2 ms·
> I disagree with assumption that year length has stayed constant the past 70 million years. It's not an assumption, it's what our best current data tells us.
by pdonis 7y ago
> I disagree with assumption that year length has stayed constant the past 70 million years.
It's not an assumption, it's what our best current data tells us. We have abundant evidence of the length of the Earth's day changing--this article is certainly not news, we have known for decades that the Earth's rotation has been gradually slowing over the past few billion years. We have no evidence of the length of the Earth's year changing significantly, and calculations agree with that (see below).
> The Earth experiences tidal friction from the Sun just like the Moon and Earth affect each other. I am guessing the year lengthening effect slower than month & day lengthening because Suns tidal force is a third of Moons.
The size of the tidal bulge on the Earth due to the Sun is about a third of that due to the Moon. But that is not at all the same as the slowing of the Earth's year due to the Sun's tides being about a third of the slowing of the Earth's day due to the Moon's tides. The situations are very, very different.
In the case of the Earth-Moon system, tidal friction causes angular momentum to be transferred from the Earth to the Moon. This slows the Earth's spin and increases the radius of the Moon's orbit.
In the case of the Earth-Sun system, tidal friction can't transfer angular momentum from the Earth's spin to the angular momentum of the Earth's orbit about the Sun, because the Earth is not orbiting itself; the mechanism that transfers angular momentum from the Earth's spin to the Moon's orbit about the Earth simply does not apply to the Earth's orbit about the Sun.
In fact, while the Sun's tidal friction does make the Earth's spin slow down a little more than it would due to the Moon alone, the result of this is to make the radius of the Moon's orbit increase a little more than it would if the Earth-Moon system were alone in space. In other words, the Sun's tidal friction simply augments the Moon's tidal friction in driving the same mechanism, transferring angular momentum from the Earth's spin to the Moon's orbit about the Earth. There is no transfer of angular momentum from the Earth's spin to the Earth's orbit about the Sun.
- pfdietz 7y ago"In the case of the Earth-Sun system, tidal friction can't transfer angular momentum from the Earth's spin to the angular momentum of the Earth's orbit about the Sun, because the Earth is not orbiting itself; the mechanism that transfers angular momentum from the Earth's spin to the Moon's orbit about the Earth simply does not apply to the Earth's orbit about the Sun." This argument cannot be correct. Suppose the sun were a point mass. It would still have tides at Earth, just like the real Sun does, but the interaction would not be able to cause any change to its spin. So, by conservation of angular momentum, if the Earth loses rotational angular momentum, that MUST be transferred to orbital angular momentum. The mechanism of course still exists. The Earth and Moon orbit each other; the Sun and Earth orbit each other. The bulge on the Earth induced by the Moon accelerates the Moon, and the bulge on the Earth induced by the Sun accelerates the Sun.
- pdonis 7y ago> The bulge on the Earth induced by the Moon accelerates the Moon More precisely, it exerts a torque on the Moon, which is equal and opposite to the torque exerted by the Moon on the bulge. So does the bulge on the Earth induced by the Sun. > the bulge on the Earth induced by the Sun accelerates the Sun. This statement is correct in principle (or more precisely, the statement that the bulge on the Earth induced by the Sun exerts a torque on the Sun), and you are right that I left it out of my previous post. Also, as I noted above, the bulge on the Earth induced by the Sun also exerts a torque on the Moon. And, for that matter, the bulge on the Earth induced by the Moon also exerts a torque on the Sun. I believe the net torque on the Sun is about 20% of the net torque on the Moon. However, that does not mean the effect on the Earth's orbit is 20% of the effect on the Moon's orbit. The relative magnitudes of the effects depend on how large the torque is compared to the relevant orbital angular momentum. Since we are working in an Earth-centered frame, that means we need to compare the Moon's orbital angular momentum around the Earth with the Sun's orbital angular momentum around the Earth. If you do the math, you find that the latter is about 300 billion times larger than the former. Multiply that by another factor of 5 (for the 20% ratio of torques) and the effect on the Earth's year is about 1.5 trillion times smaller than the effect on the Moon's month.
- pdonis 7y ago> the bulge on the Earth induced by the Sun exerts a torque on the Sun There's a further point here, though. The torque exerted on the Moon by the bulge is constant over time, because the position of the Moon relative to the bulge is constant (the bulge "leads" the Moon by a constant angle which is the result of a balance between the torque on the bulge exerted by the Moon and the pull on the bulge exerted by the Earth's spin). But the position of the Sun relative to the bulge is not constant: it goes through a complete cycle over the course of a month. So it seems to me that, at least to first order, the net torque of the bulge on the Sun over the course of a month should cancel out, so there will be no net exchange of angular momentum between the Earth's spin and the Sun-Earth orbit.