2 ms·
Parts of the game were eliminated to give Watson a chance: audio/video clues, and categories that required extra explanation. If the exact timing of buzzing in
by gojomo 16y ago
Parts of the game were eliminated to give Watson a chance: audio/video clues, and categories that required extra explanation.
If the exact timing of buzzing in – and not 'first' but 'first after a light goes on'– gave an overwhelming advantage to Watson, that could be eliminated, too. For example, why not just 'first to buzz in'? (That is, no penalty for being early?) Let Watson's parsing of the question text race the humans' sight-reading.
It looked to me like the humans usually won the buzzer on short questions, which strongly suggests it was the slowness of reading long questions that put it on par with the humans in knowledge, and then it crushed them on buzzing-after-the-light precision.
- alanfalcon 16y agoYou can program a computer to wait until it has high confidence before buzzing in, but would you trust a human to wait to buzz in until he has already chosen his answer? In many situations, a contestant will buzz in knowing they're likely to be able to determine the answer in the five seconds they're given after being called upon. You'd be trading one player's perceived advantage for another.