sounds a bit more personable and less robotic.
- jeffadotio 7y agoThis is a similar story about automation mishaps. It was posted here and I heard the story on NPR. https://idiallo.com/blog/when-a-machine-fired-me https://idiallo.com/blog/when-a-machine-fired-me
- xen0 7y agoI think a nice, less charged example of this was given by Tom Scott's video on being called regarding STI results - an automated system couldn't give him his results and so transferred him to a human with the delays and brief panic that entails. https://youtu.be/LZM9YdO_QKk https://youtu.be/LZM9YdO_QKk
- afandian 7y agoIt's a terrible situation to be in. The correct answer to this is, by definition, thinking about User Experience. But unless it's actually rigorous it's just as bad, or worse, than not having it. I use Expensify at work. It's clear that thee UX team consider a 'cutesy' UI to be a higher priority than a functional user experience. Many workflows are horribly broken (race conditions, dialogs with missing pieces, broken links). And it's CRUD for expenses, how hard can it be? And then infantile messages like "whoops! Looks like something's up with xyz" and emojis everywhere. Messages like "relax, your expenses are done" with hammock pictures. It's infuriating after I took hours to input a dozen receipts. I'd rather have a precise functioning tool. Tell me which receipts had which issues, or what needs my attention. I'm all for minimising human discomfort, but sometimes the cure is worse than the disease!
- RyJones 7y agoWe use Expensify and I often wonder if any adults work there.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoA family member of mine works enterprise sales for a major bank's CC group, and showed me their interface. It's a blast from the past. But apparently that's why they're so successful, it gets the job done and has been honed in terms of UX for almost 25 years.
- caseyf7 7y agoAnd Expensify is even worse for the administrators. One of the worst admin experiences in SaaS.
- mercwear 7y agoThis is a sad situation because of a death taking place. That said, I do not personally believe there is anything wrong with the email other than the wording. Automation exists in all parts of our lives and sometimes an outcome like this will occur.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI notice the author doesn't even pitch any improvements like writing their ideal version of that email. Because I think they, too, know that they are making an impossible ask. They may have even tried but realized it's too sheepish to encode some one-size-fits-all Hallmark card into an automated message of a system that simply informs you that it will be assigning you a new roommate. "Condolences!" "We [, the developer who wrote this automated message 2 years ago,] are sorry!" I think the opposite approach is better and more sincere: remove all half-attempts at sounding human from automated notifications, no pretense or deceit. Just a computer doing its job under the same expectation of empathy and understanding as your electric toothbrush.